4 ms·
What's wrong with the Leaf? Some people just want a car that goes from A to B rather than a to flex on the plebs in a musk-mobile, good as they are.
by mhh__ 6y ago
What's wrong with the Leaf? Some people just want a car that goes from A to B rather than a to flex on the plebs in a musk-mobile, good as they are.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoRange, battery longevity (older versions), lack of fast charge network and charge experience, no OTA software updates, no lane keeping (“autopilot”) on older versions. One can appreciate Tesla and not like Musk. Even as a Tesla investor, not a huge fan. I see him as a necessary evil. The cars sells, and that’s all that’s important.
- jackson1442 6y agoAlso, Leaf uses CHAdeMO to charge, which is neither as fast nor as common as CCS.
- mhh__ 6y agoNow find me a tesla for £7k like I can buy a leaf for used.
- Consultant32452 6y agoThe low price is an indicator of the low desirability.
- mhh__ 6y agoIt's sold 500k units which is more than most Tesla's have, it's a different product for a different market. Think again.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWho is more likely to be right? You and your cheap used car use case or sophisticated capital markets and the valuation they’ve assigned to Tesla based on future expectations? Tesla can’t build 3s and Ys fast enough to keep up with demand, and they’re $40k-$50k (roughly) vehicles.
- mhh__ 6y agoHave I touched a nerve? All I was saying is that Tesla's are very good but they're also expensive for a European market which is why the Leaf is a perfectly good EV for driving to the shops.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoNot at all. I’m simply pointing out that the market for new Tesla vehicles is enormous versus that for cheap used EVs of other brands.
- Consultant32452 6y agoWhat precisely should I think again about? If the VW was priced at the same level as a Tesla, do you believe it would generate the same sales?
- mhh__ 6y agoI have no idea what you're trying to say
- Consultant32452 6y agoWe're talking about whether or not price is a signal of desirability. You suggested a good point about the Leaf is the ability to buy a used one for $7k. I believe the way pricing works suggests that the Leaf has low desirability, because you can get one for so cheap. What you're implying appears to violate the law of demand, and I'm hoping you can explain what I'm missing.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhat you're missing is that the leaf is designed to be cheaper than a tesla. That's not hard to work out. A Bugatti veyron goes for a lot more than a specced out mercedes S-class because they're designed to be sold to different markets. The leaf's entertainment system, for example, does the job it's intended to do fine, the tesla one is designed to innovate. They are empirically desirable because they've sold half a million of them.
- ForHackernews 6y agoAs a software dev, "OTA software updates" on a vehicle I own sounds like a security nightmare / active anti-feature. I don't need my critical transportation bricked by a failed update, or removing functionality so they can charge me extra to re-enable it, or any of the other nonsense routinely seen from device makers.
- MisterTea 6y ago> no OTA software updates Feature. It's a car and software should be finished when it leaves the factory. Any other excuse is nonsense. > no lane keeping (“autopilot”) on older versions. That's your job and its called driving. If you cant handle that simple task then you should not be driving.
- gambiting 6y ago>>That's your job and its called driving. If you cant handle that simple task then you should not be driving. Ah, the "just suck it up and man up" argument. Lovely. I hope you drive a manual car with no power steering no power brakes and no abs. Heaven forbid the car helped you with the sacred art of driving, right?
- mhh__ 6y agoABS and power steering are a totally different kettle-of-fish to the car actually steering itself.
- gambiting 6y ago"if you can't turn the wheel by yourself you have no business in driving" /s It's just lane keeping. It helps immensely with focus on long trips.
- MisterTea 6y agoI've driven from NYC to FL and back a few times (Once in a Uhaul truck) in addition to NYC <-> Chicago. Never did I have trouble keeping lanes. If I did, it meant that I was tired or fatigued. As a responsible driver that means I pull off the road at a rest stop and rest. If you have trouble keeping lanes and are not fatigued then I suggest you put your fucking phone down or see a doctor. This new trend of passing responsibility to technology has got to stop. It's fueld by greed, built on human laziness and fostered by stupidity. People need to grow up and accept responsibility.
- codecamper 6y agonothing. And if you want to get some autopilot features you can install comma.ai.
- decafninja 6y agoThey look like cheap dwarf mutant hatchback economobiles similar to other (ICE) cars far lower in MSRP. One of Tesla's biggest achievements was that they produced an EV that actually looks like a cool, desireable, premium car. There are other EVs now that fit that description, but they are significantly more expensive than the Model3 and ModelY.
- lallysingh 6y agoUp until 2015 the leaf's max range was 84 miles. Teslas were never nearly that low: 220 (3 v1), 244 (roadster v1). 249 (S v1). The leaf now has 107 with it's biggest battery. Tesla's big bet on the supercharger network was the game changer. Before that, EVs we're only a 'second car' for commuting. With the SC network, an EV was parity with ICs, not a set of green/cost tradeoffs.