3 ms·
How can we look down on governments that have kept their country in a bogus "state of emergency" for decades to restrict rights, when the US is kept in a state
by ck2 16y ago
How can we look down on governments that have kept their country in a bogus "state of emergency" for decades to restrict rights, when the US is kept in a state of emergency to restrict rights via the "Patriot" Act for over a decade?
- cheez 16y agoYou can't. Move on. History is repeating itself. Again.
- mambodog 16y agoSmells like fatalism to me.
- roc 16y agoHow many elections have to come and go before it's clear that not enough people care? I'm not sure a sober analysis of the data can be painted with such a dismissive brush. The constitution-free zones, the airport security-theatre, the electronic surveillance-state -- no matter how many times abuses and power-creep hit the news, no-one much cares. I'm pretty much convinced now that even the limited outcry about the TSA's porno-scanners was just a media-creation to fill space in the annual travel stories around the holidays. Because they're still there. But no-one's talking about it anymore. And, honestly, we shouldn't be surprised. The Drunk-Driving laws provided plenty of data going back decades. People just don't seem to think too much about having their rights trampled in the name of 'safety'.
- grandalf 16y agoI'm still declining the backscatter scans, so the hubbub worked. I can't help it if my fellow sheep walk right through.
- potatolicious 16y agoI opted out for the first time last week in San Diego (thankfully Seattle doesn't have them at every checkpoint... yet). It was kind of disturbing. While the TSA agent that (man)handled me was polite and professional, I couldn't help but get the feeling that the patdown is designed deliberately to be overly thorough as a "lesson" taught to troublemakers like myself. What is far more disturbing than that is that in the probably ~100 people I passed security with, I was the only one that opted out. One lady got the patdown anyways after going through the Rapescan, though.
- jdp23 16y agoI took the train across the country rather than flying, and know others making similar tradeoffs. And hey, Congress defunded the next round of scanner purchases. So we are having an impact.
- smokeyj 16y agoThis message is from the Federal Cyberspace Police. Treasonous sentiment during a State of Emergency is punishable by 20 years in prison. Delete your comment or suffer the consequences.
- jdp23 16y agoSure plenty of people are talking about it -- PATRIOT Act renewal was _the_ biggest topic on blogs and Twitter in February, with opposition both on the right and left. It's just that most of the mainstream media isn't covering it.
- samlevine 16y agoMost "civilians" I speak with have an additude that if you have something to hide the government should find out what you're hiding. The government is, in my experience, obeying the will of the people here. You're not going to win this battle by getting the chattering classes to agree with you. The in-laws (or people at your place of worship, or people bowling in a non-ironic fashion) are the folks you need to convince that civil liberties protect them just as much as they protect people that they're afraid of.
- cheez 16y agoWhat is this constitution free zone? Wikipedia doesn't have anything Edit: I get it, kind of like the G20 where the only free speech zone was at home.
- w1ntermute 16y agoAny place in the country that's less than 100 miles from the border (which constitutes 2/3rds of the population) is a Constitution-free zone: http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty/are-you-living-constitution-free-zone http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty...
- cheez 16y agoThat's impressive. 1984 wasn't the Soviets, it's the US.
- cheez 16y agoIMO, it's an understanding of the nature of man in power coupled with the history of man under such circumstances.
- mannicken 16y agoThere's no reason to be fatalistic, we're all going to die sooner than we think, so.. who cares.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoThe standard method is by drawing a distinction with regards to the degree of the restrictions. In other words, the argument is that the extra powers granted by the Patriot Act are far less severe in their reach, and far more restricted in their actual use than the powers wielded by the other regimes in question. The extent of emergency powers, in law and in actual practice, vary wildly. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_emergency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_emergency provides an overview. And, 14 years is by no means a record; Israel has been in a State of Emergency since 1948, Syria from 1963 until last month, Egypt since 1967, etc.
- Andrew_Quentin 16y agoYou're trying to set a record with maintaining a state of emergency in the free world? The other standard method is by not comparing the free world with dictatorships. We can criticise both the Patriotic Act and the state of emergency in dictatorships and hold them to different standards or criticise them in different tones based on the degree of digression as compared to the values they claim they uphold and our own values.
- jsz0 16y agoI'm not sure foreign policy operates in a realm where contradictions and consistency play any major role. It's too nuanced and complex for that. Very much a case-by-case, detail-by-detail, type of situation which is subject to change at any time. (often in 4 to 8 year cycles here in the US) I think it's generally understood that the US, being the last standing super power at the moment, isn't going to be playing by the same rules as everyone else in most circumstances.
- Iris 16y agoWhat was suprising to me, is that this hasn't been the longest continuous interval in which the US was in a state of emergency. Apparently:[1] "During the Watergate scandal which erupted in the 1970s after President Richard Nixon authorized a variety of illegal acts, Congress investigated the extent of the President's powers and belatedly realized that the U.S. had been in a continuous state of emergency since 1950....The Act terminated the emergency of 1950 on September 14, 1978" So,currently only halfway through the US's longest state of emergency, which lasted 28 years. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_emergency#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_emergency#United_State...
- afterburner 16y agoGee, maybe the degree of control matters. The US still has free and fair elections, with orderly transfers of power and in general a lot of freedom and civil rights. Syria sends the army out killing unarmed people for daring to protest a crappy clan-based inherited dictatorship spanning back to the 60's, which has proven absolutely brutal in maintaining control and creates a thick atmosphere of oppression. Are you afraid for your family's physical safety if you say the wrong thing in private conversation in the US? I do still disagree with maintaining the Patriot Act though.