4 ms·
Am I missing something or is this the exact opposite of what torrenting is supposed to do? Torrents are decentralized so that there is no single bottleneck and
by bambax 16y ago
Am I missing something or is this the exact opposite of what torrenting is supposed to do? Torrents are decentralized so that there is no single bottleneck and no single point of attack. Re-centralizing torrents re-creates the problem torrents were supposed to solve...?
- mikle 16y agoI don't think they are doing it to support BitTorrent... It is just a service, not a replacement. I don't see why I'd prefer to use this , but I can see a situation where it can be easier to use than a bittorent client for novice users.
- probst 16y agoI have been using put.io for quite some time. Amongst other things they also provide the option to download torrent files and convert them into mp4, just like fetch.io. For me there are several benefits with using a service like this over downloading the file directly: * I can start a download, close my laptop and go to a different location or bring it to lecture or what not, and the download continues. * If my laptop is in for service I can download and stream a show on my iPad. * It is just extremely fast. Downloading a torrent to put.io and then streaming it is in my experience much faster than downloading the torrent directly to my computer. [edit: fixed formatting]
- deno 16y agoIt might be, but you're dismissing streaming the torrent directly. If your client can use moving window to select parts—instead of just doing it randomly—you could start watching your show without waiting for 100%. This does not require support in any client other than yours (however I'd imagine you would need at least some percentage of the swarm to use similar algorithm if you want to participate when the torrent is being only just seeded). Why this is not something commonly used, outside of specific commercial clients and to aid CDN networks, is a complete mystery to me.
- cleverjake 16y agoThis is more about leeching than seeding. Torrenting is also just one of many services being offered. I presume the point is the speed. As I am currently stuck on a 3G hotspot for a connection, a GIGb connection is tempting. Especially for the natty iso.
- swah 16y agoIt may also be a solution against providers that do "traffic shaping" on torrents (pretty common in Brazil at least).
- hyperbovine 16y agoHa! I've been in Rio for a week wondering why the traffic graph in uTorrent looks like a saw blade. Obrigado!
- dedward 16y agoTHe original decentralized design of the bittorrent protocol was to stop bandwidth bottlenecks only - to let the cloud of people downloading it all also immediately start contributing to uploading to others, so the more people that start torrenting something, the more bandwidth becomes available. The only original bottleneck was the tracker. It had nothing at all todo with privacy, points of attack, or anything like that. Rememeber, most of the bittorrent legal threats aren't because you downloaded but becuase you shared - because your client also uploaded parts of the content to others as well - that's distribution.