3 ms·
This seems like an over-engineered, half-assed solution like putting tape on a check engine light. There is no reason why properly working equipment should nee
by Nextgrid 6y ago
This seems like an over-engineered, half-assed solution like putting tape on a check engine light.
There is no reason why properly working equipment should need a periodic restart. Either his modem is bad and needs to be replaced or the other end (the DSLAM) is bad and bouncing the link temporarily fixes the problem as a side-effect.
- tinus_hn 6y agoMany of these devices are indeed bad and your choice is to replace them with another one that’s exactly as bad.
- robotmay 6y agoThe modem is fine; this is a very intermittent issue, like once every two months, if that, and caused further up the line. In the UK most of our internet infrastructure is, frankly, a bit shit, and maintained by a small subset of companies. These issues occur on every ISP I've had here, as unfortunately most rely on OpenReach's infrastructure. The reason I chose to automate it is that when I'm away from the house I want the connection to self-repair where possible, and resetting the modem is something basically everyone in the UK has to do sometimes to fix their line (seriously). Yes I could probably have A&A investigate it, but at some point, if it is an identifiable issue, they'd likely have to request an OpenReach engineer to work on something and then there's just the risk of it being made even worse. RevK's blog has plenty of interesting anecdotes about the issues with our internet infrastructure here: https://www.revk.uk/search/label/BT https://www.revk.uk/search/label/BT