11 ms·
Patriot Act extended four more years, USA in fourteen year state of emergency
- shareme 16y agoLets call it what it is.. 'the FBI, TSA, CIA Job act'.. For ten years prior FBI, CIA, and TSA's predecessor were complaining that their job was too hard when forced to follow laws and court rulings. After 9-11 we got a job act pretending to be a Law enabling finding of terrorists. I submit spying on Americans is not finding terrorists.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoThis isn't so far-fetched as it seems, there is precedent. For example, following the 21st Amendment and the repeal of prohibition, we had a herd of enforcement agents who had nothing to do. This is part of what led to the National Firearms Act of 1934 -- ostensibly a tax measure (anybody could have a machine gun, as long as you were willing to pay the $200 tax). How else to explain the odd linking of unrelated products under the BATF -- the "Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms"?
- Zak 16y agoAlso interesting is that the law was upheld by the courts not because the government had the authority to regulate firearms, but because the tax was a revenue-generating measure, not a restriction or prohibition. The court conveniently ignored that the tax was sometimes more than 10 times the price of the item being taxed and therefore effectively a prohibition.
- ck2 16y agoHow can we look down on governments that have kept their country in a bogus "state of emergency" for decades to restrict rights, when the US is kept in a state of emergency to restrict rights via the "Patriot" Act for over a decade?
- cheez 16y agoYou can't. Move on. History is repeating itself. Again.
- mambodog 16y agoSmells like fatalism to me.
- roc 16y agoHow many elections have to come and go before it's clear that not enough people care? I'm not sure a sober analysis of the data can be painted with such a dismissive brush. The constitution-free zones, the airport security-theatre, the electronic surveillance-state -- no matter how many times abuses and power-creep hit the news, no-one much cares. I'm pretty much convinced now that even the limited outcry about the TSA's porno-scanners was just a media-creation to fill space in the annual travel stories around the holidays. Because they're still there. But no-one's talking about it anymore. And, honestly, we shouldn't be surprised. The Drunk-Driving laws provided plenty of data going back decades. People just don't seem to think too much about having their rights trampled in the name of 'safety'.
- grandalf 16y agoI'm still declining the backscatter scans, so the hubbub worked. I can't help it if my fellow sheep walk right through.
- potatolicious 16y agoI opted out for the first time last week in San Diego (thankfully Seattle doesn't have them at every checkpoint... yet). It was kind of disturbing. While the TSA agent that (man)handled me was polite and professional, I couldn't help but get the feeling that the patdown is designed deliberately to be overly thorough as a "lesson" taught to troublemakers like myself. What is far more disturbing than that is that in the probably ~100 people I passed security with, I was the only one that opted out. One lady got the patdown anyways after going through the Rapescan, though.
- jackowayed 16y agoRather editorialized title ...
- ck2 16y agoIt's 100% fact? 1. The Patriot Act specifically removes rights due to a declared emergency. 2. It's now extended to 14 years total. Which part is opinion?
- jackowayed 16y agoWell, editorialized may not be the best term, but you submitted with a title different from the title of the source with information that was not in the source. If you want to make that point, you should submit with the original title and then comment with the additional related information that you think is constructive to the conversation about the source.
- dexen 16y agoThe title is concisely introducing the article -- and I'm glad it is, for the original title would probably escape my attention. IMHO in this case the altered title is an advantage. From HN Guidelines: > You can make up a new title if you want, but if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it, the editors may rewrite it.
- jackowayed 16y agoBut I read the whole article and I still don't actually know what this state of emergency is. Does just having the USA PATRIOT Act mean that we're in a state of emergency? If so, is that something the bill actually says, or you interpreting that the bill is so extreme that it only makes sense in a state of emergency? Or are there provisions in it that are only ok if someone declares that we're in a state of emergency, and we've been in one ever since it passed? (Which still wouldn't be 14 years. If that's the case, then you don't know that someone won't declare that we're not in that state of emergency before the bill expires) Anyway, if the fact that I read your title means that I am more confused after reading the article than I would have been with the normal title, it is a bad title that does not fit the article. (all the you's are to the submitter) Edit: Also, the title is false. It hasn't actually been extended yet, it's just heading in that direction.
- noonespecial 16y ago"If an emergency didn't exist, it would be necessary to invent one."
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- staunch 16y agoI'd be happy if the name was at least changed to something less Orwellian.
- ck2 16y agoThe real, full title of the act is even more scary: Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct
- raquo 16y agoIs it only US public sector that is so obsessed with pretty acronyms that seem to have more meaning than their unwrapped form, or is it common in Europe too? note: I'm not from US, honest question
- ck2 16y agoPolitics loves acronyms to rally behind some vague concept. You should see some of the PAC names and referendum law names, they are often the exact opposite of what they actually aim to accomplish, very much on purpose.
- mcdoh 16y agoDigital Rights Management
- dp1234 16y agoWhen it comes to proposed US laws, the simple way to tell if the law is good or bad is as follows. If the name makes it sound like it is good for you, then it is definitely bad for you and should be voted against.
- redthrowaway 16y agoTerrorism
- 16y ago
- dhechols 16y agoFuck, fuck fuck, fuck.
- gregholmberg 16y agoThe timing of the renewal is awfully convenient -- two weeks after the death of the number one most wanted terrorist, and immediately preceding a presidential (re)election cycle. I would hope that an intelligent, accomplished US leader would not feel the need to flex military muscle and pass tough-guy legislation just to gain credibility with right wing voters.
- jdp23 16y agoThe timing's due to the three-month extension in February. With strong libertarian, progressive, and tea party opposition to the PATRIOT Act, Democratic and Republican leadership both want to remove it as a campaign issue for 2012: the House Judiciary Committee was proposing a six-year extension, and in the Senate Feinstein was proposing 2013.
- jdp23 16y agoJust a reminder: the votes haven't happened yet. So call your Representative and Senators, send them email, write on their Facebook walls, etc. etc. And tell your friends to as well. And then in 2012, remember how they voted on this -- and cast your own vote accordingly.
- RobertKohr 16y agoWhen election season comes around, go to http://www.votesmart.org http://www.votesmart.org (I just found them on google) It allows you to look up politicians and see what their voting record is. I find this more useful than anything a person says or what their political party is.
- paganel 16y agoAnd when you think that WW2 only lasted for 6 years...
- Luyt 16y agoIt's hard for anyone, governments included, to give up power. Or any advantages indeed. A small example: I remember that the Dutch government (led by a socialist PM back then) imposed a 'temporary' extra tax on gasoline: fl.0.25 extra per liter [1]. This was sold to the people as a temporary measure. Guess what? The tax was never abolished. Don't expect governments to ever give back that they take from you. This goes for freedom and civilian rights, too. [1] http://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwartje_van_Kok http://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwartje_van_Kok (Dutch)
- cma 16y agoHow about women's suffrage? Governments can change to give more or to give less freedom; pretending they are a one way ratchet is counter-productive.
- arecibodrake 16y agoOne step forward, fifty thousand steps back?
- cma 15y agoFree-speech was largely won in the 60s.
- uriel 16y agoThis is one of the reasons power always tends to concentrate.
- oldcigarette 16y agoit hasn't been extended yet, write your bloody representatives instead of bitching about it