4 ms·
If a mutant strain of COVID-19 becomes twice as deadly, this "merely" doubles the pressure on hospitals. A constant factor like this can be dealt with. However
by jiggawatts 6y ago
If a mutant strain of COVID-19 becomes twice as deadly, this "merely" doubles the pressure on hospitals. A constant factor like this can be dealt with.
However, an increased rate of spread (R factor) is a change in the parameter of the exponential curve, and cannot be dealt with by any sub-exponential response. The only thing that could possibly work is to change the factor. Rapid vaccination or lockdown. It's impossible to vaccinate the population of London in two weeks, which means a full lockdown is the only option now.
YC News is mostly a forum for software developers, which means that these notions ought to be familiar to most people here. When talking about software algorithms, we all learned about big-O notation. We all learned that Exponential time algorithms are (nearly) the worst case, and will always be worse for large data sets than a linear-time or quadratic algorithm, irrespective of the constant factor.
Essentially the new mutant strain changes the "R" term in Θ(a×exp(R×𝑡)), whereas increasing the lethality is a change in the "a" term.
People are concerned about the lethality getting worse, but they shouldn't be. This change in the infection rate is more scary.
- laqq3 6y agoGood analysis but small nitpick: the use of "Θ" in Θ(a×exp(R×𝑡)) is slightly inaccurate (or is it the use of "a"?) because the set of functions Θ(a×exp(R×𝑡)) is the same for all positive a.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- s_gourichon 6y agoWell, yes, of course: isn't "a doesn't matter" the core of the point of the parent comment?
- mikepurvis 6y agoI agree, but I think there is now a non-trivial group who are either a) in total denial about the virus or believe it's a conspiracy, b) overwhelmed by news of it and unable/unwilling to process anything new, or c) believe in herd immunity and might even welcome a faster spread on that basis. Arguments about exponentials mean nothing to anyone in any of these buckets— they'll be flaunting a lockdown up until and perhaps beyond the point where it is administered by force. I don't know how to deal with this reality, but it feels like the greatest threat at this point.
- fossuser 6y agoWe're at a weird mixture of competence. Extremely good coordination with vaccine invention, extremely bad with all other aspects. Humanity is irrational, most people believe crazy, inconsistent things, and are easily manipulated. The average citizen is stupid, the government is vulnerable to sentiment from the average citizen (and partisan media orgs that seek to influence those citizens for their own power or money). It's a bad situation. It's basically like Asimov said, "The saddest aspect of life right now is that science gathers knowledge faster than society gathers wisdom."
- plutonorm 6y agoI'm shocked that many of the comments here are dismissive of the seriousness of the situation. I thought the HN crowd would be more rational.
- mikepurvis 6y agoI'm taking it very seriously. This is a meta-discussion about reasons other people may not be, and how to address that both personally and at a policy level.
- Hongwei 6y agoI don't know. I would say I'm d) believe that the West cannot and should not enforce a lockdown the same way authoritarian China or Singapore can, and therefore it is doomed to fail. So: * lockdowns are guaranteed not going to eradicate the virus the way it has in China. * lockdowns are guaranteed to crush small businesses and restaurants, creating an L-shaped economic recovery and putting the West at a disadvantage in future geopolitical conflicts. * the vaccine works but will take a year to rollout to everyone and it is unimaginable that the public will tolerate a lockdown for more than a month * herd immunity might work I truly welcome any debate on this as I'd love to be wrong about my critique of my country's (Canada) approach to all this. We seem to be not having our cake and not eating it too.
- mikepurvis 6y agoWaterloo Region here. Up until the end of August, I was pretty happy with the response where I am, at all three levels of government— it seemed like the policies were basically working and the spread was contained, with new flare-ups presumably being seeded from elsewhere (Toronto, the US probably) and quickly dying out. And then cases started spiking in September, I suppose due to some combination of back-to-school, lockdown fatigue, increased indoor gatherings, etc. At that point I became extremely unhappy as it became apparent how little the Provincial gov't in particular had taken advantage of the long summer of low cases to build up test and hospital bed capacity, and to make plans for vaccine distribution. The second wave hit and it felt like basically just rewinding to March. This was apparent to everyone and I think it probably became a positive feedback loop as more and more people gave up and had in-person Thanksgiving and Christmas gatherings.
- krona 6y ago> This change in the virulence is more scary. I think you mean infectivity (relating to transmission), not virulence.
- jiggawatts 6y agoThanks, I edited the sentence.
- ed_balls 6y agoHow do we know that lethality ("a") has increased? My understanding is that there is an evolutionary pressure to become less lethal.
- lolc 6y agoThe virus getting deadlier is a hypothetical scenario. Yes we can assume there is selection pressure for more benign strains. But that doesn't mean those strains will win.
- owl57 6y ago> People are concerned about the lethality getting worse, but they shouldn't be They should. Lockdowns deal with the exponential phase, but in the long term the process is not exponential. The virus is probably going to infect half of population anyway. There simply aren't ten times more people it could infect. On the other hand, there are ten times more people it could kill or cripple.
- jiggawatts 6y agoPercentage wise the total population infection rate even in the US and UK isn't actually high, something like 9-11 percent at the moment after a full year of the virus spreading. Even with this faster spreading strain, it's possible that the vaccination efforts will win out and halt the spread before it reaches 50% of the population.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- postalrat 6y agoNothing in nature grows exponentially. If it did it would overwhelm the universe. YC News is mostly a forum for software developers, which means most of us have a tendency to want to keep things simple. That's fine for simple thinks like operating systems or proving all problems in NP are also in P. But nature is on a completely different level.
- lolc 6y agoWe are right now observing exponential spread of a virus. And we don't want to hit the natural end of exponential spread for this virus.
- postalrat 6y agoI've been hearing that for months. If coronavirus had a doubling time of 7 days we should be well over 1,000,000,000,000,000 cases by now. And you or nobody else knows what the natural end would be for this virus. A fast spreading variant could overall reduce deaths over the next 5 years.
- lolc 6y agoThe projected natural end of this pandemic would come within a year when the majority of the population got infected. As a society we've decided to not let this happen. Which is why the numbers diverge from your simplistic formula. > A fast spreading variant could overall reduce deaths over the next 5 years. What do you mean by this?
- postalrat 6y ago> What do you mean by this? Assume being infected from this variant grants some protection to future variants. If everyone was infected (or vaccinated) and protected then it would be difficult for the virus to spread and mutate. A slower spreading virus would produce more mutations over time and its possible one of those mutations could be catastrophic (though unlikely). Not only do you have more mutations but you also have fewer people protected.