7 ms·
> It's inevitable that medical care in some way is tied to personal wealth. Some treatments are so expensive and/or niche that public programs likely wouldn't c
by arcticbull 6y ago
> It's inevitable that medical care in some way is tied to personal wealth. Some treatments are so expensive and/or niche that public programs likely wouldn't cover them. Such treatments will probably always exist. (And if they didn't, then that could he a problem by itself.)
Not in a single-payer state, no.
It's also not really a problem in and of itself. You'll find that if cancer treatments are actually cheaper and more effective than the status quo as demonstrated by a study that a single payer state will quickly take them up.
[edit] Frequently you'll find these eccentric or fringe treatments that are incredibly expensive aren't actually better per se. There is a point of diminishing returns in everything. If you paid $200K for cancer treatment, would you get a better outcome? $1M? $10M? $1B? No. We know what we know, and we have the tools we have. Healthcare isn't a pay-to-win game. Generally if you find a way to pay more to get better care you're just bumping someone else down the priority list. That may be acceptable in America but it's not in much of the rest of the world.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoExtremely rich people in non-USA countries can still travel elsewhere and pay exorbitant amounts for exotic treatment if they so desire. Some of those might be lifesaving.
- arcticbull 6y agoSome (who don't understand the value of money) may even visit the US. My question is do you have some good examples of this, particularly where efficacy is disproportionately better?
- jjeaff 6y agoI could be wrong, but I believe one of the few metrics that the US outperforms in is cancer survival. I have heard that there are quite a few wealthy people (even from places like canada and the uk) that come here for cancer treatments that are not provided in their country because the public health system will not pay for them.
- arcticbull 6y agoThat's a funky one, and I'll be the first to say that America does have some very good cancer treatment clinics if you don't mind bankruptcy (although the same is true if you break your leg). Part of that has to do with how cancer survival rates are measured and what role screening has in the various systems. This came up with Giuliani a while ago and is well described here [1]. tldr: The statistics are quite misleading as cancer survival is measured in 5-year survival rates, and the US has aggressive (sometimes medically unjustified) early screening programs. Early detection of some kinds of cancer, such as prostate cancer, doesn't change the mortality rate but it does change the 5-year survival rate as the disease is detected earlier. If you have more data, or this isn't what you were referring to, I'd love to read it! [1] https://www.factcheck.org/2007/10/a-bogus-cancer-statistic/ https://www.factcheck.org/2007/10/a-bogus-cancer-statistic/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- refurb 6y agoHere is a good example as to why you might want to go to the US for cancer care. "It's crazy that I live in Canada, but now I'm looking at having to sell my house for coverage of my medication." https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/a-tale-of-2-friends-with-breast-cancer-1-has-coverage-for-costly-drug-the-other-forced-to-pay-1.4495123 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/a-tale-of-2-...
- arcticbull 6y agoThat's one people out of 36 million, making national news. You'll trip over a stack of them on your way to the news stand in the US. "I'm looking at having to sell my house for coverage of my medication" is practically America's national anthem. Failures happen from time to time but they are the exception and not the norm. Numbers available here: [1] for the most part Canadians getting medical care in the US are "snowbirds" who live in Florida or California for half the year. This is utterly logical as Canadians don't usually have $100,000 to pay for a new hip. If you dig into that specific situation, the issue was that Health Canada only gave conditional approval for Ibrance in early 2016. Broader approval was granted in mid/late 2017. This article was written in January of 2018 - between when Health Canada had approved Ibrance and when the British Columbia Ministry of Health had added it to it's list of covered drugs. That happened just 3 months after the article was published, in April of 2018. This particular lady chose to travel to the US to obtain a drug that was not approved for sale in Canada at the time. That has since changed. I don't think it's fair to indict the health system over this especially when not all health Canada approved drugs are fda approved and vv. [1] https://www.vox.com/2016/10/9/13222798/canadians-seeking-medical-care-us-trump-debate https://www.vox.com/2016/10/9/13222798/canadians-seeking-med... [2] https://www.pfizer.ca/pfizer-receives-expanded-health-canada-approval-ibrance® https://www.pfizer.ca/pfizer-receives-expanded-health-canada...
- Anon1096 6y agoThis isn't correct in the UK under NHS. There's a set amount NHS is willing to pay for drugs and treatment, and beyond that, it's refused altogether. You'd have to go elsewhere and on your own dime for expensive treatments. Here's a link from the BBC I quickly found but it's widely documented: https://www.bbc.com/news/health-28983924 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-28983924
- arcticbull 6y agoThe QALY metric they mention is exactly what I had in mind, actually, very cool. Wealth won't get you better care, or faster care, or different in the NHS. That's the point I was making, and your article supports that position. > "You'd have to go elsewhere and on your own dime for expensive treatments." [In a single payer system there's nowhere else to go.] (retracted)
- grey-area 6y agoThe majority of single payer systems don't outlaw private care. There are private hospitals in the UK for example. Single payer is about removing insurance companies from the process (saving money), standardising care (saving money, improving outcomes), collective bargaining for drugs (saving money), providing a base level of care to all (saving money and improving QOL). But it doesn't usually forbid spending money on private care. As a result single payer results in similar outcomes for vastly less public money, and almost zero private money spent on healthcare.
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, and I retract my final sentence.
- fraggle_sock 6y agoIdeally though, all private healthcare would be banned. Aside from ideological concerns about not giving the wealthy an unfair advantage, this has pragmatic benefit in ensuring that the public healthcare system is up to standard. That is, if the wealthy and powerful are forced to use it too, it means they have skin in the game and won't just use their power to run it into the ground in pursuit of profit or from lack of concern for others.
- toshk 6y agoThere are a few treatments that work well but are just to expensive to be viable. For instance a few decades there was a gene therapy developed for people with a gene deficiency that blocks them from digesting fats. If I remember correctly it was developed in Canada. Even though it cured the people, it was and is too expensive for it to be used at the moment.
- Aerroon 6y ago>Not in a single-payer state, no. You can always go to another country or just pay someone personally to hear out your problems and help fix them. You can't avoid that. >It's also not really a problem in and of itself. You'll find that if cancer treatments are actually cheaper and more effective than the status quo as demonstrated by a study that a single payer state will quickly take them up. Some people report that doing a ketogenic diet helps them control some diseases (eg diabetes). It's been a decade since its surge in popularity. Keto doesn't seem to always work, but it seems to work for some. Is it considered a treatment yet? Because doing a keto diet is likely to incur a higher cost - carbs are cheaper compared to protein and fats. >Healthcare isn't a pay-to-win game. Generally if you find a way to pay more to get better care you're just bumping someone else down the priority list. What do you mean? Healthcare is not a fixed pie. It's constantly expanding in what can be treated, you can train and hire more doctors and nurses, you can make more and better equipment. If people are willing to pay enough extra for some treatment, then this can directly lead to the capacity of that treatment increasing. >That may be acceptable in America but it's not in much of the rest of the world. This is exactly how it works in many countries. You have your public healthcare and then private healthcare, where you can skip queues.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI like our healthcare system here in Canada, but this is not fully true. There are often experimental or very expensive treatments that the provincial health care systems don't cover, and so every few months I hear about some medication for a rare disease or cancer that someone is struggling/lobbying to get covered. One historical example is Herceptin, for treating breast cancer. It took six years to get the Ontario gov't to finally cave and cover it, meanwhile some people were traveling to Buffalo or other places in the US and paying out of pocket to get it. See this old article from 2005: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/ontario-makes-herceptin-widely-available/article1122113/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/ontario-makes-herceptin... On average, yes, it is better to be a cancer patient here than in the US, especially if you're working class or poor. And I believe last time I looked the life expectancy and recovery rates statistics etc. bore that out. But there are definitely medications and treatments not covered, still, and having extra insurance coverage is important enough that people I know have struggled to keep their jobs so they could continue to pay for their partner's treatments. In general, in Canada, medical care is covered but prescription pharmaceuticals are not. Which needs to be remedied.
- arcticbull 6y ago> In general, in Canada, medical care is covered but prescription pharmaceuticals are not. Which needs to be remedied. Dental and vision too!