5 ms·
> This argument takes as an unstated axiom that the correct way to organize society is by having everyone in a role that strictly maximizes that system's assess
by pdonis 6y ago
> This argument takes as an unstated axiom that the correct way to organize society is by having everyone in a role that strictly maximizes that system's assessment of their economic output.
No, that's not the axiom. The axiom is that scarce resources should be allocated to their most productive uses. If the scarce resource of your time and energy can be more productive at building houses if you have a real job and donate a portion of your income to house building, than if you built houses directly, then that's how that scarce resource should be allocated.
Note that it is you doing the resource allocation here, not "the system". It is true that "the system" is very inefficient, but what it's inefficient at is providing people with opportunities to choose from to be more productive with the scarce resource of their time and energy. The way to make that more efficient is more free markets and less government regulation; but our society tends to be the other way around.
- eevilspock 6y ago> this way of organizing society is in fact itself the main cause of the human misery you're trying to eliminate. looks like this went completely over your head
- pdonis 6y ago> looks like this went completely over your head The fact that I disgree with the statement you quoted doesn't mean I didn't read it.
- CPLX 6y ago> most productive uses The problem comes when you try to define this phrase in a way that’s not a tautology. Our current economic system defines economic productivity to be the thing that generates the highest economic returns according to the rules of the system. Without an independently derived set of values the phrase doesn’t have any descriptive value. You could just as well be describing Bostrom’s paperclip maximizer, and I would suggest, in fact, that this is exactly what you’re doing.
- pdonis 6y ago> The problem comes when you try to define this phrase in a way that’s not a tautology. Economists solved that one along time ago: revealed preference. > Our current economic system defines economic productivity to be the thing that generates the highest economic returns according to the rules of the system. That's because our current economic system is not a free market, so instead of reflecting the revealed preferences of people making choices in a free market, it reflects the revealed preferences of politicians and financial institutions. There's no reason an economy has to work that way. Our does because it's driven by politics, not economics. > Without an independently derived set of values What people want is an independently derived set of values.
- CPLX 6y ago> Economists solved that one along time ago: revealed preference. I'm quite certain they didn't solve the problem of determining the correct long term value system for the human race. For context I have looked into the idea, I have a degree in Economics. We don't even have a perfect optimal strategy for the completely bounded game of chess yet. But somehow we've solved the problem of determining optimal strategy for the unbounded game of social and economic interactions between millions of independent actors? It's a pleasant thought, but no, we haven't. In real life what people are doing is making economic tradeoffs within a narrowly constrained section of a complex adaptive system within which no actor can do much more than guess at the prospective outcomes of their decisions. Or put another way, in economic terms how would an economic actor express a clear preference for a sequence of events that leads to a personal connection with someone who doesn't have any money, when they are not aware that's even a thing they can do?
- pdonis 6y ago> I'm quite certain they didn't solve the problem of determining the correct long term value system for the human race. Having a non-tautological way of capturing what "more productive uses" means, which is what I was responding to, in no way requires solving this much more difficult (and quite possibly unsolvable in that there might not be a single answer) problem. > in economic terms how would an economic actor express a clear preference for a sequence of events that leads to a personal connection with someone who doesn't have any money, when they are not aware that's even a thing they can do? If they're not even aware of the option, then the obvious thing to do is to make them aware of the option. Economists call this "creating a market". Enabling transactions to take place that couldn't take place before is one of the primary ways that new wealth is created. If this isn't happening, it's a sign that "the system" is, once again, not a free market; and the way to fix it is to make it more of a free market.