3 ms·
Waking up "earlier" doesn't really mean anything because you'd also go to bed "earlier". Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore since the invention of
by jedberg 6y ago
Waking up "earlier" doesn't really mean anything because you'd also go to bed "earlier". Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore since the invention of artificial light and blackout shades. It's a lot more dependent on when you turn off your screens and lights.
And kids have been going to school in the dark for a long time already. Talk to the Alaskans who go to school in the dark for a lot of the year. If anything, this would push people to move to a year round school schedule so we can take a longer winter break during the darkest part of the year.
- pkulak 6y ago> Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore So because we _can_ disregard the sun, we should? I have lights in my home, but the sun still shines in the windows in the morning and on my head while I walk to work. I'd rather have sane policy than worry about always having a portable SAD light available in the winter mornings.
- jedberg 6y agoOne hour either way won't make a difference. If you need a SAD light, you'll need it with either time zone. Keep in mind that even with our existing time zones, people can live near one edge or the other, where there is already almost an hour difference between when the sun comes up locally.
- pkulak 6y agoI still contend that it _does_ matter. As someone north of the 45th, if we're adding daylight somewhere, I want it added when my body is supposed to be waking up, not going to sleep.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut that's just not true? Getting one more or less hour of sleep can make a huge difference to your health and well-being.
- runarberg 6y ago> Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore since the invention of artificial light and blackout shades Is there any research that shows this? I’m not aware of any. In fact there are social reasons people might stay up late. It is a mistake to ignore that. They had this discussion in Iceland recently (which is on permanent DST; and with heavy population centers way north of Alaskan population centers) and health officials were pretty keen on moving to standard time precisely because teenagers have a hard time waking up so often before sunrise. Yes a big part of the year will always be before sunrise, however on standard that part is shorter.
- jedberg 6y ago> Is there any research that shows this? Yes, a lot. It's well summarized here: https://justgetflux.com/research.html https://justgetflux.com/research.html
- runarberg 6y agoThis is not exactly what we are talking about. Yes artificial blue light disrupt our natural sleep rhythm. Yes there is research that shows this fact. But, that does not mean that we are not effected by the sun. This research would need to show that blinds and artificial blue light would be sufficient to replace natural sunlight for setting the sleep rhythm to a healthy level. The existence of flux actually suggests the opposite is true, and people need software to prevent artificial blue light from disrupting the sleep rhythm.