3 ms·
By "nuclear", my understanding is that these used thermoelectric radioactive batteries, not nuclear fission reactors. Big difference. Much lower maintainence.
by dheera 6y ago
By "nuclear", my understanding is that these used thermoelectric radioactive batteries, not nuclear fission reactors. Big difference. Much lower maintainence.
(Basically you get a hunk of radioactive material that heats up from its own radiation and harvest that heat for electricity.)
- dhuk_2018 6y agoRTGs are also used on a lot of US and Russian deep space missions...
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoThe Saturn mission Cassini had 72 pounds of plutonium on it. The Pluto mission New Horizons has 24 pounds of plutonium to power itself.
- hairytrog 6y agoThe most convenient decay source is Plutonium-238 because it does not produce any gammas during the decay which would require lots and lots of shielding to protect people. It has long half life of 87 years so a reduction in power of roughly 1% per year. However, it's weapons material - not okay for wide use. This cannot be overstated. Making nuclear weapons today is very easy when you have the requisite materials (Ted Taylor of Los Alamos used to say it would take 3 guys a few months starting from scratch). With today's off the shelf timing systems, explosives, and manufacturing, it could be even faster. Next up is Strontium, but that is quite dangerous due to human uptake in the bones. And there's polonium - very poisonous and too short a half life to be used. I have heard from a friend in the business of a new concept that generates desirable isotopes specifically for decay heat sources in a reactor in an encapsulated form which gets rid of any weapons material or processing of radioactive material. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator#238Pu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_ge...
- tiku 6y agoSo why can't we have this tech with radioactive waste in our home or cars? With a proper lead shield would it be dangerous or not?
- soared 6y agoI was going to reply saying I don’t want tiny pieces of radioactive material all over my house/globe, but then realized I have a tiny explosive (battery) in my hand and littered all of my house.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYeah but when your phone battery blows you just have fire. You don't have to abandon your house because it's contaminated :)
- dheera 6y agoPeople freak out when they hear "nuclear" and "radiactive", but there are 3 types of radioactivity. Alpha and low energy beta emitters such as those used in nuclear batteries are not dangerous at all if shielded properly. In fact they are MUCH easier to shield than shielding a Lithium battery from the possibility of fire. It's gamma emitters that are much harder to shield properly.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's more complex than that in case of a failure, because ingesting an alpha or beta emitter - directly, or through the food chain - is going to be dangerous to health. Can't exactly line your intestines with lead. And while giving RTGs to general population isn't the brightest idea, it's stupid to consider these issues as a wholesale dealbreaker for nuclear technologies.
- hinkley 6y ago> Alpha and low energy beta emitters such as those used in nuclear batteries are not dangerous at all if shielded properly. Read: if there is no feasible route for them to be aspirated, ingested, or get into your eyes. Making a new device that has this property seems to be a pretty straightforward problem that we know how to do. The problem comes when an old device has been damaged or destroyed kinetically or via pyrotechnics.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoIt's still fission. Just natural decay without management to speed it up or slow it down. In reactors the fuel rods naturally decay slowly and can be sped up with neutrons. So they can be turned 'off' and adapt to changing electricity needs. But RTGS are very static. Principle is still the same though. Both decay, cause heat which is made into electricity.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoTechnically speaking, fission is defined as splitting a nucleus into large chunks, approximately half the size of the original atom. These things use radioactive decay, which is either alpha or beta particles coming out at a constant rate. Alpha and beta decay are not considered fission. (Though you'd have a reasonable case with Beryllium-8 alpha decay to Helium-4!) Spontaneous fission decay is a thing and does happen. But not enough to power any of these kinds of things.