7 ms·
Space things happening in 2021
- robin_reala 6y agoThe JWT launch and deployment is going to be terrifying. Peeking between my fingers for that one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hashmymustache 6y agoPicking Halloween is an interesting launch date. That said it’s hard to believe any timeline or budget at this point.
- nickserv 6y agoYes! Deployment in particular, as it's never been done before. Launch is on an Ariane 5, and those have become very reliable.
- bumby 6y agoThis part makes my nether-regions pucker: 307 single point failure components. I do not envy the reliability or systems engineers on that project. http://spaceref.com/news/viewsr.html?pid=51617 http://spaceref.com/news/viewsr.html?pid=51617
- koheripbal 6y agoThis data point is not useful without knowing the failure rate for each of them. For example, the Sun is a single point of failure for us each day. ...but the odds of the Sun being destroyed per day are so infinitesimally small, that it's not meaningful to say I have a single point of failure each day for the next 20,000 days.
- vlovich123 6y agoThat’s a logical albeit unhelpful argument. My observation of how engineering is done and the economic pressures involved make me think that such cost cutting is inevitable. So the short term “we’ll just make this single point of failure component more reliable” is not an effective strategy as “design in depth” that assumes any single component will fail. It can be more expensive but in some ways (maintenance, up-front cost) but can also be cheaper since the individual components don’t need as much testing/validation/reliability. That being said, engineering is all about trade offs so the takeaway I have from something like this is blind faith/hope that the domain experts make these decisions better than an outsider (me) and that when mistakes are made they’re corrected in the longer-term. I don’t know a better way than that.
- bumby 6y agoThis is fair. Single point of failures denote a severity (loss of mission) but risk is defined as severity x probability. To extend your example to the extreme, everything on the JWST has a failure probability > 0, even the systems with redundancies. What ends up happening is each failure is plotted on a severity x probability matrix with a resulting score. Depending on the requirements, the exact probability category thresholds may be defined quantitatively (e.g. 1/10,000 chance) or they may be more qualitative (e.g., ‘likely’ vs. ‘may happen’ vs. ‘improbable’). The resulting risk has to accepted by someone (usually a program or project manager). To your point, they have obviously found each to be an acceptable (but perhaps uncomfortable) risk. Some projects will define the acceptable level of risk at the requirements stage to drive design (e.g., no single points of failure that can result in loss of crew). With all that said, it is still an abnormally high number of single point failures in a complex system and reliability is generally not linearly related to complexity (just think about what happens to cyclomatic complexity as you add more variables and the resulting number of test cases you need for full coverage) In my opinion, the real dangerous part of this process is that humans are notoriously poor at thinking in probabilistic terms. Challenger, Columbia, EVA 23 etc. are all attributable, in part, to bad assessments of probability. Human biases are all but guaranteed to affect these probabilities and thus affect our understanding of the associated risk.
- tedd4u 6y agoI happen to know someone working in the area of reliability and testing on JWT. Personally, I couldn't take the stress. The design as you point out seems to be unlike other missions where the very design limits failures. My understanding is the people who made these decisions are long gone, leaving the current team to make it work or $20B and two decades will be flushed down the drain. I think people on this team are aging at 5x real-time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nickff 6y agoI am quite skeptical that it will take place this year. The project is already 14 years late and ~20x over the original budget. I expect them to announce a shocking delay later this year, blaming COVID. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope#Cost_and_schedule_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope#Cos... https://xkcd.com/2014/ https://xkcd.com/2014/
- koheripbal 6y ago14 years "late" is not exactly accurate as the initial time projections were based upon full funding from the initial moments of the project - which was never a realistic goal. Similarly, the 20x budget overrun number makes two errors - 1. that the initial numbers were in today's inflation adjusted dollars (which they were not), and that project scope remained exactly the same - which it has not. Numerous aspects of the telescope have been enhanced/improved to accommodate additional science.
- nickff 6y agoThe project was supposed to take 10 years and is already at 24! That's simply atrocious, and saying that they didn't get everything they wanted to is a poor excuse. I ran the numbers for inflation adjustment, and 500MM in 1997 is equivalent to ~811MM today. That means the project is between 12x-20x over budget... not much of an improvement in my mind.
- black6 6y agoAt least the Ariane 5 is a proven launch vehicle. Artemis 1 is going to be the real knuckle-biter, if NASA defies all odds and meets schedule.
- _ph_ 6y agoI am looking so much forward to this. Hubble has been launched in 1990 and look what insane amount of great science and pictures it brought. JWT should be a huge step upwards from this, especially as it looks into different wavelengths. This could deliver an amazing amount of science. I also hope, that if the Starship becomes operational, it could deliver much larger telescopes to space and start a new era of astronomy.
- ackbar03 6y agoI really feel space tech is gonna be the next big thing going forward, but I have zero clue about how to get involved. It seems like one of those things where you really need to either be some government agency or have a PhD in it or something.
- mulcahey 6y agoWell it depends what you mean by “involved” but there are plenty of “new space” companies hiring software engineers - from real time Linux to web dev
- avmich 6y agoIt's both pretty easy and insanely hard. Insanely hard - from an engineer prospective - because there is a big gap between software disciplines and, ughm, "the real world". When you're pushing bits, today it's easy to forget about the times when computers were quite unreliable, from the hardware point of view. Bad contacts? Unreliable memory bits? Overheating parts? Magnetic tape which loses data and paper media which breaks? Today most of this is factored away and engineers largely operate with logic. Try to do hardware projects - even easy Arduino-based designs will give you a glimp of difficulties you're going to get with space technology, and if you're trying something modestly interesting... Pretty easy is because "rocket science isn't rocket science". It's technology invented more than a century ago - converging-diverging nozzle was invented about 150 years ago, about 120 years ago Tsiolkovsky wrote about liquid hydrogen fuel and multistage rockets, more than 90 years ago Goddard flew his first rockets, almost 80 years ago von Braun was already working on V-2, and this year we're celebrating 60th anniversary of Spootnik. A great deal of efforts went into perfection of rocketry, and now we know a lot - that's a big part of the reason why SpaceX moves so fast - and can do a lot. Now you can have a nano-launcher startup for less than 100 million dollars - may be way less - which just couple of decades ago is unheard of. More, there are competitions - X Prize for flight 100 km up, Northrop Grumman Lunar Lander Challenge, Google Lunar Prize, and now, say, NASA's https://breaktheicechallenge.com/ https://breaktheicechallenge.com/ - where you can participate with much smaller barrier to entry. The webinar from this last challenge - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UXgdEDBTPJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UXgdEDBTPJE - contains references on other competitions NASA is hosting. So, to conclude, if you're an engineering mind, especially capable of working outside of applied math of programming, the possibilities are certainly there to try in growing space industry.
- kylebarron 6y agoOne notable omission is the launch of Landsat 9 [0]. Landsat 9 is expected to be launched by NASA in September 2021 and will hopefully continue the Landsat program's uninterrupted, nearly 50-year remote sensing history [1]. [0]: https://landsat.gsfc.nasa.gov/landsat-9/landsat-9-overview https://landsat.gsfc.nasa.gov/landsat-9/landsat-9-overview [1]: https://landsat.gsfc.nasa.gov/landsat-1-3/landsat-1 https://landsat.gsfc.nasa.gov/landsat-1-3/landsat-1
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoThe orbital debris problem mentioned at the end is really scary in the medium-long term. We're used to mistakes being relatively self correcting down here. A bridge falls over, and it's terrible, but when it hits the ground, it's "stable" again. Then you can learn from your mistakes and try again. With orbital debris, on the other hand, if there was some day a chain reaction, could take ages to sufficiently deorbit, like a building that keeps falling for years or decades (or even generations! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome)
- inglor_cz 6y agoWe will need a cosmic vacuum cleaner one day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TrainedMonkey 6y agoWon't work because cosmos is mostly vacuum already :) But there are some neat tricks with lasers that can help https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom When really scares me is how easy it would be for a malicious actor to kickstart the process. Imagine a cylinder filled with ball bearings painted black and an explosive device in the middle. Launch that to a mega-constellation altitude and at the very least that orbital altitude is no longer inhabitable.
- inglor_cz 6y agoCould perhaps ferromagnetic pieces be collected using a giant magnet?
- TrainedMonkey 6y agoYup, magnetic drag is a definitely a thing, see https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2020SW002472 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/202... . To have a real effect the magnet would need to be ginormous, specifically effectiveness would be proportional to a ratio of distance between magnet poles and the target object. The distance between poles is important because if both poles are equidistant to an object the net effect would be 0. So with that constraint in mind I doubt anything we can do at our current Kardashev scale can top Earths magnetic field. (Note the above is for a permanent magnet, it is possible that electromagnet would fare better. However given that magnetic force strength decays proportionally to distance squared, a magnet powerful enough to be effective would mess up real satellites too.
- aml183 6y agoHi Everyone. I am the co-founder of Payload. We are a free weekly newsletter covering the business and policy of space. We cover topics like this all the time in our writing. If you are interested, sign up here: https://www.payloadresearch.com/ https://www.payloadresearch.com/