6 ms·
>Why is that strategy simultaneously remarkably efficient and remarkably high-performance? What enabled/led them to make those choices where others haven't? Th
by coldtea 6y ago
>Why is that strategy simultaneously remarkably efficient and remarkably high-performance? What enabled/led them to make those choices where others haven't?
The things people give them complains about:
(a) keeping a walled garden,
(b) moving fast and taking the platform to new directions all at once
(c) controlling the whole stack
Which means they're not beholden to compatibility with third party frameworks and big players, or with their own past, and thus can rely on their APIs, third party devs etc, to cater to their changes to the architecture.
And they're not chained to the whims of the CPU vendor (as the OS vendor) or the OS vendor (as the CPU vendor) either, as they serve the role of both.
And of course they benchmarked and profiled the hell out of actual systems.
- fartcannon 6y agoThey could still do all this shit without the walled garden. To me, it suggests they aren't willing to compete. They're anti-competitive.
- marrvelous 6y agoWith the walled garden, Apple can set enforceable timelines for the software ecosystem to adopt to architectural changes. Remember the transition to arm64? Apple forced everything on the App Store to ship universal binaries. Without the App Store walled garden, software isn’t required to keep up to date with architectural changes. Instead, keeping current is only a requirement to being featured on the App Store (which would just be a single way to install software, not the only method).
- danaris 6y agoWell, and on the Mac, it's not the only method. The walled garden here has big open gates. That said, all software on the Mac, post-Catalina, has to be 64-bit, whether it's distributed through the Mac App Store or not, because the 32-bit system libraries are no longer included at all.
- coldtea 6y ago>Well, and on the Mac, it's not the only method. The walled garden here has big open gates. Gates are not incompatible with walled gardens. Most walled gardens have those. Plus, I mentioned the walled garden as a good thing. It's part of the Apple proposition (even if not alll get it), and part of what it enables it to move at the speed it does (whether in the right or wrong direction). But one can susbstitute "walled garden" with "tight control of the OS, hardware and imposed requirements on most of third party software, and willingness to enforce hard schedules (e.g. regarding removing 32-bit, OpenGL, etc) to all (or tons) of its developers at once.
- ogre_codes 6y agoThey are little tiny 6" tall walls that you can step over. Like micro-walls. Except for the bits where you have no walls at all. Like if you install literally any programming language, HomeBrew, or MacPorts. The walls in the walled garden only exist in the heads of people who never use a Mac.
- astrange 6y ago32-bit Windows software is actually supported through WINE and works in Rosetta.
- coldtea 6y agoThis is about 32-bit OS X software/libs.
- coldtea 6y ago>They could still do all this shit without the walled garden With much slower adoption, pushback, and bike-shedding, like in the Microsoft and Linux world. >To me, it suggests they aren't willing to compete. Compete with what? With themselves? They compete with Windows (and to a degree Linux, though few care for that), and with Android. They'd compete with Windows Phone too if MS wasn't incompetent. But they didn't do anything to preclude others from making their OS/hardware and selling it to customers. In fact, they have nowhere near a monopoly in either the desktop (10% or less) or the mobile space (40% or less). Whereas MS for example, had 98% of the desktop (home and enterprise), and abused its power to threaten OEMs to do its bidding against Linux etc.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> They could still do all this shit without the walled garden. They do. MacOS isn't a walled garden. > They're anti-competitive Have you heard of this little company from Washington called Microsoft? They have something like 85% of the PC market. There is another OS called Linux. About 85-90% of the internet runs on it. I can understand a little where people get the idea the iPhone is anti-competitive, but we're talking about MacOS here.
- fartcannon 6y agoIt's the same cowardly leadership that stewards both iOS and OSX. Ask Amphetamine about how open they are.
- ogre_codes 6y agoI do wish people would keep the quasi-religious aspects out of things. Amphetamine is a perfect example of how the Mac isn't a walled garden. They always had the option top sell outside the App Store. That is fundamentally the difference between what makes a platform a walled garden. They might have lost some sales because they couldn't participate in the Mac App Store, but they could still sell their product. Some companies choose to avoid the Mac App Store because they don't like Apple's policies.
- coldtea 6y ago>Ask Amphetamine about how open they are. That's neither here nor there. (a) Amphetamine could still be sold outside the Mac App Store. (b) An app name could be problematic even in FOSS land. It's just that instead of Amphetamine being the name that causes it, it will be something else. E.g. with the trend of banning/changing terms like "master" (as in replication primary master, not as in the owner of slaves), unfortunately named apps could be thrown out something or ask to be renamed to be included in a distros package manager or a project.
- astrange 6y agoThere are a lot of juvenile named open source projects that will definitely get in trouble or already have. GIMP and LAME are examples.
- anfilt 6y agoI will be honest as long apple keeps this walled garden shenanigans going. I am not buying any of their hardware.
- anfilt 6y agoWhat's with downvotes? I know some people don't mind, but it's a deal breaker to me, and it something I don't want to support. I don't care how good their hardware is. Moreover, good luck sourcing parts if the device has trouble. Apple will not sell you the parts. Even if you wanted. A walled garden does not make their hardware any better. If anything it makes it worse. I hope for Mac users apply does not clamp down further on Macs.
- coldtea 6y ago>What's with downvotes? Didn't downvote, but I think it's the same as when people read a "letter to the editor" of yore, declaring that some person "cancelled their subscription" because of something in the magazine. A natural response is "Don't let the door hit you on your way out", which on HN might be expressed through a downvote by some. >I don't care how good their hardware is. Moreover, good luck sourcing parts if the device has trouble. Apple will not sell you the parts. Even if you wanted. Well, they repair all kinds of parts, and have guarantees and guarantee extension programs. But in any case, their allure was never "can find parts to build my own / repair damages forever" or in their stuff being cheap to own or fix/replace. >A walled garden does not make their hardware any better. Well, it does in a few ways. Mandating how the software is made, and what software is sold, when it should adapt new libs to continue being sold, etc, means that they can move the platform in different ways faster.
- anfilt 6y ago> "Don't let the door hit you on your way out" I never bother to enter apple's tyrannical ecosystem . So there is no door to hit me on the way out. > Well, they repair all kinds of parts, and have guarantees and guarantee extension programs. You can not get a lot surface mount chips to repair a mac book or iPhone without having to look on the gray-market. This is even before possible firmware issue if you manage to find parts. Heck even getting full replacement boards is basically impossible, unless they are from donor machines that have other problems. > "Well, it does in a few ways. Mandating how the software is made, and what software is sold, when it should adapt new libs to continue being sold, etc, means that they can move the platform in different ways faster." I disagree, allowing people to side-load does not stop apple from having policies in place for it's app stores. That's honestly the only problem. It's the owners hardware, they should not need apples permission to run code on it. Unless the owner can sign software themselves and/or run it without apple's consent this will always be a problem. You can't even install gcc without jailbreaking an iPhone. At the very least I should be able to install an other OS on the device like GNU/Linux. If apple does not want to open iOS the user should at least have that option for the hardware. This is even before you get into how apple treats developers. Have you read the entire App store guidelines. Some of it is ridiculous. Some of the insanity prevents Firefox from even porting their own browser engine.
- jeffbee 6y agoNeither A nor C makes any sense, are not supported by evidence. There is no aspect of the mac or macOS that can be realistically described as a "walled garden". It comes with a compiler toolchain and ... well, some docs. It natively runs software compiled for a foreign architecture. You can do whatever you want with it. It's pretty open. A "walled garden" is when there is a single source of software.
- ogre_codes 6y agoPeople seem to get creative about terminology. It's not remotely like what I'd consider a walled garden (xBox, iOS, Playstation, etc).
- coldtea 6y agoWalled garden has many meanings, depending on context. macOS promotes the App Store as the source of software (even if it's not the sole), and has walls like notarization requirements and the Gatekeeper to prevent weeds from intruding. With the App Store Apple knew that there's a pool of N apps that follows its guidelines, has passed internal checks for API use, and can be converted quite easily to a different architecture, that it could count on. Their control over the platform allowed them to enforce Metal and deprecate OpenGL pronto, to add a new combined iOS/macOS UI libs, to introduce Marzipan. They have also added stuff like Universal Binary support, and most importantly Bitcode, which abstracts away parts of the underlying architecture. All of those where steps towards the ARM/M1 (and future developments), and all were enabled via Apple's control of the hardward, software, and - sure, partial - control of third party apps.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoRunning apps downloaded outside the store requires jumping through an increasing number of hoops or vendors pay to get every build signed off by a single party.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 6y ago