3 ms·
>> I don't see why web apps should be handicapped compared to their native versions. For starters, native apps have too many permissions already. Second, if y
by phkahler 6y ago
>> I don't see why web apps should be handicapped compared to their native versions.
For starters, native apps have too many permissions already.
Second, if you run a native app it should require explicit permission for internet access (perhaps at install time) so you have some idea if local data is going somewhere. Web apps are implicitly assumed to have internet access.
This should be fairly obvious, and the notion of granting more local access to arbitrary outsiders should be distressing. The fact that google and web sites feel entitled to everything on and about you computer says a lot about them. If they were humans with that lack of boundaries and sense that what's yours is theirs, we'd label then narcissists or psychopaths (not sure which).
- Arnavion 6y agoIndeed, OSes already have privilege access mechanisms like GPO on Windows and SELinux / AppArmor / Flatpak on Linux to restrict installed binaries. Then all that goes out the window when the 100 MiB gorilla named /usr/bin/browser wants access to everything anyway, connects all that privileged information to other people's computers, and then implements its own entirely separate privilege access mechanisms in userspace to make that secure.
- wieghant 6y agoYet we are as of right now where even our OS will go behind our back and act like malware to collect data even when we explicitly say no. The native apps are also all trending to online first and cache offline. I don't understand how a native app going behind your back and asking only for internet connection permission (and not hardware) is viewed as more secure. Why do we trust these native apps more? Arbitrary psychopathic outsiders have already been here for quite a while. Even if you're running super paranoid homebrew linux distro.