6 ms·
How it could be that half of the population is deplatformed and censored when the most popular media(Fox) in that country caters for that demographic, had elect
by mrtksn 6y ago
How it could be that half of the population is deplatformed and censored when the most popular media(Fox) in that country caters for that demographic, had elected a president and the president was in power for 4 full years when the events happened, the events were organised by the said president?
What else these people demand? Not being called out for their behaviour?
What kind of platform they are looking for? What exactly could be changed to de-victimise those people?
- chroem- 6y agoPeople being relegated to digital ghettos (Parler) is not a sign of healthy discourse. This is about individuals not feeling like they can speak publicly.
- mrtksn 6y agoSure but how is this the other half’s fault? Are the other people obligated to accept lies and bigotry? What’s the plan here? Maybe the people who are into alternative facts should not annoy people who are into facts?
- newguy1234 6y agoYou have to discuss with them diplomatically instead of say "haha, dumb trumper" or something similar. There are left-wing trolls that basically do that lol and the right-wing people just leave to go to the alt-right websites instead. Why do you think there are so many of these right-wing "talk shows" on places like youtube?
- sagichmal 6y agoThis is an anachronistic view, and empirically ineffective.
- SirHound 6y agoSpeech has consequences. The snowflakes should stick to The Donald and Parler - where, by the way, I probably wouldn’t be able to speak publically.
- ng12 6y agoBut why can't they exist on the same domain as you? Reddit is federated by design, it should be equally open to right-leaning and left-leaning subs.
- newguy1234 6y agoBecause left-wing activists run reddit and they enjoy censoring the right-wing. So most get fed up and go to the alt right websites instead. Guess what they do there? "Hey have you heard about white genocide??" etc. There are even people that specifically go to reddit to encourage people to leave and go to the alt right website. It is a form of recruiting for the cause so to speak.
- maest 6y agoThere are both right and left leaning subs on reddit and it works ok. Reddit occasionally bans subreddits for various reasons (see r/fatpeplehate and the predecessor to r/hydrohomies). True, r/thedonald was banned, but not because of political leaning (r/conservative is running just fine), but because of how it was spreading misinformation and calling for violence.
- ng12 6y ago> but because of how it was spreading misinformation and calling for violence That's the rhetoric Reddit used but I was completely unconvinced. They spent the better part of a year looking for a reason to ban /r/td, going as far as to invent "quarantining" as a soft-ban, and when they finally did so the cited evidence was extremely unconvincing.
- yanderekko 6y ago>There are both right and left leaning subs on reddit and it works ok. But for any given sub that isn't political, there probably are not right and left-leaning subs. And given that viewpoint-based moderation is overwhelmingly-common on Reddit, this means that on non-politics based subreddits then engaging on any political issue as a right-leaning individual carries a decent risk of getting some sort of wrongthink ban. It's extremely common, sadly, and even though one can avoid politics entirely it's hard to just watch people circlejerk and mock people who hold your views when these issues do arise.
- cycrutchfield 6y agoThen they shouldn't have violated policies that resulted in their account getting banned. They weren't banned for their political beliefs, they were banned in large part because they were doing one of the following: doxxing, harassing, threatening, inciting violence, etc.
- belltaco 6y agoNot to mention talk radio which reaches like 50% of the population, and is a major hub of misinformation/
- bufferoverflow 6y agoFox is not a social media platform. You're arguing in bad faith. All major social networks are controlled by the left and are extremely censorious towards anything that goes against the narrative. That's Twitter, Facebook, Youtube, Instagram, Tumblr, Reddit. Remember Hunter Biden laptop story? They declared it was fake news within minutes of publication, without any verification, based on the testimony of pocket anonymous experts who thought it smelled fishy. You will end up with country more and more divided. They will create their own platforms. And then what your plan is for the information you don't like? You won't even be able to argue against it, because everyone is sitting in their huge echo chambers.
- jandrese 6y agoThe Hunter Biden laptop story was declared bullshit before it was released because the guy who provided it shipped it around to several news outlets including Fox News who initially passed because even their underused fact checking department saw that the entire story fell apart under the lightest of scrutiny. It does not serve society's interest to have blatant falsehoods broadcast as news.
- zpeti 6y agoYou’re saying that like the other side hasn’t had to endure the entire Russian conspiracy thing (Steele dossier) for years, which has been thoroughly discredited. It was shared widely and I haven’t seen any mainstream coverage when it got discredited. If you want to hold social media to certain standards, it should be across the board, not when your side benefits.
- FrozenVoid 6y ago> It does not serve society's interest to have blatant falsehoods broadcast as news. Censoring it does exactly the opposite: https://github.com/FrozenVoid/Philosophy-DB/tree/main/DigitalCulture/Censorship/Deplatforming https://github.com/FrozenVoid/Philosophy-DB/tree/main/Digita...
- leereeves 6y agoFox is the most popular single media source because it's the only (mainstream) source that "caters for that demographic". Dozens, perhaps hundreds, of other sources are actively hostile to that demographic.
- mrtksn 6y agoWhat is the argument here? Are they deplatformed unless everyone says the things they like? Breitbart, a huge network of News Corp, 4Chan, many subreddits, many youtube channels, many podcasts, radio channels etc are all dominated by those people. Does everyone have to agree with them so they don’t feel deplatformed?
- leereeves 6y ago> Deplatform: Prevent (a person...) from contributing to a forum or debate, especially by blocking them on a particular website.[1] Everytime someone is removed from a platform they've been deplatformed[2]. The existence of a few remaining platforms that aren't participating in that effort doesn't mean it doesn't exist. And don't be fooled; it is an active, organized effort whose ultimate goal is to make disagreement impossible. Hell, the term for it in the UK is "no-platform", which makes the goal quite clear. You seem to be arguing that movement doesn't exist, simply because it hasn't completely succeeded. 1: https://www.lexico.com/definition/deplatform https://www.lexico.com/definition/deplatform
- mrtksn 6y agoAre half of the US population removed from this platform? Which platform exactly are those 160 million Americans removed from?
- leereeves 6y agoPeople also feel threatened and silenced when someone else who publicly expresses their point of view is deplatformed for it. Do you really think people don't or shouldn't respond to the deplatforming of other people?