4 ms·
What a great idea. Of course you should do this! What could go wrong? Now remember that someday the tables will turn. Someday the bad orange man‘s side will ha
by tomcam 6y ago
What a great idea. Of course you should do this! What could go wrong?
Now remember that someday the tables will turn. Someday the bad orange man‘s side will have control of the media, and I expect you to support when they suppress the other side’s speech just as it was done to them today. Because we all know freedom of speech is good except when the other side has it.
- pyrrhotech 6y agohave you read his tweets? this has nothing to do with free speech. You are free to post as much conservative philosophy on twitter as you want, but you can't post blatantly treasonous and violence-inciting falsehoods. Twitter allows the accounts of 99% of republicans to go completely uncensored. This is not about censoring the right, it's about protecting our republic and way of life from a violent demagogue. We don't want another Mussolini on our hands. For the record, I lean conservative/libertarian on most issues
- tomcam 6y agoI see no evidence of treason and violence incitement by the president, but the great news is we have a court system that can deal with these things. I assume you want all incitement of violence by all Twitter accounts to result in the same kind of censorship, correct? > Twitter allows the accounts of 99% of republicans to go completely uncensored. Well that’s damn good of them.
- pyrrhotech 6y agoDid you watch the video that was deleted? IMO it is treasonous to blatantly put forth completely baseless election conspiracy theories in order to undermine our democracy. Trump directly encouraged the insurrection today to "Stop the Steal", in other words, to start a coup to forcefully end our democracy and instate himself as our autocrat. This is blatant treasonous behavior
- garbagetime 6y agoTrump's side and Twitter's side are both very far from what I see as moral. I'm not waiting until the tables turn from bad to worse to be horrified. I'm horrified now. Sure, I'd be horrified even if people I generally agreed with were the ones censoring. It's might-is-right level stuff. Twitter's censorship is just one aspect of the issue. Talented philosophers, scientists, etc. are being excluded from mainstream society (forced out of their education, employment, etc.) for having the wrong opinions. Many of the smartest people I know exist almost entirely outside of established institutions. Not a good situation. Very sad that people have so much respect for those in power.
- tomcam 6y ago> Trump's side and Twitter's side are both very far from what I see as moral. I happen to feel the same way about his predecessor. But I always supported Obama‘s use of the bully pulpit. Even though I agreed with very little of his core politics, I feel it’s the right of the president to use freedom of speech, period. Also, regarding morality. Because I believe in freedom of speech, I support the right of people to write and say immoral things. Even reprehensible things. And if we choose to suppress such speech, we should expect it to go underground and fester and explode painfully at the worst possible time. Much better in my view that these things be examined and rebutted in the public sphere.
- casefields 6y agoMoral? The Hayes Codes is long gone. Tell me, if you were a lawyer, would you have defended the neo-nazis right to march down Skokie's Main Street where tons of Holocaust survivors settled down after escaping Germany?
- garbagetime 6y ago>Tell me, if you were a lawyer, would you have defended the neo-nazis right to march down Skokie's Main Street where tons of Holocaust survivors settled down after escaping Germany? If I was a lawyer I would have done that if that's what I was employed to do. Hayes code seems irrelevant: what was being discussed was people feeling less positive about censorship when those who they thought were moral were being censored (rather than those thought to be immoral).
- AgentME 6y agoYou could argue against any rule enforcement by saying "what if they do the opposite eventually".
- tomcam 6y agoYes. That’s precisely how I structure my thinking. It is incumbent on me to imagine the results of policies that I support going wrong. For example, I tend to be slightly on the side of the death penalty. That means I have to imagine that a loved one of mine could be falsely accused of a crime and be executed for it. It would be morally reprehensible for me not to imagine all consequences of something I believe in. Likewise, anyone against the death penalty should imagine the case, for example, where their own children are killed and the murderer isn’t punished similarly. There are usually principle of arguments on both sides and I feel it’s important for me to account for them.
- tomcam 6y ago"principled arguments", not "principle of arguments", sorry.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]