2 ms·
In a single payer system there's nowhere else to go. We have private health care in the UK in addition to the national health service (eg https://www.bupa.co.u
by onion2k 6y ago
In a single payer system there's nowhere else to go.
We have private health care in the UK in addition to the national health service (eg https://www.bupa.co.uk/ https://www.bupa.co.uk/). It's insurance-based, and it pays for treatment in hospitals both inside and outside of the NHS. It's even offered as a perk by some employers. Specifically relevant to this HN story, there's access to cancer treatments before they're approved by the NHS and NICE (https://www.bupa.co.uk/health/health-insurance/bupa-cancer-promise https://www.bupa.co.uk/health/health-insurance/bupa-cancer-p...).
I realise that some people are politically averse to single payer healthcare, but please read up a bit about how the UK's healthcare system works before posting about it. You're only spreading misinformation if you don't.
For clarity - the UK's NHS is a single payer taxation funded, free-at-the-point-of-use healthcare system, but we also have companies that offer parallel private health insurance funded healthcare for anyone who chooses to pay (and yes, that does mean they're paying for the government service and their own private service, but that's just how taxation works).
- arcticbull 6y agoI wasn't commenting on the NHS there, I was making my comments with reference to the Canadian system. I retracted my comment because I made it overly board. If you'd like to learn more about the legality of private cover within the Canadian system you can do so here. [1] In Canada, while in general private cover is not illegal, for covered health services, it roughly speaking does not exist and my statement that you "have nowhere else to go" holds. I can see that my statement was unclear, hence my edit. With respect to the other statement I made, that money won't buy you better care within the NHS is true to the best of my knowledge. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC80881/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC80881/
- beagle3 6y ago> In Canada, while in general private cover is not illegal, for covered health services, it roughly speaking does not exist and my statement that you "have nowhere else to go" holds. The key is “covered health services”. E.g. a friend who broke his arm in Israel (which has an NHS like medical system) needed to have it cast; a standard plaster cast was covered, but for an extra $150 or so, he was able to pay and get a super-lightweight composite cast material (which he had to buy at a pharmacy down the road himself, but the doctors at the public hospital happily applied). This was about 20 years ago - I suspect the ultra lightweight cast is covered by now as well - but there will always be treatments which may make sense for an individual to pay for, but not for the system. Similarly to the NHS, more money doesn’t buy you better care within the system in Israel; but there is a complementary private system which occasionally can get you better care (and can often get you the same non urgent care faster). The general rule for coverage inclusion in the Israeli system is: if it’s life saving, it is covered. If it’s life extending or quality improving, then a QALYs analysis and budget constraints set the priorities (most proven reasonable cost treatment are indeed covered)
- arcticbull 6y ago> The key is “covered health services”. Covered health services in Canada is substantially all health services. This is addressed in the link I provided.
- beagle3 6y agoIt is the same in Israel. And yet, there’s room for some private health services. In the public system, you usually have a room mate after an operation. If you use the private system, you get a private room and get to request specific food. You don’t get treatment that is any better from a health perspective. But you do get a nicer stay.