5 ms·
Neither A nor C makes any sense, are not supported by evidence. There is no aspect of the mac or macOS that can be realistically described as a "walled garden".
by jeffbee 6y ago
Neither A nor C makes any sense, are not supported by evidence. There is no aspect of the mac or macOS that can be realistically described as a "walled garden". It comes with a compiler toolchain and ... well, some docs. It natively runs software compiled for a foreign architecture. You can do whatever you want with it. It's pretty open.
A "walled garden" is when there is a single source of software.
- ogre_codes 6y agoPeople seem to get creative about terminology. It's not remotely like what I'd consider a walled garden (xBox, iOS, Playstation, etc).
- coldtea 6y agoWalled garden has many meanings, depending on context. macOS promotes the App Store as the source of software (even if it's not the sole), and has walls like notarization requirements and the Gatekeeper to prevent weeds from intruding. With the App Store Apple knew that there's a pool of N apps that follows its guidelines, has passed internal checks for API use, and can be converted quite easily to a different architecture, that it could count on. Their control over the platform allowed them to enforce Metal and deprecate OpenGL pronto, to add a new combined iOS/macOS UI libs, to introduce Marzipan. They have also added stuff like Universal Binary support, and most importantly Bitcode, which abstracts away parts of the underlying architecture. All of those where steps towards the ARM/M1 (and future developments), and all were enabled via Apple's control of the hardward, software, and - sure, partial - control of third party apps.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoRunning apps downloaded outside the store requires jumping through an increasing number of hoops or vendors pay to get every build signed off by a single party.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 6y agoYou don't have to pay to have your apps signed off (notarized).
- paulryanrogers 6y agoI'll have to check again because if that's the case it's still a walled garden, just with free admission.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- astrange 6y agoJust right-click > Open and you can do anything you want.
- perryizgr8 6y agoWhich is a short wall you just jumped. To get into the walled garden.
- matthew-wegner 6y ago"A" does matter a bit. Builds are uploaded to the App Store include bitcode, which Apple strips on distribution. According to docs, enabling bitcode: "Includes bitcode which allows the App Store to compile your app optimized for the target devices and operating system versions, and may recompile it later to take advantage of specific hardware, software, or compiler changes." It seems quite likely they have (and probably used) the capability to recompile any app on their platform to benchmark real workloads against prototype silicon changes.