3 ms·
I think there’s some commingling in this argument. When an institution subscribed they are getting access to research done by _other_ institutions. Presumably
by mc32 6y ago
I think there’s some commingling in this argument. When an institution subscribed they are getting access to research done by _other_ institutions. Presumably they have their own records of their own research.
- 0xdde 6y agoThere isn't. He is pointing out that publicly funded research is then not freely available to the public.
- madhadron 6y agoNot really. Sure, you could go get the paper from the guy down the hall, but most universities don't have their own hub for publications that is accessible to their faculty.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoSo there's some value in a central hub, which I assume also costs money to set up and run?
- sooheon 6y agoWhich scihub provides. Journals are their own silos and require multiple exorbitant subscriptions.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoSci hub benefits from having journals enforce standards, have editors, reviewers, and a ton of value added that they didn't pay for. I like Sci Hub, but it didn't create a lot of the value it provides - it does that on the $ of a lot of other actors. Even arxiv was getting flooded with crap and had to do some gatekeeping. Sci hub gets a huge benefit from the publishing industry at keeping out a flood of crap and pseudo science nonsense that floods most places that don't have such a process.
- anigbrowl 6y agoJournals don't pay reviewers either, as has been explained above.
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>Journals don't pay reviewers either, Some do. And I am aware of that most don't, having published enough papers, reviewed papers, and been asked by journals to review for them. However, I never claimed reviewers were paid. I did state Sci Hub is getting benefits they didn't pay for, like keeping out crap, the value from being reviewed, uniform quality from known journals, etc. If I, having published academic papers, and in many cases keeping my own copyrights as I always try to negotiate that (and a surprising amount of journals will let you if you ask), want scihub to not publish my work, funded by me, and published by journals I selected, will they remove it? No? Then they are stealing the same as others. It's just their theft is popular since it lets people access stuff for free.
- madhadron 6y ago> I did state Sci Hub is getting benefits they didn't pay for, like keeping out crap, the value from being reviewed, uniform quality from known journals, etc. A few journal pay editors and reviewers, but the vast majority do not, so Sci-Hub is paying the same as anyone else. > will they remove it? Last time I checked, Sci-Hub doesn't host, it proxies, so your license to the journal to distribute the paper is still what applies. The journal has standing, but you don't. And the idea of uniform quality from known journals is laughable.
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>so Sci-Hub is paying the same as anyone else. You seem to be missing the point: Who is going to review for sci hub? Reviewers review for the journal the decide to - and that's based on the quality of a journal. I will review for a good journal. I won't for a bad one. Who would review for sci hub? I wouldn't, and I doubt many if any top researchers would either. Sci hub will accept the crappiest of stuff, so I (and pretty much anyone else doing solid reviews) would not bother. >Sci-Hub doesn't host, it proxies Did you check that or write it because you want to believe that? Sci hub pulls a copy to sci hub using stolen credentials when you ask for a copy. For example, here [1] is one of my papers that sci hub has copied and serves from their site. (not sure how long they cache copies, but it's not hard to see using chrome and viewing requests to tell where files come from). The paper even has a front page and watermarks added in 2016 from where it was downloaded from. So no, sci-hub didn't just proxy to the journal. [1] https://zero.sci-hub.do/5265/2478517301ba71ba89a837647f1a133a/lomont2002.pdf https://zero.sci-hub.do/5265/2478517301ba71ba89a837647f1a133...
- armoredkitten 6y agoSome, but not all, universities do have institutional repositories for their own work. But they are at best inconsistently used. Some academics also (when allowed by the licensing agreement of the journal) put their own research on a personal/lab website. But again, this is inconsistent, and really relies on secondary solutions like Google Scholar to be usable (unless you already know exactly which paper you're looking for and navigate directly to the author's website). The bottom line is that in most cases, academics rely on journals even for access to research from other folks in their own university. Things get passed around informally. And there are changing trends, such as preprint archives (like ArXiv), in some fields. But the majority of research is still paywalled. Edit: To return to your point, yes, I was sort of discussing some Platonic ideal of "The Taxpayer". Obviously, if you live in the US, your taxes don't pay for research in Europe (only for universities' access to that research). And we could be talking about federal taxes for federal grants, but state taxes for state-run schools. But in general, the point is that the journals make exorbitant profits from labour paid with public funds.