3 ms·
> The reason the ISM bands look so "hot" or busy on a spectrum analyzer is exactly because they're a "free for all." It's a classic tragedy of the commons: ever
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> The reason the ISM bands look so "hot" or busy on a spectrum analyzer is exactly because they're a "free for all." It's a classic tragedy of the commons: everyone keeps "shouting" at max volume to be heard and there's no coordination between operators and users of different services.
This would be a lot more believable if the unlicensed spectrum wasn't already under low regulatory limits on power levels.
You can always come up with some kind of system that will extract a little more efficiency out of things, but the reason most things use maximum power is that "maximum power" is already low enough that you can barely provide decent coverage from an access point on one side of your apartment to a device on the other.
The reason the unlicensed spectrum is busy it that it's busy. Because there isn't enough of it.
And the reason licensed spectrum isn't as busy is that incumbents buy more spectrum than they strictly need because it's a mechanism of excluding competitors.
- high_priest 6y agoThere is an odd misconception in public, that "wireless" means full connection through two walls of rebar filled concrete... If you think that you can have pleasant, modern, net surfing experience without an AP in each room, then you can't say you know much about radio communications.
- brokencode 6y agoSurfing the internet is a pretty low bar for WiFi networks, and has been easily passed for 10+ years. The fact is that wireless signals do penetrate walls, and putting an access point in every room would probably do more harm than good in terms of increasing interference.
- posguy 6y agoWiMAX delivered a pleasant, modern experience without an AP in each room when that was operating at 2.5Ghz in the US, one tower would provide the coverage you describe for 2/3rds of a mile in any direction. Sadly, this 250+Mhz chunk of spectrum is now held by T-Mobile who uses only 40% to 60% of this spectrum for LTE and 5G coverage. There is plenty of spectrum left over to double the size of the 2.4Ghz ISM band used for WiFi, but the FCC has let Sprint/T-Mobile mispurpose this 2.5Ghz/2.6Ghz spectrum that was licensed for educational use only (explicitly for educational institutions to use for educational purposes like inter-building wireless links for campus TV stations).
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoThis ^. It's really hard to believe in the theory that the WiFi bands are poorly regulated and all the routers are shouting at each other and fill the spectrum, when your routers can barely reach through 2-3 rooms and 1 floor, with no nearby stations to blame for interference. The issue is obviously the transmit power which is already set so low (while perhaps being on the maximum allowed settings) that the reach is already a couple of rooms. How much more weak could it even get? To only reach within one room? What would be the point of WiFi then?
- wtallis 6y agoThe radius at which your WiFi AP causes interference with other networks is larger than the useful radius at which your client devices can maintain a decently fast connection speed. And for many APs with poor management of airtime, having a client device on the fringe of your coverage area can cause your router and that client device to both waste a disproportionate amount of airtime shouting at full TX power and a low data rate, maximizing the amount of interference you're causing to anyone else trying to make use of that channel.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoYes but what is your proposed alternative? It is still the lowest possible amount of interference in terms of tx power. If you decreased it the WiFi would not even be useful (if it would only work within a single room)...
- wtallis 6y agoYour claim that WiFi "can barely reach through 2-3 rooms and 1 floor, with no nearby stations to blame for interference" is simply not believable, when it's easily demonstrated that WiFi can cover a whole house and a good sized yard in a truly quiet RF environment. Without interference, covering a single apartment is no trouble at all unless the building materials for interior walls were maliciously chosen. I think you're simply misidentifying the cause of your connectivity issues, and blaming low transmit power when your real issue is that you have far more competing traffic on the 2.4GHz band than you think, and thus a shortage of quiet airtime. And lowering transmit power of everything (preferably done automatically and adaptively on a per-device basis) is the solution to the latter problem, while using higher transmit powers on everything can only make the latter problem much worse.