4 ms·
My personal security metric is "how many bitcoins would I leave in a wallet app on this phone". Currently that number is about 1 ($30k) on an up to date androi
by londons_explore 6y ago
My personal security metric is "how many bitcoins would I leave in a wallet app on this phone".
Currently that number is about 1 ($30k) on an up to date android. I believe that if I had more bitcoins on a phone, and told people about it, there's a good chance a targeted exploit would steal those keys. Even if I had them encrypted, at some point I have to type a password in to decrypt, and that would be the point they'd be stolen.
However, on an iOS device (which is more robustly locked down), I'd probably happily store 10 bitcoins. (if I had them, hah!)
On dedicated hardware (like a trezor wallet), i'd also be confident up to about 10 bitcoins (far less attack surface, but also a less competent security team than Apple can afford).
On an outdated android, it would be more like 0.1 bitcoins - there are trivial ways to root them from the web browser and any old website can do it!
Considering that for many people, access to all the private data on their phone could ruin their job, relationships, and even put them in prison, I'm sure a lot of people value the security of their phone at multiple years salary. If I have to choose between that and the ability to run an emulated game slightly faster, I'm totally choosing security!
- shawnz 6y agoWhat is so wrong with Android that you trust it 10x less than iOS? What attacks are possible on Android that aren't possible on iOS? There are also trivial ways to root ancient iOS versions with a web browser, too. In fact, I think that technique was more common among iOS devices than it ever was among Android...
- londons_explore 6y agoA bunch of things that add up...: * Lack of things like w^x enforced across the OS. (the root of this post). * The quality of SoC and OEM provided drivers being very very poor - there are lots of kernel exploits to be found. * Very slow/no updates. Time from an exploit being reported to Google to it being patched by a typical user is usually 6 months or more. That means for any random device you find on the street, there is probably a viable exploit buyable on the black market. * Less strict review process on apps - means there is more dodgy code with access to /dev/exploitabledevice...
- shawnz 6y agoSome good points, although... > Lack of things like w^x enforced across the OS. (the root of this post). Are you sure iOS does this for the filesystem at all? I can't find any documentation besides some comments that they don't allow apps which exec other binaries in the app store. > The quality of SoC and OEM provided drivers being very very poor - there are lots of kernel exploits to be found. And how do we know about the quality of the proprietary code in iOS? There have been plenty of exploits found there too. > Very slow/no updates. Time from an exploit being reported to Google to it being patched by a typical user is usually 6 months or more. Where did you get this 6 month figure? Was that before or after the introduction of Project Treble, Project Mainline, the new security update system, etc? > Less strict review process on apps - means there is more dodgy code with access to /dev/exploitabledevice... Can't argue with you there. However I will say that even the weak points here aren't any worse than the state of the art for desktop PCs
- saagarjha 6y agoiOS apps on the App Store effectively cannot create W^X mappings.
- shawnz 6y agoSure, but the other poster seemed to be talking about software policy-based security measures with that point (like what Android is adding) and not just app store review restrictions.
- user-the-name 6y agoiOS enforces this in the memory manager.
- shawnz 6y agoThis change is regarding the filesystem though, not memory
- ufmace 6y agoYup this. I bought my device to do useful things on and store a bunch of personal private information. I'm a lot more concerned about keeping it working at 100% reliability and keeping all of that data as secure as I can than whether I can run some weird random hack on it for kicks.
- Daho0n 6y agoThere are more exploits on sale for iOS than Android. So if you had 10 bitcoins you invested them poorly and put them in the wrong phone.
- MrDresden 6y agoWell yes, I would consider any Android device family other than the Pixel / Nokia line a security hazard, with or without any bitcoins on it. Comparing a rushed Q4 market Samsung phone to an iPhone is simply comparing a brick and an orange. There are many problems with Android, but that the price for a zero day exploit on Android has become more valuable than one for iOS as far as 2019 [0] should tell you something about how a proper Android phone would fare in the comparison. Please leave the brick where it belongs. [0] https://www.wired.com/story/android-zero-day-more-than-ios-zerodium/ https://www.wired.com/story/android-zero-day-more-than-ios-z... p.s I would also just never leave bitcoin on my phone.
- zinekeller 6y ago> Android device family other than the Pixel / Nokia line a security hazard As someone who uses a HMD (Nokia) phone, please do not buy the models with Mediatek SoC in it when you are absolutely concerned with security. Apparently Mediatek is the one building the kernel of the device and not even HMD has knowledge on what modifications have been made (for example is DuraSpeed, which was an aggressive battery saver that ruined some apps, was enabled without permission and even HMD cannot disable it permanently). Qualcomm SoC devices are okay, but expect a slight delay (around a week or two especially if it was a device from a carrier) for updates.
- MrDresden 6y agoGenuinly interested in any more detail you have on this, any articles you know of?