4 ms·
I remember hearing a talk by Philip Zimbardo, one of the main figures in the Stanford Prison Experiment. He concluded that 'evil' behavior is a product of a co
by AliAdams 15y ago
I remember hearing a talk by Philip Zimbardo, one of the main figures in the Stanford Prison Experiment.
He concluded that 'evil' behavior is a product of a combination of:
1) Mindlessly taking the first small step (eg Milgrim Experiment - the first 45volts couldn't be felt)
2) Dehumanization of others (giving them numbers in a prison)
3) De-individualisation of self (anonymity)
4) Diffusion of personal responsibility (saying a higher authority takes responsibility)
5) Blind obedience to authority
6) Uncritical conformity to group norms ('Everyone else is doing it')
7) Passive tolerance of Evil through Inactions and/or Indifference
8) New or unfamiliar situations (default actions don't apply so morality can become disengaged)
If you take this in the context of anonymity online, a substantial number of these factors are heavily involved(2,3,4 and potentially 1,7&8).
Anonymity has its advantages, but the encouragement of it diffuses people's responsibility, potentially encourages 'evil' action, and has subsequently risk of escalation...
I think my vote has to be transparency.
TED talk link:
http://www.ted.com/talks/philip_zimbardo_on_the_psychology_of_evil.html http://www.ted.com/talks/philip_zimbardo_on_the_psychology_o...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bugsy 15y agoFalse argument. De-individualisation of self is not anonymity. You are misrepresenting Zimbardo. Zimbardo would note that the tracking and surveillance we are talking about is the sort of thing that leads to atrocities.
- AliAdams 15y agoDehumanisation could be arguably not as applicable as some of the others but it isn't difficult to see parallels between a 'number in a prison' and an avatar; In a forum, the person can address the avatar without thought of the individual (human) behind it. I don't think my point was anything to do with surveillance. It is an interesting thought that Zimbardo would draw that conclusion though.