7 ms·
If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That seems like a
by onion2k 6y ago
If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That seems like a ridiculous stretch in my opinion.
It's more like an oncologist posting that every doctor needs to revise cancer treatments for a month before applying for a role in a hospital without realising that other doctors have spent 10 years specialising in different areas of medicine, and then the hospital being amazing at treating cancer but wondering why they're absolutely terrible at mending broken arms.
In this analogy cancer is advertising, and broken arms is privacy.
- georgeglue1 6y agothis is off topic, but medical training (at least in the US) is unfortunately about as dysfunctional as you describe. there's are years of inefficient labor from students, residents, fellows, and junior doctors on procedures they'll never do again (because they relatively cheap)
- dvdbloc 6y agoI’m not sure exactly what you’re describing but sounds like they could be getting practical experience? Like a junior dev doing some scripting grunt work that no one else wanted to do but they are gaining other skills along the way possibly?
- llimllib 6y agoBut at least when you're 10 years into your career you aren't judged based on your boards any longer
- tobmlt 6y agoYou do need to take them every so often to stay certified. This cartel isn’t for slackers, come now. (I jest - half my family is in the medical business. I studied economics for a while)
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoFirst of all, I'm not sure where this "10 years" is coming from. I know many/most "senior" developers who reached that level long before 10 years out of university. Secondly, programming doesn't have a standard licensure process like medicine. If it did, I think a lot of these kinds of interviews that companies do would not be necessary. But as it stands I've interviewed many engineers with years of experience who couldn't competently program, and I'm talking about maybe a tad above FizzBuzz level proficiency.
- caymanjim 6y ago> First of all, I'm not sure where this "10 years" is coming from. I know many/most "senior" developers who reached that level long before 10 years out of university. That's because it's a near-meaningless title that has been watered down. Everyone is a "senior" now by their second year working.
- barnacled 6y agoIt really depends on the place and nearly always applies only to experience specifically in the exact role you are in. I have 15yrs experience and moved sideways a few times and I am in effect treated as if I were new in my current role. So senior doesn't so much translate to experience or even transferable working knowledge but rather 'how well you have done politically to gain position in this specific company'. Yes I am cynical :)
- cratermoon 6y agoAs of 2-4 years ago, the number of programmers working in the industry was doubling every 5 years. That might not seem relevant until you realize that it means half of all programmers have less than 5 years experience. If you have 10 years in the industry, you're more senior than 75% of your co-workers. That's why anyone with 5 years on the job is considered "senior", even though most in most professions you're just getting out of the entry level after 5 years.
- wyclif 6y agoThe most frustrating thing about this post for me isn't the "10 years" issue, but rather this: Most of these companies have solid internship programs, and almost all E3 (entry-level) positions are offered to returning interns. What this means is that there's no track into a junior position where you can gain experience and work your way up to senior within a FAANG if you're older than a recent college grad. That's unfortunate, because as someone working for a mid-tier company I'd like to work hard and land a senior role at a FAANG but I often wonder if these companies would look down on candidates who have spent years at lesser companies.
- Aunche 6y agoI'm sure many people from Facebook switched from the advertising department to the privacy department.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoReally bad analogy. Look at the post, these are basic computer science topics he is recommending for study, things like data structures and algorithms, not any specific technological subspecialty. A better analogy is that all doctors need to pass licensure exams in basic medical knowledge (e.g. anatomy, physiology, etc.)
- learc83 6y ago>A better analogy is that all doctors need to pass licensure exams in basic medical knowledge (e.g. anatomy, physiology, etc.) The problem with the situation is that doctors don't need to do that every time they change jobs.