9 ms·
This is the wrong direction, we should be on standard time year round! Daylight saving time gives you more daylight during the hours people are awake, but only
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
This is the wrong direction, we should be on standard time year round! Daylight saving time gives you more daylight during the hours people are awake, but only because it forces everyone to wake up earlier!
We already have major issues with e.g. making teenagers wake up earlier than most of their bodies are tuned for at that age. How much worse is it going to be if they have to get up an hour earlier in the winter? (Remember: what our bodies consider "early" is dependent on when the sun rises, and not the numbers we put on our clocks.)
And just to top it off, you'll be forcing a lot of kids to walk to school in the dark.
---
Edit: To be clear, it's not just children!
On weekends and holidays when people don't have to work, how much of the population do you think wakes up right when the sun rises, in order to maximize their daylight? I certainly don't have any data on this, but I would guess a large majority take the opportunity to sleep in.
Having extra daylight seems really nice at first, and it is. Unfortunately, shifting clocks doesn't actually create more sun, it just creates a societal mandate. My view is that we already start our workdays too early, particularly when you take commute times into account.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoEven with daylight savings time they're still getting up "earlier than their bodies are tuned for" And considering that they'd be getting hundreds of hours more daylight after their working day for the entirety of their adult lives it seems like a more than fair trade. Teenagers are far more resilient than young kids when it comes to this kind of thing. Extending the portion of the year that parents can let younger kids recreate outdoors in daylight has far more societal benefit than whether a teenager is 10% more irritable. The teenager problem could also be solved by letting them go to school on their own and decoupling their school timing from adults work schedules.
- runarberg 6y ago> Extending the portion of the year that parents can let younger kids recreate outdoors in daylight has far more societal benefit. Are you sure? Have you done the research? They had this discussion in Iceland recently and I think they found this point inconclusive. I think health officials still favored moving out of permanent DST into permanent standard because they know the health benefits of good sleeping, and they know that many children are sleep deprived.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> They had this discussion in Iceland recently and I think they found this point inconclusive. Iceland is significantly farther north than the northernmost point in the continental US, so what is best on-balance for Iceland on a matter that has to do with the relation between social schedules and the sun is not necessarily a guide to what is appropriate in the US, even if we assume the correctness of the judgement in Iceland. Which is not to say that you are wrong to question the evidence, only that “Iceland found…” is itself of not much value in a discussion of US policy on the issue.
- runarberg 6y agoYou are right, public health experts need to go over the available data, and study whether changing to permanent DST might lead to more damage then good in for the health of the general population. There are reasons to doubt that the benefits of extra sunlight in the evening is not worth the potential sleep deprivation. This needs to be studied in the effected areas before a decision is made.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAnd to start with, how is the fact that people in the western end of a timezone get an average of 19 minutes less sleep? This was linked by another commenter, and I think it's pretty strong evidence: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167629618309718 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01676...
- creaturemachine 6y agoExactly. The problems with teens are solved once they age into adulthood. The kids are alright.
- andlarry 6y agoI’d rather have more daylight in the afternoon than bend time around a poorly chosen schedule set by schools. You make a compelling argument for the schools starting later, they should do that.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoSchools should start later. But those times don't exist in a vacuum—for obvious logistical reasons, you generally want the kids to be in school before the parents have to be at work.
- andlarry 6y agoHigh schools here start at 8:15, it’s earlier if you have a bus. How late is the proposal? More importantly, why tie recent science (which can change) about the high school population with our standard of time. Solve that problem separately.
- jedberg 6y agoWaking up "earlier" doesn't really mean anything because you'd also go to bed "earlier". Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore since the invention of artificial light and blackout shades. It's a lot more dependent on when you turn off your screens and lights. And kids have been going to school in the dark for a long time already. Talk to the Alaskans who go to school in the dark for a lot of the year. If anything, this would push people to move to a year round school schedule so we can take a longer winter break during the darkest part of the year.
- pkulak 6y ago> Our bodies don't really time to the sun anymore So because we _can_ disregard the sun, we should? I have lights in my home, but the sun still shines in the windows in the morning and on my head while I walk to work. I'd rather have sane policy than worry about always having a portable SAD light available in the winter mornings.
- jedberg 6y agoOne hour either way won't make a difference. If you need a SAD light, you'll need it with either time zone. Keep in mind that even with our existing time zones, people can live near one edge or the other, where there is already almost an hour difference between when the sun comes up locally.
- pkulak 6y agoI still contend that it _does_ matter. As someone north of the 45th, if we're adding daylight somewhere, I want it added when my body is supposed to be waking up, not going to sleep.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut that's just not true? Getting one more or less hour of sleep can make a huge difference to your health and well-being.
- runarberg 6y ago
- nullc 6y agoIf the time is not shifting all the time, opening and closing times can be adjusted. DST doesn't make anyone wake up at any particular time. Either way is probably fine but daylight time applies for more of the year, so this is a smaller change. Next step: to abolish leap seconds.
- falcor84 6y ago>Next step: to abolish leap seconds. In favor of what? Having the day just drift?
- nullc 6y agoYes. It will take roughly 4000 years to have an hour drift absent leap seconds. In 4000 years we can adjust all the timezone definitions by 1 hour, if we even still care about how close noon is to solar noon. The once per 4000 year adjustment could be planned tens or hundreds of years in advance (just less than 1000 years in advance, for accuracy reasons). Timezone differences/changes are already handled pretty well by existing systems too, so it isn't the case that extensive new plumbing would be required for this. In exchange we save tens (to hundreds) of millions of dollars a year that are spent on preparing for, managing, and suffering from leap second disruption, building systems that are tolerant of 'time' being discontinuous or even non-monotone. We avoid de-synchronizations from systems which handle leap seconds differently. We also gain the ability for independent atomic time to keep subsecond accurate civil times without some costly to obtain (and often dubiously secure) date feed of unpredictable leap seconds -- something that will likely become more relevant as solid state optical atomic clocks become something commercially producible. At the moment we appear to be moving in the direction of a negative leap second. If one occurs the disruption will likely be substantially greater than the typical leap second disruption (which is still significant-- and growing the longer we go without a leap second). I hope we abolish the leap second before a negative leap second is issued, but if we do not I hope that it will at least be the last leap second.
- philwelch 6y agoAlso, in 4000 years, the majority of the population won't even be living on Earth anymore.
- martincmartin 6y ago> what our bodies consider "early" is dependent on when the sun rises, and not the numbers we put on our clocks. It's more of when we turn on the lights in the house. The lightbulb has messed with our sleep cycle for a long time, e.g. causing people to stay up later than they did in the days of kerosene lamps.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoSee: https://justgetflux.com/research.html https://justgetflux.com/research.html Artificial lights certainly mess with our clocks, but not to the same extent as the sun, because they have different wavelengths.
- chr1 6y agoMost often our bodies see lot more artificial light than than natural, so numbers on clock have much more power than they used to.
- pkulak 6y agoI hate switching clocks, but I think I'd hate permanent DST even more. If I had a vote, I'd actually vote against this and at least keep standard time around for the winter.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoPeople don't spend most of their lifetime as young teenagers. The majority of the US population are not young teenagers. It's imbalanced to make the entire country deal with a time change just for them. Also, everything in your post would be addressed if school would simply start later, like at 9 or 10am.
- warent 6y agoIf school starts later then that means work for adults has to start later too. Which means modifying public transportation schedules and business hours. What exactly is "simple" about any of this?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> If school starts later then that means work for adults has to start later too. Why? Teenagers can get themselves to school can't they?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAt 13, when most kids start high school? I'd say a large majority of children at that age are able to (at minimum) wait alone for a school bus†, but not all of them. I'm very much in favor of giving kids more freedom at younger ages, for privileges well above waiting alone for a bus. But I think it depends on the kid, and schools are for everyone. † Assuming there is a school bus.
- jjk166 6y agoSo the very few kids that can't wait at home for a later bus take an earlier bus and wait at school. Not very complicated.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYour district has two buses? We never did growing up, and I don't think it's too common.
- CarVac 6y agoI want evening sun more than I want morning sun.
- runarberg 6y agoYou think you do, but I’m not sure you do, and I know you wouldn’t if you were a teenager forced to wake up before sunrise a big part of the year. Source: I was a teenager in a place that observed permanent DST in a heavy north latitude.
- kibwen 6y agoAs a teenager in a place with "normal" DST observance I woke up at 5:50 every day; trust me, I didn't see the sun anyway.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoHave you considered waking up an hour earlier? Unlike the reverse (where you have the start of the workday as a deadline), there's likely nothing to stop you from shifting your day to start and end an hour sooner!
- CarVac 6y agoMy issue is that work ends at 5pm and the sun is already down.
- gregkerzhner 6y agoEven if your schedule is flexible, other people's schedules aren't. This means that if I want to shift my schedule to wake up earlier to take advantage of the morning light, I either have to miss out on evening social activities (lets say an 8pm dinner), or miss out on sleep.
- rosseloh 6y agoBusiness hours. I'm at work from 8AM to 6PM five days a week. Near the winter solstice, the sun sets around 4:30-5:30. Getting up earlier would just make me have to go to bed earlier. It's dark either way.
- kshacker 6y agoAny state can choose to go back to standard time today ... without any approval from the Feds because that is codified in law.
- axaxs 6y agoThank you. This is what's missing in the whole argument. They can already go back to standard...what Florida wants is the currently non-existent option to go full time DST. Most states want full time DST.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoIt's problematic for one state to move by itself though. I live in NYC, so if New York adopted permanent standard time, we'd spend half the year in a different timezone than New Jersey. I don't think I'd be in favor of that, even though in aggregate I very much want year-round standard time.
- kstrauser 6y agoYou are absolutely, 100% right about this. I am astronomically offended at the idea of "midday" meaning "an hour before the sun is at its highest". That's just wrong. If we're doing away with DST, so be it. I mean, it'll be horrible in the winter when sunrise is at like 9AM (or in the summer when it sets at 8PM, depending on which option you choose), but I understand the arguments. But if we get rid of it, permanent standard time is the only sane choice.
- kibwen 6y agoSolar noon is already far removed from 12-o-clock; up to 30 minutes in either direction for an average-sized timezone and even further for wide timezones like EST (solar noon is 12:50 in Boston in the summer). What matters much more than solar noon is sunrise and sunset; let's focus discussion on that.
- kstrauser 6y agoRight, but it's 12 on average (with an average half-hour displacement in either direction). I sincerely disagree that sunrise and sunset are more important. We can shift business hours, which would probably look like the federal government changing its hours and everyone else following. I think that's much more logical than saying "eh, we're going to arbitrarily pick solar noon to be 1PM now so that the big hand on the clock will point to a number we find aesthetically pleasing".
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI have always claimed that the early-risers ruined it for the rest of us. They got up early one day and decided to throw the rest of us under the bus.
- icedchai 6y agoEveryone is different, but DST / summer time seems more natural for me. I prefer more daylight in the evenings. The dark days of standard time, like December through March, are particularly brutal. Teenagers should start school later anyway. I think that is a different issue.
- partiallypro 6y agoYear round Standard Time sounds absolutely horrible. I would much rather prefer year round DST or just what we have now with clock shifting. I actually think what we have now isn't as bad as people make it out to be.
- jedberg 6y ago> I actually think what we have now isn't as bad as people make it out to be. Out of curiosity, do you have children? I didn't think it was so bad until we started having kids in the family. They do not adjust well to time zone changes.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Remember: what our bodies consider "early" is dependent on when the sun rises, and not the numbers we put on our clocks. Presumably this is only relevant to people who live with no household lights? > And just to top it off, you'll be forcing a lot of kids to walk to school in the dark. Is this an inherent problem? People manage this in the far north and south all the time.
- carabiner 6y agoIt does increase car crashes for teenagers. It seems like schools should move their start times to be a 1-2 hours later, while DST should be made year-round. How adults would then help their kids get ready for school before work though, I don't know.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> This is the wrong direction, we should be on standard time year round FFS, this is why we have to change clocks twice a year. It’s like the left or right side of the road debate. Which side you drive on doesn’t matter. Agreement is what matters. We don’t have agreement on time because everyone has their pet argument for why this or that time standard has some marginal benefit for a given slice of the population. Meanwhile, we can all agree on that those marginal benefits pale in comparison to the measured harms of changing clocks twice a year. We have a bill. It’s taken work. The choice isn’t daylight time or standard time. It’s this bill gets through the House (and is likely ignored by the Senate) or we punt the issue for a generation. Arguing we picked the wrong side of the coin is a point for the latter. (If you prefer kids walking to school in the light, just change the school hours.)
- nobody9999 6y ago>We don’t have agreement on time because everyone has their pet argument for why this or that time standard has some marginal benefit for a given slice of the population. Meanwhile, we can all agree on that those marginal benefits pale in comparison to the measured harms of changing clocks twice a year. I'm confused. You contradict yourself from one sentence to the next. Can we not agree, or are we all in agreement? I say it's the former, not the latter.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> FFS, this is why we have to change clocks twice a year. It’s like the left or right side of the road debate. Which side you drive on doesn’t matter. Agreement is what matters. If my options are to either switch clocks twice a year, or to be at work by the equivalent of 8 am in the winter, I'd much rather switch clocks. It's not even close, either. I'm scared of these permanent DST bills.
- wnoise 6y agoFeel free to argue that your employer should have different hours in the winter. Don't make the rest of society alter their schedule and complicate timekeeping for that though.
- echelon 6y agoMore daylight is better for business and workers. It makes time after work more enjoyable. Winter is depressing because it's dark during our leisure hours. This bill gives us an extra hour to enjoy. This is the correct decision.
- runarberg 6y agoIs it? They did claim this back in the 60s, however the logic seemed a little handy to be believable. Some armchair logic would say it is a mistake to ignore sleep-deprived workers when measuring what is “good for business”. It is also a mistake to ignore the health impact of teenagers that are forced to wake up before sunrise bigger part of the year now. My armchair logic says that you should expect a rise in depression, especially among teenagers. And that seems kind of bad for business, when workers have to deal with their teenage children being more depressed.
- echelon 6y agoTeenagers are a small percentage of the population. The solution for them is to let them sleep in later, and potentially start school as late as 11 am - that's independent of what this bill does. Restaurants, for example, would love for an extra hour of daylight. It brings patrons in an extra hour.
- runarberg 6y agoSo we should potentially sacrifice the health of a large portion of the working class and school children so that restaurants could have more business? It sounds a little unfair.
- echelon 6y agoNo. Kids should wake up later and go to school later. It's a totally separate issue. By your same argument, the health of workers faced with depression from getting off work at night is also worth noting. I don't have a compelling paper to cite, but I can say that anecdotally everyone I know and talk with about DST hates wintertime hours.
- ironmagma 6y agoWith standard time, if children are participating in outdoor social activities (band, crew, etc.), those have to be moved to the morning, forcing them to wake up even earlier. Daylight saving allows them to do those after school.
- npsimons 6y agoI really like having sunlight after work, but as a teenager in high school, we had "zero hour" marching band practice before the sun rose, and over one hundred students had no problem making rehearsals. I think making the argument that everyone should be forced to cater to a special interest group is not the way to go, and I strongly believe that school start times should be adjusted, and work shifts should be flexible too. Too much regimenting with a one size fits all approach is the problem, not DST
- ironmagma 6y agoI too suffered through zero hour class in high school, and it was completely miserable and likely led to permanent sleep deprivation damage in my case. The fact that hundreds of people did something does not imply that it was harmless. This is nothing more than anecdote vs. anecdote, when we have real research that suggests later start times are better. https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/features/schools-start-too-early.html https://www.cdc.gov/sleep/features/schools-start-too-early.h... I agree flexibility is good, but it’s impossible to enforce by definition, and nothing is going to magically make it happen, whereas a law does make it happen.
- avalys 6y ago> Remember: what our bodies consider "early" is dependent on when the sun rises, and not the numbers we put on our clocks. I'm sure there's a contribution, but obviously the effect is small given that the length of the day varies by ~6 hours throughout the year, for pretty much all the US? And we all sit inside all day in artificial lighting anyway? Kids don't give a shit about walking to school in the dark. I know, as someone who was recently a kid and resented winter "daylight wasting time", I would much rather have had more hours of daylight in the afternoon when I was finished with school and could actually do fun stuff outside, rather than useless daylight in the morning while I'm sitting on the bus or in a classroom at 7:30 AM. And as an adult I feel the same about work.
- TheGoddessInari 6y agoPeople forget how cold it is an hour earlier in the middle of winter in most of the US.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjk166 6y agoSchools and buses and workplaces are heated.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYou have to wait for the bus outside. And a lot of children in the US still have to either walk to school, or walk to a school bus stop (which isn't their house).
- jjk166 6y agoWait inside for the bus Heat the bus stop Drive kids to the bus stop Move bus stop to a more convenient location Wear appropriate clothing for being outside in the winter. There are a lot of ways to limit a few people being cold besides shifting all of society to a suboptimal schedule, and it's not like it's balmy an hour later anyways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoHonestly, for teenagers it's a separate issue, which should be fixed simply by changing the start times for high schools to be a couple of hours later. It shouldn't be confused with the DST issue. And if we can get DST all year round (which I'm personally all-for), it could help be the impetus to finally shift high school times. The fact of the matter is, our sleep schedules are determined largely by our school/work schedules. Simply from the popularity of DST in the summer, it seems clear that people do prefer for society to coordinate to wake up an hour earlier in order to have an extra hour of daylight at the end of the day. Here in the northeast, it's horrible in the winter when it's dark by 4:30 pm. For a lot of people, it's a huge life upgrade to change that to 5:30 pm.
- throwaways885 6y agoUnfortunately teenager and adult hours are forced to be synchronised, so schools just cannot open later.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Unfortunately teenager and adult hours are forced to be synchronised, No, they aren’t. Even with the progressive infantilization of children over the last several decades, its still generally widely accepted that children over 12 can be left alone for a few hours at a time. Though shifting the standard workweek to 30 hours and adjusting to that by moving the standard start time forward by two hours wouldn’t be a bad idea, either.
- runarberg 6y agoEven if you are right, adults and teenagers still sync around dinner time, they still sync around social activities, etc.
- freeopinion 6y agoA lot of people are comfortable with children coming home from school a couple hours before their parents get home. Many of those people are much less comfortable with children waking up and going to school a couple hours after their parents leave for work.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoBrazil did this recently, people have been complaining to the news that the sun has been coming up at 4:30 am this summer.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoThe problem with standard time year around is that in the more northern areas it'll be light at ~4:30AM in June. Maybe we could meet in the middle and compromise by 1/2 an hour?
- jghn 6y agoIt depends on where you are. For instance once could make the argument that a good chunk of the northeast should either be permanently EDT or Atlantic standard time. Meanwhile, for folks on the western edge of the eastern timezone that'd be a silly proposition
- CoolGuySteve 6y agoWhy not move to the other side of your timezone if that's an issue for you? You will effectively shift your solar time by an hour or more.
- runarberg 6y agoThese comments stating: “just move if you’re unhappy”, are not helpful, and infact quite insulting. They remind me of “if you’re not happy with our immigration policy just move somewhere else”. It is completely ignoring how people actually live.
- cataphract 6y ago> We already have major issues with e.g. making teenagers wake up earlier than most of their bodies are tuned for at that age. Forget the teenagers, standard time kills people. People are more tired in the afternoon and have more accidents if the sun is already down. Summer time actually saves lives.
- runarberg 6y ago> standard time kills people What is this, a high school competitive debate? I could just as easily argue that permanent DST kills people. People are sleep deprived, and stressed, and have higher rate of depression, etc. I think these claims are best supported by public health experts that actually use studies to back up their claims. In fact we should ask public health experts if this move is cleaver instead of leaving it up to the politicians to decide what is best for us.
- tzs 6y agoAnother factor is that morning and evening commutes are quite different. The evening commute is more spread out over time. In the morning, you have adults going to work, kids going to school, delivery trucks rolling out, people going to get supplies they will need for the day, people doing morning exercise, and so on. Sleep is a big synchronizer that tends to get most of us aligned at the start of the day. By the evening rush, most of those people other than adults who went to work are already home. Also, the times people start the evening commute tends to vary more than the times they start the morning commute. Add in to this that morning weather and evening weather are quite different. Mornings tend to be colder than evenings, as they are coming off the sunless night. This means that hazardous driving, biking, and even walking conditions are more likely in the morning than the evening. This won't make a different in Florida (where the author of this bill is from), but it sure makes a difference when you get into the northern parts of the continental US. Put this together and whenever you have the morning commute before the sun is up you are combining the most number of people, the greatest mixing of pedestrians and bicycles with cars, and the highest chance of bad conditions (icy roads and sidewalks, poor visibility). When you have the evening commute after the sun has set, it sucks, but you have less traffic of all kinds and better road and weather conditions. Thus, if you have to have one of the commutes outside of daylight, it is going to be better to have that be the evening commute.
- munificent 6y agoThe sun doesn't care what arbitrary numbers you assign to points in time. Just change all of the school and office start times when you make the switch and you get the exact result you want. Numbers are arbitrary labels for points in time. You can just assign different labels.
- MarkLowenstein 6y agoWhat is lovely about this debate is that people who don't like getting up early think that DST gives them a magic extra hour of daylight, so they push hard for permanent DST. At the same time, they think that people advocating 8-4 working hours or earlier school hours are draconian ascetics. Yet what they get in both cases is exactly equivalent, other than which numeral you use when referring to the time.
- brummm 6y agoI disagree with this. The summer time is much, much better for my mental health. I am stuck working all day and the time of day when I want to and can enjoy daylight is after 5pm. Hence, the summer hours are much better.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut is that really daylight saving time though, or the fact that we just have more hours of daylight in the summer? I can't speak for your psyche (and you may well be a naturally early riser), but we know that having to wake up earlier decreases a lot of people's sleep overall, and that is also not good for mental health.
- npsimons 6y ago> And just to top it off, you'll be forcing a lot of kids to walk to school in the dark. That sounds like a problem of school starting too early. Honestly, I like having sunlight after work, so I can do things out of doors like bouldering. I don't need sunlight in the morning when I'm commuting to an office with no windows, or even if I'm working from my home office. > My view is that we already start our workdays too early, particularly when you take commute times into account. Again, this just sounds like some people need to be accommodated for time shifting their work days. There are those of us who naturally wake up with the sunrise, even when we don't have to, and getting up when it's dark to get to work early is routine for us. Offsetting working shifts by an hour (or more) would also help reduce traffic congestion. ETA: You sound like those people who insist that everyone has to work in an office building because otherwise they will be goofing off at home, neatly ignoring all the water cooler time wasters distracting everyone in the open office by talking about celebrities and sports. Not everyone has children. Not everyone is the same.
- frontiersummit 6y agoAgreed. A recent study indicates that living on the Western end of a timezone decreases sleep by 19 minutes on average, with an accompanying host of negative health effects. Permanent DST is the equivalent of shifting everyone one entire timezone west on the shortest days of the year. Also, many of the US timezones are too far west to begin with. Indianapolis is on Eastern Time, but it is approximately where the middle of Central Time should be. Putting it on permanent DST will make noon 2 hours late. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167629618309718 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01676...
- wdr1 6y ago> This is the wrong direction, we should be on standard time year round No federal law is needed for this. Each state can decide on its own to stay on standard time the full year. Notably Arizona still doesn't.
- WorldMaker 6y agoIt depends on which edge of a timezone you live on. Standard time makes more sense for the eastern most edges of timezones and Daylight time makes more sense for the western most edges of timezones (and people towards the exact center of timezones distrust both because they both don't work correctly to the sun), because timezones are hour-wide. Going back to 15-minute wide timezones would be extraordinarily painful, of course, but as someone in a city that partly defines the western edge of a timezone, I do sometimes wonder what life would have been like when the city had a 45-minute offset from its eastern edge counterparts back before railways standardized on hour-wide timezones.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoGeography definitely makes a difference, but I think that on average, society is currently optimized for early risers at the expense of late-risers. I've been trying to find this article all afternoon, and I finally remembered enough of the title: https://www.vox.com/2016/3/18/11255942/morning-people-evening-chronotypes-sleeping https://www.vox.com/2016/3/18/11255942/morning-people-evenin... The article largely thinks increased schedule flexibility is the solution, but I don't think that's every going to be practical for many types of work. But, we can at least make sure we don't make our world even more lopsided.
- WorldMaker 6y agoI don't disagree, I'm just pointing out that geography magnifies the early riser problem. Schedules set by early risers in the east in a timezone are "twice" as early for late risers in the west of that timezone. When the sun of your city is always 45-minutes to an hour behind the city that "leads" business in your timezone, even some of their late-risers start to look like early-risers with respect to sunlight hours.