5 ms·
A law is only good if it can be enforced. Technically piracy is illegal and yet pirated content exists and keeps being consumed because there's no way (for now)
by Nextgrid 6y ago
A law is only good if it can be enforced. Technically piracy is illegal and yet pirated content exists and keeps being consumed because there's no way (for now) to control what people run on their computers and even more so when there's a direct financial incentive which could even fund building dedicated hardware if general-purpose computers can no longer do the job.
- vkou 6y agoIt's as easy to enforce this law as it is to enforce laws that criminalize possession of bits - for example, child pornography. Which, by the way, get enforced all the time. The only reason piracy isn't enforced is because it's largely a civil, as opposed to a criminal matter, which constrains the tools available to copyright holders to go after pirates. Criminal investigations, in comparison, are not hamstrung the way that Warner Brothers going after someone downloading The Matrix is. You significantly overestimate the financial incentives for building special purpose hardware solely for the purpose of participating in a criminal economy. That would be trivial for the police to shut down, because hardware manufacturers have a very conspicuous physical presence. There's a reason nobody sells 'piracy-solutions-in-a-box'. It's because you need factories to build those, and you can't exactly own a factory in secret.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> There's a reason nobody sells 'piracy-solutions-in-a-box'. It's because you need factories to build those, and you can't exactly own a factory in secret. Piracy boxes are a thing. There are Android TV set top boxes loaded with all kinds of piracy software being sold at a premium, and they manage to do so without factories. Similarly, you don’t need a factory to build a Bitcoin wallet if (hypothetically) you can no longer use a general purpose computer for that - a microcontroller and hobbyist-level tooling is enough to build one.