10 ms·
81k UK-owned .eu domains suspended as Brexit transition ends
- wdb 6y agoIs there a list available of the suspended domains? :D Guess UK citizen can just use some random EU address? Luckily I only have settled status ;)
- K0nserv 6y agoI had the same thought. Presumably, as long as you hold one EU citizenship you're still eligible, even if you're also a UK citizen.
- arcticbull 6y agoGood thing I'm both. Now where's that list...
- tomc1985 6y agoSounds like an opportunity for domain squatters
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 6y ago> Guess UK citizen can just use some random EU address? Luckily I only have settled status ;) Many registrars offer proxy registration service.
- benbristow 6y agoOne of mine's been suspended. istheukstillinthe.eu Clearly it isn't anymore haha
- iso1210 6y agoIronically not including leave.eu - the instigators behind the entire process. Their domain is registered by a company in Ireland.
- gbil 6y agowell Ireland (Republic of) is still part of the EU so technically it makes sense EDIT seems like I'm down voted for pointing the obvious since the registar is indeed in Ireland... HN being more political than usual?
- berdario 6y agoI didn't downvote, but your wording is a bit weird: > still part of the EU It seems that you might be implying that leaving the EU is something natural/desirable/inevitable for Ireland
- gbil 6y agoMaybe(?) But I'm pretty sure if I've written "Germany is still part of the EU" I wouldn't get any down votes In any case the still was nothing more than to highlight that IE is part of the EU while UK is not anymore
- iso1210 6y agoThe point was that "Leave EU" - a group dedicated to leaving the EU and removing the rights of UK people to register a .eu domain - has itself got an eu domain which is unaffected by the leave process because it's registered via an EU company. Perhaps "hypocritically" rather than "ironically" may have been more accurate, but certainly would have been more political. To be honest I can't think of any other .eu domains other than leave.eu.
- thomasedwards 6y agoI want to believe you but their website says: Leave.EU Group Limited trading as Leave.EU. A company registered in England & Wales. Company Registration Number 9763501 Registered office: 2430/2440, The Quadrant, Aztec West, Almondsbury, Bristol. BS32 4AQ Edit: EURid says it’s registered to “BETTER FOR THE COUNTRY DIGITAL MARKETING SERVICES DESIGNATED ACTIVITY COMPANY” in Waterford, IE
- 6y ago
- akmarinov 6y agoSo now someone can see which are the most popular ones and reregister it when they become available in 2022?
- mfer 6y agoI can see it now... some companies providing a service where you can have an EU address to register a domain from the UK. These services already exist for other things.
- clort 6y agoSo naturally, there are some complaints > The Commission's announcement was met with severe criticism with .eu website owners claiming that revoking existing domains went against the right to property. which if this > EU regulations currently stipulate that .eu websites can only be allocated to EU citizens – regardless of their place of residence – as well as non-EU citizens and organizations established in a member state. is "the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth" then it seems to me that this revocation is somewhat premature. It could be argued, that these domains were allocated in accordance with the law and just because the status of the owner has changed, that does not require Eurid to deallocate them, which would expose them to legal repercussions if they simply chose to do that.
- OnlyOneCannolo 6y agoDoes "be allocated" mean "the act of allocating" or "being presently allocated"?
- axlee 6y agoTo me, it has to be "being presently allocated". Otherwise, any reseller based in the EU could act as middleman and make .eu available for any entity in the world by transferring the rights after registration, which goes obviously against the intent of the rule.
- sgc 6y agoThere are brokers of .eu domains that allow you to get a .eu address for the purpose. Of course it's a service and subscription, but it's trivial for anyone to get a .eu domain.
- CorruptedArc 6y agoImagine also if you had a domain run by multiple people. Only for the one its registered under to be a UK citizen. You get de-platformed and were given little to no warning to switch the registrant.
- jaymzcampbell 6y agoA couple of years ago I moved everything over to my brother who resides in Dublin just in case I lost my long standing domains. It seems I could in theory update this back to my home address in Northern Ireland given this: https://blacknight.blog/brexit-and-eu-domains-again.html https://blacknight.blog/brexit-and-eu-domains-again.html - does anyone know if that's actually the case? I found the potential loss of yet another part of my EU identity thanks to Brexit a real kick in the teeth :( Edit: I guess as I hold an Irish passport I'm entitled to own an EU domain. Though I remember messaging EurID at the time (https://twitter.com/EUregistry/status/1086252921380065285 https://twitter.com/EUregistry/status/1086252921380065285) and they didn't seem to know for sure - but that linked page now says a Union citizen, independently of their place of residence - so that probably covers me. I feel for any UK only citizen losing theirs :/
- egeozcan 6y agoThe sad thing is probably people registering the .eu domains are big supporters of staying in the EU.
- knolan 6y agoOur H2020 project page was affected in error. It’s back up now.
- itissid 6y agoSad bookends to a poorly thought out process. The trade deal with the EU was also kind of sad because it revolved around "territorial waters" for Fishing which is < 1% of the economy, while saying nothing of Services Sector and of course Immigration Control. The biggest challenge for the liberal politics in the coming decade is how to get ordinary people to weigh long term risks more intentionally, while not alienating them because of bad/heavy handed governance.
- oblio 6y agoI'm guessing the fishing debate was for political brownie points, à la US coal. You know, something obvious and easy to understand by the layperson.
- PoachedSausage 6y agoThat is how it appeared to me. Like Vultures fighting over bare bones. It would have been better if they had a agreed a 10 year moratorium on fishing in EU and UK water to let fish stocks recover.
- google234123 6y agoThat is disingenuous. There were many other issues. e.g. The EU also wanted other powers and wanted their courts to have jurisdiction over the UK.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIf you consider that the UK got an agreement on goods where we have a deficit but not one on services where we have a surplus then it doesn't look like a good outcome.
- mhh__ 6y agoI can feel the freedom already
- hinkley 6y agoBrexit feels like the Comedy Roast of William Shatner. It's supposed to be somewhat light-hearted, but Takei clearly had beef and he did not care if this was being recorded. Wait you guys didn't all like me the whole time? No, fucker, we did not.
- bagpuss 6y agoamazingly, Shatner stopped selling his Shatner merch to the UK as a result of Brexit https://news.sky.com/story/star-treks-william-shatner-threatens-uk-sales-boycott-over-red-tape-12105849 https://news.sky.com/story/star-treks-william-shatner-threat...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoOuch. I do have certain level of disdain for bureaucractic power and this appears to be a good reminder as to why. Then again, the sentiment in EU may be to punish Brexit by any means necessary.
- sime2009 6y agoIt's not punishment. It is just simply applying the same rules to the UK as other countries outside the EU. It is from a feeling of entitlement by some in the UK to complain about the rules they aggreeded to.
- cortexio 6y agoThe problem isnt Brexit, it's how the EU handles it. There's literally no reason to suspend those domains, just block them from extending it and creating new ones. Everyone happy. but.. nope... Let's just force shutdown these websites, just so we can tell other countries, see, this is what happens when u leave the EU. The EU is so pathetic.
- CydeWeys 6y agoBlocking renewals has the same ultimate result, just with added steps and a less clean process (because right now everyone whose domain has been suspended is FORCED to resolve it within the next 3 months, which is preferable to domains just randomly vanishing over the upcoming years as they expire).
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe problem IS Brexit. Without Brexit, none of this whole sorry mess occurs.
- dingaling 6y agoOr you could say that the act of tying eligibility for registering a domain to citizenship was the problem. Isn't the Internet meant to be supernational? Do bits have to stop for visa checks at borders?
- cromka 6y agoThe ccTLDs are maintained by the respective entities that own them. This has nothing to do with Internet being supranational, the DNS simply does not reflect that. In fact, it had been controlled via ICANN by the US for the longest time: https://newrepublic.com/article/117037/us-gives-iana-and-dns-control-icann https://newrepublic.com/article/117037/us-gives-iana-and-dns...
- thu2111 6y agoA big part of the justification for Brexit is because the EU is a crap bureaucracy that does arbitrary, self-harming and utterly unnecessary stuff like this all the time. It's totally in character for them to do this, which simply indicates why Brexit is a good idea.
- hanoz 6y agoThis is unbelievably petty and spiteful. The least they could do is grandfather in existing registrants and only enforce these requirements on transfer. I don't suppose many of their EU registrants realise they'd have to forfeit their domains if they ever decided to emigrate.
- cure 6y ago> I don't suppose many of their EU registrants realise they'd have to forfeit their domains if they ever decided to emigrate. That's false. EU citizens can own .eu domain names, regardless of where they live.
- hanoz 6y agoNot everyone resident in the EU is an EU citizen, and not every other country allows dual citizenship.
- berdario 6y agoIt's false, but there's confusion around it because the rules actually changed in October 2019 https://eurid.eu/en/news/new-eligibility-criteria/ https://eurid.eu/en/news/new-eligibility-criteria/ before, it was actually true
- MichaelZuo 6y agoIs there a database of EU regulations that is version controlled? i.e. so that one can know what all the rules were at a given point in time?
- CydeWeys 6y agoAnd that's why you don't use ccTLDs. Looking at you, everyone still using a .io TLD -- you never know what trouble might be lurking in the pipeline there.
- MrCatMrCat 6y agoCan anyone suggest a domain provider who offers good emergency support? (e.g. they pick up the phone). My current provider only does daytime email support. Combined with a 9hr timezone difference, this has meant trying to fix this .eu domain issue has now reached day 5.
- itsnot2020 6y agohttps://hover.com https://hover.com offers telephone support though it's not 24 hours, always been helpful though.
- ourcat 6y agoI lost mine. But we were told about this quite a long time ago now.
- andruby 6y agoDo you mind sharing when you were first told about this? Some people in this thread seem to think this was abrupt.
- ourcat 6y agoTue, 14 Aug 2018. Email from GoDaddy: Brexit is coming, and it brings changes to .eu domains like (mydomain).eu "Now that the UK has voted to withdraw from the European Union, the registry for .eu domains (EURid) has decided to revoke domains registered to UK residents, and prevent them from purchasing new ones. In light of this decision we will no longer offer .eu domains to UK residents. EURid may act as early as March 30, 2019, but the deadline might shift as Brexit negotiations continue. You still have options, though. You can either update your registrant address to one outside the UK, or replace your .eu domains with another option."
- ourcat 6y agoThen on Tue, 27 Nov 2018: "In 2016, the United Kingdom voted to withdraw from the European Union. Soon new .eu registrations will be restricted to any natural person, company or organization residing in or established in the European Union, Iceland, Liechtenstein or Norway. This means that customers in the UK will no longer be able to register new .eu domains. Plus, .eu domains that are currently registered to UK addresses will be revoked. These changes may take effect as early as March 30, 2019, but the deadline could shift as Brexit negotiations continue. In light of these new policies, we're no longer offering .eu domains to UK residents. We also urge UK residents with .eu domains to consider their options: either update your registrant information to an .eu-compliant address or replace any .eu domains with other available options. "
- rtsil 6y agoAt least since October 2020 for the new deadline. > On 1 October 2020, EURid has notified by email all UK registrants and their registrars that they will lose their eligibility as of 1 January 2021 unless they demonstrate their compliance with the .eu regulatory framework by updating their registration data before 31 December 2020. They could do so by indicating a legally established entity in one of the eligible Union Member States, or updating their residence to a Union Member State, or proving their citizenship of a Union Member State irrespective of their residence. https://eurid.eu/en/register-a-eu-domain/brexit-notice/ https://eurid.eu/en/register-a-eu-domain/brexit-notice/
- cleansy 6y agoI mean, "Brexit means Brexit", no? The ToS for .eu domains is not that clear about the fact that these are not to be considered property but there is an important point: > SECTION 9. RIGHTS GRANTED > 1. Upon registration of a Domain Name, the Registrant obtains a limited, transferable, renewable, exclusive right to use the Domain Name for the Term unless otherwise stated in the Rules. No other rights can be claimed by the Registrant except for those included herein. The key point here is: limited. This should indicate that a domain name is not property. On top of that UK .eu domain owners had 2 years time to figure things out. This whole article read like a big complaint about not doing long ago announced homework.
- ourcat 6y agoExactly. I was emailed back in 2018 about it. Multiple times. (by GoDaddy fwiw)
- thu2111 6y ago1. Changing your domain name isn't easy. You can easily lose PageRank, email addresses stop working, OAuth has to be reconfigured, it may lead to downtime, etc. 2. The .eu domain is practically deserted. Nobody cares about it. There's no real benefit to freeing up names in this TLD. Together, we see that this is a classic EU move - interpret the rules in whatever way is most spiteful towards anyone who doesn't play ball. They could have very easily decided that the eligibility matters at allocation time, and simply continued to allow pre-existing holders to use their domains. Or they could have steadily increased the prices to ease people out on their own pace. Or many other things. Instead they yank all of them simultaneously with no recourse: the worst possible outcome for everyone. Honestly though, I wonder what people who registered .eu domains were thinking. There's no real benefit to having one and the true nature of the EU Commission is not really a secret, albeit it's not covered by American media. If you willingly submit yourself to the Commission when you don't have to, you're almost signing up for some kind of abuse.
- lemonspat 6y agoWhen the new registrations begin (Jan 2022), hopefully the former owners moved off of them completely, before an attacker registers them, points the MX records, leading to mailbox collection and password resets. Without ownership, it might be hard to change other systems (DNS-based verification).
- asiando 6y agoIf you’re just a number, you’re treated like one. This kind of news worry me because we’re all just numbers in someone’s eyes. Legally this might have made sense, but what about the people that this change affects?
- PaulKeeble 6y agoShortly after the Brexit vote came back to leave I started the process of moving away from the EU domain we utilised. We spent about 2 years transitioning until almost all traffic was to the replacement and haven't used an EU domain since 2018. Most people only got told in 2018 that they would almost certainly loose them unless negotiations determined otherwise but I just thought it wasn't worth the risk.
- wolfretcrap 6y agoI want to ask what happens to those who are still getting under graduate degrees in UK who are originally from EU. Will they find it easier to get job in EU or will they be leaving UK?