5 ms·
> Would the author be convinced to write the same article if the vaccine had been rolled out in January, and as a result the world suffered a second thalidomide
by pdonis 6y ago
> Would the author be convinced to write the same article if the vaccine had been rolled out in January, and as a result the world suffered a second thalidomide scandal?
A better comparison would be the swine flu vaccine in 1976. According to Wikipedia [1], about 45 million people were vaccinated and 362 of them suffered Guillan-Barre syndrome. Only 1 person died of the actual swine flu.
But that comparison actually makes Ben's case stronger. What if all 330 million people in the US had been vaccinated against COVID, and 1 in 100,000 of them (about the same proportion as for the 1976 vaccine) had serious side effects? Even if all of those side effects were fatal (and they wouldn't be), that would still be only 3,300 deaths--less than 1 percent of the US COVID death count currently reported. And even leaving aside that not all side effects would be fatal, that death count is clearly an overestimate, since in the US people would be given the choice whether to be vaccinated, and not all Americans would take it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_swine_flu_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1976_swine_flu_outbreak
- ivanbakel 6y agoThat's assuming that we have already seen the worst-case outcome for a rushed vaccine - which I don't think is true. Human medicine is sufficiently complex that its negative consequences are extremely ripe for black swan events. From that perspective, your argument falls in the same hole as Ben's: based on a retrospective view of bounded outcomes, you are trying to argue about unbounded future events. The real risk of a rushed vaccine rollout is not a repeat of the 1976 incident, but a medical disaster which is unpredictably and massively worse. Modern medical red tape exists precisely because of the risk of such disasters.
- pdonis 6y ago> That's assuming that we have already seen the worst-case outcome for a rushed vaccine Why don't you think the swine flu vaccine, which was much more rushed than the current COVID vaccine, was reasonably close to a worst case outcome? Or at least close enough to serve as an upper bound estimate for side effects from the COVID vaccine? > based on a retrospective view of bounded outcomes, you are trying to argue about unbounded future events That's just as true of our actual response to COVID--none of the so-called "experts" ever really considered where we are now as a possibility back when doing so would have mattered. > a medical disaster which is unpredictably and massively worse You mean like what actually happened with COVID? > Modern medical red tape exists precisely because of the risk of such disasters. No, it doesn't. Modern medical red tape exists because our approach to risk is extremely one-sided; we punish regulators only when something bad happens that we think they could have prevented, not when something good fails to happen that they could have enabled. For example, the FDA took ten years longer than European regulators to approve beta blockers for people at risk for heart attacks. A rough estimate is that 100,000 heart attacks were suffered by Americans during those ten years that could have been prevented. But no regulator got punished for allowing those 100,000 deaths to happen.
- ivanbakel 6y ago>Why don't you think the swine flu vaccine, which was much more rushed than the current COVID vaccine, was reasonably close to a worst case outcome? Or at least close enough to serve as an upper bound estimate for side effects from the COVID vaccine? Because 1. the negative side-effects of a vaccine are not a function of its rushed-ness - just like the injuries you get when a car runs you over are not proportional to how quickly you ran into the road without looking both ways. 2. I don't believe there is a sensible "upper bound" for medical side-effects, apart from the obvious one (everyone dies). Even if there was, you could not think to have safely established it through a single example. >we punish regulators only when something bad happens that we think they could have prevented, not when something good fails to happen that they could have enabled. This is also a very retrospective view. How would you establish when a regulator "failed to enable" new medicine? How could you decide that an entity had enough information in advance to make a decision that is obvious in retrospect? How would that entity then prove its historical ignorance in its own defense? Moreover, in the case of a disaster, how would it argue that its predictions were justified and the opportunity cost was too great to institute rigorous checks? These questions don't exist for the current system. A regulator that fails to catch some medical issue is not questioned on its intentions, but instead punished for simply not being rigorous enough. That cures are slow to roll out is just the price of safe medicine.
- sooheon 6y ago> A better comparison would be the swine flu vaccine in 1976. I don't see how we can know that this is representative of the worst possible outcomes.
- pdonis 6y agoWhy not? Note that I'm only using it as an estimate of what fraction of people would be expected to suffer serious side effects from a hastily developed vaccine. And it doesn't even need to be an overall worst case estimate, just a reasonable upper bound for the fraction of people who could be expected to suffer serious side effects from the COVID vaccine. Also note that the swine flu vaccine was not an RNA vaccine, it was an ordinary flu vaccine using, as far as I know, deactivated virus. RNA vaccines are inherently safer.
- 1996 6y ago> Even if all of those side effects were fatal (and they wouldn't be), that would still be only 3,300 deaths--less than 1 percent of the US COVID death count currently reported. No, because even if you assume no black swan (ex: zombie outbreak due to bad QC control of a new and untested mRNA technology) you are trading less old people death for more young people death. Why should I increase my low risk of death even by 5% to save an old person that has maybe 1 year left to live anyway?
- pdonis 6y agoI explicitly said in my post that people would be given the choice of whether or not to take the vaccine. You could simply refuse if you thought your risk from the vaccine was higher than your risk from COVID. But that old person whose life you so blithely discount might make a different choice. That's how a free country is supposed to work.
- 1996 6y agoYou assume people will be given the choice to get vaccinated. I believe it will be as "optional" as not having a SSN or a bank account: in theory possible, in practice with so many hurdles that people will relent. (ex: ban unvaccinated people from plane, train and bus interstate travel using the TSA for controls)
- ghiculescu 6y agoYour example will almost certainly happen in a few months. pdonis is just suggesting the same thing happen, but 6 months earlier.
- pdonis 6y ago> You assume people will be given the choice to get vaccinated. I assumed that they would in my hypothetical, yes. That's in a USA that was even capable of considering that option a year ago, the concept of a "free country" would be understood. In the actual USA of now, that concept is not understood; just as the article under discussion says, our current society combines the worst features of freedom with the worst features of authoritarianism, and gets the benefits of neither. Your hypothetical about how vaccination will be handled is an example of that. In other words, you are giving further evidence that the status quo in the USA is not working and needs to change.
- potatoz2 6y ago> What if all 330 million people in the US had been vaccinated against COVID, and 1 in 100,000 of them (about the same proportion as for the 1976 vaccine) had serious side effects? What your comment and the article both miss are the second order costs to safety failures: it's not only the immediate side effects that are a problem, but rather the change in behavior coming from the rest of the population. If you think that 330 million people would have gotten a vaccine that had not gone through any safety trial, even though a large portion of the population is still unsure after the phase 3 trials, I think you're deluding yourself. If, on top of that, you had widely reported and exaggerated ("free speech" at work) reports of side effects, the percentage of willing volunteers falls dramatically. Vaccinating 5% of the population in January doesn't really help.
- pdonis 6y ago> it's not only the immediate side effects that are a problem, but rather the change in behavior coming from the rest of the population. That's just as true of our actual responses to COVID. > If you think that 330 million people would have gotten a vaccine I explicitly said in my post that not all Americans would choose to take the vaccine. You are attacking a straw man. I was simply giving the highest possible upper bound to the expected number of deaths from vaccination. > a large portion of the population is still unsure after the phase 3 trials Yes, and why is that? Because despite all of our "respected" institutions saying that the vaccine is safe, many people don't believe them. Why not? Because they know that those same institutions lied to them, repeatedly--and not just in general, specifically during the whole COVID crisis. So why should people believe those institutions now? In other words, we have a problem with the status quo. > If, on top of that, you had widely reported and exaggerated ("free speech" at work) reports of side effects, the percentage of willing volunteers falls dramatically. Who would be reporting and exaggerating the side effects in a way that everyone would hear about? The mainstream media. In other words, the problem you describe is the status quo right now. So the status quo in this respect obviously needs to change since it makes us as a society stupid, unable to even consider courses of action that, in hindsight, would have been obvious and dramatic improvements over what actually happened.
- 6y ago