3 ms·
Unlike stocks the risk here is vastly larger than the reward. COVID vaccines aren’t believed to be indefinitely effective, so it’s very possible that less effe
by Retric 6y ago
Unlike stocks the risk here is vastly larger than the reward.
COVID vaccines aren’t believed to be indefinitely effective, so it’s very possible that less effective large scale vaccination effort would cycle through and fail to stop the spread long term. However, a sufficient vaccination effort could completely eliminate the disease globally.
- paulmd 6y agoOn what basis do you say that? Stocks could potentially involve you losing everything, and the "reward" of cutting the number of necessary doses in half is that we could potentially reach herd immunity much faster. Bear in mind that the expectation is only about 1.9 billion doses total will be produced in 2021 - so we are talking about the difference between maybe 1/3 or 1/2 of the first world being immunized, and hitting herd immunity this year. I'm not saying we should, the FDA is probably correct that we should follow the dosing schedule we know works rather than throwing away a whole year of vaccination efforts, but it's obviously desirable. (it's unfair but I'm sure that most of the doses are going to end up in the US, Europe, and other western-aligned countries first, then China and Southeast Asia, and the developing world is going to get the shit end of the stick, the developed world is going to hit herd immunity long before let's say India or Africa.)
- kingnothing 6y agoYou're not going to die from bad stock advice. You may die from COVID.
- cma 6y agoWhy don't we start playing options? Everyone gets a tenth of a dose so we can get it done next week. Just start a whole new study, made up of everyone.
- creddit 6y ago> COVID vaccines aren’t indefinitely effective Citation?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoWe don’t have specific data on covid, but it’s closely related to other diseases where immunity from contacting the disease tapered over time. The best estimate we can make on the vaccine is. "From what we know of the duration thus far of immunity, I would be surprised if it turns out to be a 20-year duration, but I would also be surprised if it was less than a year," We don’t have the capacity to make enough vaccines for global herd immunity in under a year. Which is why reduced long term efficiency is a significant concern over a faster rollout schedule.
- creddit 6y ago> We don’t have specific data on covid So you're making a super strong statement that's not very justifiable. > but it’s closely related to other diseases where immunity from contacting the disease tapered over time. I mean, maybe? Let me know when there's more then extremely minimal evidence of reinfection. We are at the point now where we are coming up on a year of significant spread and it's still missing. Additionally, have we ever seen an mRNA vaccine for a coronavirus? Nope. Evidence here is at best uncertain. > We don’t have the capacity to make enough vaccines for global herd immunity in under a year. Which is why reduced long term efficiency is a significant concern over a faster rollout schedule. Would we have enough if we split doses? Why does the US need global herd immunity?
- Retric 6y ago> So you’re making a super strong statement that’s not very justifiable We don’t think of each annual flu as it’s own disease, but they are caused by closely related strains not a single virus. Similarly, COVID-19 was originally named SARS-Cov-2 due to it’s close relationship with SARS-CoV also known as SARS. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/types.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/types.html Which is why the vaccine could both be developed so quickly in the first place and we can make reasonable predictions about the vaccine. They didn’t create a successful vaccine in under a week from scratch without a lot of knowledge of closely related diseases. It’s that same knowledge which is behind the dosing schedule, and why it was tested like that. > Why does the US need global herd immunity? Ending the vast social and economic harm from social distancing efforts. With local herd immunity things go back to normal even if the rest of the world is dealing with the disease. PS: The demographics of the developing world even support a staggered approach. First a focus on vaccinations for the elderly and medical workers globally then local herd immunity based on population demographics. Local herd immunity protects those who the vaccine can’t, but evenly spreading out vaccinations to the younger population accomplishes little.
- standardUser 6y agoVaccines generally do not eliminate a pathogen and they are not expected to eliminate this Coronavirus. Smallpox is the only human disease to ever be successfully eliminated.
- Retric 6y agoRelatively few vaccines exist, and even fewer old ones, but on the whole they have been quite effective. https://www.vaccines.gov/diseases https://www.vaccines.gov/diseases In total both Smallpox (human) and Rinderpest(cattle) have been eliminated in the wild. Seasonal flu is kind of an interesting case as each year is arguably a different disease with the old one having been eradicated. That’s hopefully a model which will work for covid-19. Polio is very close to being eliminated, with only 125 known cases in 2019, which was a spike. Rubella dropped from 670 thousand in 2000 to under 15 thousand in 2018. Ovine rinderpest elimination is considered a reasonable goal, but still 15+ years off.