4 ms·
No, people use the web for apps because: (a) AWT was shitty and Swing an overengineered mess. (b) GTK+ was never decent cross platform. (c) QT was more decen
by coldtea 6y ago
No, people use the web for apps because:
(a) AWT was shitty and Swing an overengineered mess.
(b) GTK+ was never decent cross platform.
(c) QT was more decent, but had its own issues, and still in an uncanny valley (neither native enough, not its own thing like the web UI is).
(d) Cocoa and whatever Windows has this week are not cross platform.
(e) Most other alternatives are buggy, understuffed, and just don't look good
(f) It's easy to put something on the screen with not even a compiler or download needed.
- judge2020 6y ago> whatever Windows has this week Just for informative purposes, it's maui - a cross platform .net core UI. https://github.com/dotnet/maui https://github.com/dotnet/maui Currently predicting Nov 2021 (dates may change) > .NET MAUI general availability November 2021
- coldtea 6y agoI said it half jockingly, but I have read about over 5 transitions from UI framework to UI framework in Windows-land in the past 25 years... Haven't even heard of this maui thing -- the last thing I remember was XAML, WPF, etc.
- alexhutcheson 6y agoAlso, of those options, only Qt works on mobile, and only since version 5.1 in late 2013. Qt licensing is also a bit complicated on iOS. The web enjoyed a fairly long monopoly as the only cross-platform option if you cared about mobile.
- KronisLV 6y agoI really wanted to like Swing - despite it really being an overengineered mess, with some IDE GUI tools for creating UI layouts (a crutch that you might want to use, given how messy the code-first approach would be), it was actually a passable way of creating cross-platform GUI apps. Though you'd still need JDK, which was a drawback (and it wouldn't look or feel native, but then again, at least it worked). JavaFX/OpenJFX, despite its advantages, somehow feels worse integrated into the development workflow that some people like me used to have. Never really got into GTK+ or Qt, or other tools that are more wieldy in the lower level languages, i'm afraid, though i'm sure that with enough time investment, bindings for other languages could be found and you could use them well enough. Though the closest i've seen to "easy" cross-platform GUI development that actually respects the underlying platform (unlike Electron), but that also doesn't make your hair go gray, was the way FreePascal + Lazarus handled it, by attempting to support multiple frameworks in a transparent manner, where possible ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lazarus_Component_Library https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lazarus_Component_Library ). Now, normally something like that would fail, since abstractions are leaky, but it seems like a number of useful pieces of software was actually written that way ( https://wiki.freepascal.org/Projects_using_Free_Pascal https://wiki.freepascal.org/Projects_using_Free_Pascal ). It's just sad that the language is kind of dead nowadays, as is the idea of having up-to-date tooling around it, or even many tools for developing web APIs. :/