2 ms·
Here's why I don't think your time-based analogy is correct. First of all, there's no geography on the internet. Being able to only speak from the top of a mou
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
Here's why I don't think your time-based analogy is correct.
First of all, there's no geography on the internet. Being able to only speak from the top of a mountain in Colorado in 1789 would have severely limited the potential of the population to hear you (essentially, to zero). Being able to speak "only" from one's own blog only makes discovery difficult, it does not limit people's access post-discovery.
Secondly: you appear to consider FB/Twitter etc. to be "virtual public squares". They demonstrably are not this. At the very least, it would require legislation to make them so.
Thirdly: even given the 1st amendment, even physical public squares have distinct limitations in how they can be used. For one thing, they do have geography. Any given public square is a long way from most of the population in a country of any size (even more so in countries like the USA that span thousands of miles), meaning that a particular public square is not effectively accessible to most people. As a corollary, most of the public will never be present in any actual public square.
They also have geometry: there are limits to how many people can speak in them at once.
Finally, in a public square you still cannot do the equivalent of yelling "fire" in a crowded theater, along with presence of simple noise limits for many possible public square locations. These things work very differently, or are non-existent, for written communications.
- ghaff 6y ago>Being able to speak "only" from one's own blog only makes discovery difficult, it does not limit people's access post-discovery. Exactly. And furthermore, while the big social media platforms help discovery and amplification, they're not that powerful (fortunately). They're not the difference between Faneuil Hall and a remote mountaintop. Posting on Facebook and Twitter is no guarantee of being heard. You can ignore all the major social media platforms and your ability to reach a wide audience is still incredibly democratized.
- spoonjim 6y ago> you appear to consider FB/Twitter etc. to be "virtual public squares". They demonstrably are not this. At the very least, it would require legislation to make them so. Yes, that is what I am saying. I am advocating for legislation to protect free speech on platforms like FB and Twitter in a similar (but not identical) way that the First Amendment protects free speech on a public street.