4 ms·
Every time I ride a bike on a rail trail, I can't help but wonder how much safer the roads would be if freight was still being transported there, instead of on
by kube-system 6y ago
Every time I ride a bike on a rail trail, I can't help but wonder how much safer the roads would be if freight was still being transported there, instead of on the road. I guess it's better off as a trail than nothing at all, but it feels like a fresh coat of paint over infrastructural decay to me.
- ghaff 6y agoThere is absolutely no shortage of cargo going by rail in the United States, which is how most non-high value long haul shipping is done.
- nagyf 6y agoCurious: why only non-high value? I would think that's more secure than transporting on the road
- ghaff 6y agoNo idea about loss rates on rail vs. trucks. Not sure why containers on rail would be more secure than containers on trucks. But I assume most high value cargo, e.g. an iPhone, goes by air except locally.
- kube-system 6y agoOf course, there is still a lot of volume going by rail (more than in the past, even)... but relatively speaking, air and truck traffic have taken over a larger share of the total. https://www.bts.gov/archive/publications/freight_in_america/figure_06 https://www.bts.gov/archive/publications/freight_in_america/... It just would have been nice to see our freight needs prioritize safety and environmental friendliness, but we've prioritized speed instead.
- m463 6y agoI think the problem with rail is economic. Market forces are much more powerful with trucking for instance because anyone can buy a truck and start a business. Same thing with container ships - buy a ship, go into business (don't know about port berth complications) So with rail, the rail owners get in the way. It's like if someone owned the roads or the ocean and worked on collecting rent. I wonder if there were a model where anyone could use the rails, like anyone can use the highway system, and then rail shipping/use would go up.
- hedora 6y agoRail works fine overseas. The US automobile industry bought up and intentionally destroyed our passenger rail networks. Antitrust law should have been used to prevent it, but it wasn’t, and now the damage has been done.