4 ms·
The thing he's arguing against is the Chicago/Austrian school of economics, whose response to just about every monetary policy measure is "But inflation!" UBI w
by jfengel 6y ago
The thing he's arguing against is the Chicago/Austrian school of economics, whose response to just about every monetary policy measure is "But inflation!" UBI would cause inflation; raising the minimum wage would cause inflation; worker protections would cause inflation; government borrowing causes inflation.
That kind of economics gained popularity in the 1970s, when inflation caused genuine hardship. It left a kind of economic PTSD -- especially among people who have money, because inflation erodes the value of savings. The response is a trickle-down economics, where the best way to help the poor is to ensure that the rich have lots of money so that they can give poor people jobs.
So the Internet is full of "But inflation!" and often "But hyperinflation!", usually based on an argument from the first two weeks of economics class where you're shown supply and demand curves. But economics classes go past two weeks. There's a lot more to it than that, and the data simply don't support that argument. The fact is that consumer inflation is very low, and has been for a long time, despite intensive intervention from the central banks.
It is more complicated, and there has been inflation -- most notably in the stock market, and to a lesser degree in other assets (including real estate and cryptocurrency). The stock market has inflated to ludicrous levels, not just in tech assets but as a whole. But not at the consumer level, for a variety of reasons -- a lot of things have become cheaper to produce, and despite tax cuts for the wealthy wages haven't gone up. The wealthy don't eat more or live in more houses with that money, so they're not competing all that much for regular consumer goods. They take all that extra money and buy stocks -- trading them to each other rather than actually starting new businesses.
Anyway, that's what he's arguing against. It should shortcut a whole line of knee-jerk "but inflation!" arguments. But it's been true for decades, and this isn't a new observation, so it doesn't really change anything.
- caeril 6y ago> especially among people who have money, because inflation erodes the value of savings. What? Wealthy people don't buy CDs. They tend to invest heavily in assets. Often, these are leveraged assets like real estate or equities in a margin account. NOTHING makes the rich richer like inflation. Reducing the burden of low-interest mortgage or margin debt whilst boosting earnings in equities. Meanwhile, the poor still pay 20%+ on credit cards used to buy food that gets more expensive every year, and see annual rent increases from their landlord. There's a reason that CNBC cheerleaders absolutely love ZIRP, and it's not because it helps the downtrodden poor.
- jfengel 6y agoThis argument mostly comes from the upper-middle-class types who make Friedmanesque arguments on the Internet, who seem to focus on their eventual retirement moved into low-interest assets like bonds. They want to make the big risky investments, then stop the whole economic engine once they're safe. Actual Chicago economics arguments are much better than the ones you hear on the Internet. I think they're still pretty bad, but not as bad as the parodies based on first-half-of-the-first-semester Econ 101. HN in particular is often full of that kind of argument, because it attracts a demographic of exactly that top 20% who have lots of assets but enough in cash-equivalents -- or imagine they will some day real soon.
- ivanbakel 6y agoMy interpretation of the comment you're replying to is that "people with money" doesn't refer to the wealthy - who, as you point out, are typically asset-rich - but instead of a cash-rich, asset-poor middle class (or even anyone in the working class with some savings). Certainly if you're currently saving up to buy your first house in large parts of the West, inflation is your bogeyman - it threatens to simultaneously drive up house prices further and devalue your deposit.
- defertoreptar 6y ago> and despite tax cuts for the wealthy wages haven't gone up. Real median personal income went up almost 8% from the year before the tax cuts (2017) and 2019. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N
- jfengel 6y agoI'm referring to the long term policy of tax cuts, starting in the 1980s. The data set you link to has real median income (after inflation) going up by about 40% since 1975, under 1% per year. That's not zero, but compared to GDP, the stock market, and other measures of overall economic health -- which have gone up by an order of magnitude or more -- the median is practically immobile. And for much of that time, it was even more immobile. The median was $31k in 1997, and was $31k in 2014. It bottomed out at $30k in 2012; it has been rising since but that was almost two decades of complete stagnation -- while GDP rose and stock markets climbed.
- defertoreptar 6y agoHere is an image that plots the effective capital gains rate from the 1950s to recent years: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax_in_the_United_States#/media/File%3AFederal_Capital_Gains_Tax_Collections_1954-2009_history_chart.pdf https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_gains_tax_in_the_Uni... Let's analyze three periods: 1953-1985: no significant trend in effective capital gains tax 1985-1996: upward trend and higher capital gains tax 1996-2020: downward trend Now let's compare those periods to real median family income (which tracks to 1953). https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEFAINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEFAINUSA672N Annualized growth in real median income: 1953-1985: 1.8% 1985-1996: 0.8% 1996-2020: 2.0% Real median income growth during lower capital gains tax policy was twice that of the period of higher capital gains tax policy.
- dragonwriter 6y agoYour choice of a thirty-two year period, and 11 year period, and a 24 year period, when the unequal periods aren't supported by some kind of consistent in-period patterns in the conjectured independent variable, plus using fuzzy subjective descriptors for the independent variable, suggest a breathtaking degree of cherry picking and desired-results-driving-methodology, here.