3 ms·
That’s still showing a break even around ~30$/gallon fuel costs in 2020 dollars for pure heating applications. It’s hard to reach those kinds of delivery cost
by Retric 6y ago
That’s still showing a break even around ~30$/gallon fuel costs in 2020 dollars for pure heating applications. It’s hard to reach those kinds of delivery costs. It’s even worse when you want to use RTG’s for electricity as you add complexity and lower efficiency.
- cozzyd 6y agoyes, but if you want to leave a device buried in the middle of nowhere on the ice sheet for 10 years that draws ~30W, an RTG is much simpler (only have to transport it once, no moving parts, no need for exhaust, etc.). Delivery and deployment costs to the middle of the ice sheet are not cheap.
- Retric 6y agoIf you only need 30W for 10 years then Lithium thionyl chloride batteries are a viable option down to -55C. In continuous operation waste heat will give you significant temperature leeway. That’s going to be expensive and very heavy, but there really isn’t a good option for truly remote applications. 30W is kind of the no mans land of remote power. Batteries are becoming seriously impractical, but nothing is the clear winner.
- cozzyd 6y agoI mean, outside of polar regions, solar + battery hybrids work well enough year-round. Solar + fuel cell + battery hybrids can work in Polar winter if you can transport enough fuel, but the exhaust requirement is a problem (moving parts + can't let your fuel cell + batteries get buried in the snow). The solar panels also need to be raised every once in a while (or mounted high enough in the first place). Eventually reversible fuel cells might be a good option (use excess solar in the summer to produce methanol or whatever, then consume it in winter). edit... so I need 40,000 of these: https://www.batteryjunction.com/xl-205f.html https://www.batteryjunction.com/xl-205f.html :)
- willyt 6y agoLighthouses typically shine a beam up to 20-30 miles, depends on height obviously. I would imagine the loads would be at least 1kW especially with old fashioned incandescent bulbs?
- Aperocky 6y agoIt's not hard when you're delivering fuel to one location 1000km in desolate wilderness with no road access. Your only option is basically ship borne helicopter, and then you have to make this trip semi-regularly. Plus. nuclear material are only expensive because there are not enough usage - hence the economy of scale is small. They're arguably cheaper in the Soviet Union (even if they followed market terms).
- Retric 6y agoThese where used for lighthouses which aren’t exactly useful if people stay 1000km away from them. Now for unmanned Antarctic observation or something then that’s a possibility, but hardly going to feed economies of scale. Outside the Arctic circle solar panels + batteries win hands down.
- cozzyd 6y agoAs you probably already know, RTGs were of course commonly used in Antarctic weather stations in the past, by both the US and others: https://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/104291748/radioactive-generators-powered-antarctic-science https://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/104291748/radioactive... The last was removed in 2015, as far as I know.
- marcinzm 6y agoYou're missing the autonomous part of the equation. An RTG and light will run independently with occasional checkups for decades. A gas generator will not. So now your costs have to account for a permanent local crew, sending supplies for them (food, etc.) and constructing a building they can live in. That's on top of shipping the fuel itself into the desolate location.
- Retric 6y agoThey needed to go to these lighthouses multiple times a year even with RTG’s, presumably to change bulbs etc. Truly remote areas without people don’t need lighthouses. In that context operate generator N for X hours then swap to generator N + 1 and repeat as needed. The more modern solution for even more remote areas is fuel cells which can last significantly longer between inspections.