3 ms·
The tricky question is whether twitter is in essence a public square. Arguably they've made a new space - governed by nothing but their own corporate policies.
by josephg 6y ago
The tricky question is whether twitter is in essence a public square. Arguably they've made a new space - governed by nothing but their own corporate policies.
I mean, if conversations on twitter are akin to conversations in a public park in the USA, then you would expect the same social / legal conventions to hold on twitter as in public spaces. If I incited violence in the local park, there are norms and laws that come into play. Arguably the same laws should hold on twitter. From that perspective, its weird that a tech company acts as the judge and jury - rather than the police and the courts. And complaints about censorship make total sense.
But if you think of twitter, google, facebook etc as corporate serfdoms, then there's no problem with twitter's enforcement. Twitter is a space owned and ruled by a tech company. You rent your twitter account, but own nothing. Twitter can set any rules they like, or set no rules and act entirely capriciously. The interesting question is whether or not we want the internet to work like a weird echo of the middle ages. And what (if anything) we should do about it.
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoExactly - The Voice is a crucial building block of The Cathedral. It must be free. Best summary so far on whats happening: https://twitter.com/RokoMijicUK/status/1347132644056854539 https://twitter.com/RokoMijicUK/status/1347132644056854539 EDIT another good take, reversion to feudalism: „Twitter & Facebook act as a) De facto spaces of prominent public debate b) De facto news content (press) De jure, they pretend they're in private tech business (to escape legal responsibility of a +b)“ https://twitter.com/_benoux_/status/1347155317516365826?s=21 https://twitter.com/_benoux_/status/1347155317516365826?s=21
- bergstromm466 6y ago"What I want is to see Uber’s technology become a protocol. Same with Airbnb, same with Postmates, same with other companies in the gig and sharing economies. Same with lots of other important technology companies, while we’re at it. Obviously this can’t happen overnight, but if the technology is useful enough to provide real value, then it’s too useful to be subjugated to the whims of profit forever. I would love to see these technology platforms either fully decentralised, or centralised in such a way that the entity running it is not-for-profit and, ideally, accountable to all stakeholders. The actual mechanisms for making this work are beyond the scope of this post, but I want to throw this idea out there and get people thinking about it, because it’s the only way of making the future work for all of us. I suspect — and feel free to call me naive, but I don’t think I’m wrong— that the majority of people working on Uber’s technology would prefer to build a system whose social impact they could be proud of. Based on my admittedly limited sample size of people I know in the tech industry, I feel like lots of people working at companies like Uber are there because they want to solve interesting technical challenges and deploy useful innovations in the world. I believe that if given the choice, most would prefer to build a system that makes the world a fairer and more equitable place. The problem is that this choice is, for the most part, withheld from them, and whatever individual intentions they may have are inevitably co-opted by the capitalist structure in which they make their living. By working together to counteract these prevailing systematic forces, though, they may be able to open up a space in which to envision alternatives." [1] -- Wendy Liu [1] https://medium.com/@dellsystem/dont-put-your-faith-in-uber-727b864756a4 https://medium.com/@dellsystem/dont-put-your-faith-in-uber-7...
- insert_coin 6y ago> The tricky question is whether twitter is in essence a public square. Arguably they've made a new space - governed by nothing but their own corporate policies. Public squares do not have corporate policies. Twitter has never been a public square they've always enforced speech rules from the beginnings.