4 ms·
The real news is not that Apple won't remove malware, it's that Apple is apparently actively working to conceal the truth and perpetuate the Mac-selling legend
by sliverstorm 16y ago
The real news is not that Apple won't remove malware, it's that Apple is apparently actively working to conceal the truth and perpetuate the Mac-selling legend that Macs cannot get viruses.
- mambodog 16y agoApple is doing the most sensible thing for their business. An uptick in users installing adware on their computers (yes, you have to manually install it) is a far cry from having a platform blighted by drive-by infections and autonomously spreading worms as Windows was in years past. However, from a marketing point of view it's a lot harder to sell. Compare: You can't get viruses on Mac. with: Using a Mac you are very unlikely to get a virus, and provided you don't download and install anything shady ad/spyware isn't a concern either. The second statement is true of Macs today, and still presents an advantage over Windows, but "No viruses" is a much simpler message, and one it seems they are trying to keep (superficially) intact.
- Niten 16y ago> An uptick in users installing adware on their computers (yes, you have to manually install it) is a far cry from having a platform blighted by drive-by infections and autonomously spreading worms as Windows was in years past. Well yes, but lately how are these drive-by installations happening? Mostly through holes in third-party software. My concern, as a Mac user, is that there's no fundamental reason it should be any harder to attack OS X this way; it's just that up until now Windows has been a vastly more profitable target. And that is changing. If you're a careful and conscientious user I'd honestly say you're safer on Windows at this point, because Windows is used to being attacked. It's used to defending itself against this kind of threat. You have this ecosystem of powerful antivirus programs like MSE or AntiVir that update themselves constantly, and innumerable other third-party tools such as Secunia PSI as preventative measures, and these just don't really exist on OS X yet. Windows also yet has some exploit mitigation facilities that OS X lacks, such as ASLR and kernel patch protection. It will be a while before OS X has developed such an ecosystem of its own, and we just have to hope the adjustment period won't be too painful.
- bandushrew 16y ago'but lately how are these drive-by installations happening? Mostly through holes in third-party software' nope. by the user running an installer when requested by a browser ad popup.
- Niten 16y ago> nope. by the user running an installer when requested by a browser ad popup. I agree that this is how most malware happens in general, but I was talking specifically about the subset of malware installations that are drive-by downloads, i.e. which are performed without user interaction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive-by_download http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive-by_download What I mean to say is that most of those are exploiting third-party software (Java, Adobe Flash and Reader) rather than Microsoft stuff these days.
- Pheter 16y agoThe first point your link makes is that Drive-by downloads includes user intervention: "Downloads which a person authorized but without understanding the consequences".
- danssig 16y ago>and these just don't really exist on OS X yet And hopefully they never will. This is the stupidest possible way of protecting your computer. The proper solution is a more modern security system like SELinux instead of this outdated user/group/others approach.
- wisty 16y agoIt's not a virus. It's malware. Users install it, and it sends them to porn sites. If you run "sudo rm -rld /*" on a Mac, it may not run so well either. Of course, it may be a sign that more sophisticated malware (i.e. real viruses, and other stuff that actually exploits the Mac's vulnerabilities) will be on the way.
- daeken 16y ago> Of course, it may be a sign that more sophisticated malware (i.e. real viruses, and other stuff that actually exploits the Mac's vulnerabilities) will be on the way. Once an OS has the attention of malware writers (even user-installed malware like this), real malware won't be far behind. Especially when you consider how much easier exploitation is on OS X than, say, Windows or Linux. It's 2011, but OS X still doesn't have useful ASLR -- supposed to be coming in 10.7, but it was also supposed to come in 10.6, so we'll see how that goes.
- danssig 16y ago> when you consider how much easier exploitation is on OS X than, say, Windows or Linux. [citation needed] It wasn't until Windows 7 that windows finally got a reasonable security approach. I don't know what install bases look like these days but most PCs I interact with are still on XP which is obviously not harder to exploit that OS X.
- blub 16y agoThat is not correct, most of the security improvements were already implemented in Vista, which was released in 2007.
- adamc 16y agoYes, but Microsoft has acknowledged that there were weaknesses in its 32-bit ASLR implementation for Vista; see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Address_space_layout_randomization http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Address_space_layout_randomizat...
- beedogs 16y agoApple lies about the capability, strengths, and shortcomings of their products all the time, and have done so for as long as I can remember. It just seems to be their standard practice.
- ericd 16y agoNo, they just don't bog their messages down with caveats, which just serve to confuse people. Effective communication sometimes sacrifices some small measure of accuracy. You see this in conversation all the time.
- nickolai 16y agoThe parent post may be a bit generalizing, but how exactly is "the safety of your system also depends on the user's actions" a confusing caveat? Because that is the point being suppressed/omitted in the present case.
- ericd 16y agoEven that bogs things down in the context of a bulletpoint on a big poster with a four word sentence about macs not getting viruses.
- lloeki 16y agoApple sells anti-malware right in Apple Stores. How's that for truth-concealing?