5 ms·
To be fair to GH, I wouldn't trust them if their customer service could be convinced to unlock an account with neither email nor 2FA access. Passwords leak all
by jeroenhd 6y ago
To be fair to GH, I wouldn't trust them if their customer service could be convinced to unlock an account with neither email nor 2FA access. Passwords leak all the time (because people are bad at using unique passwords) and social engineering efforts are quite effective at hijacking high-value accounts in a great deal of companies, so while I sympathise with the loss of your account, your experience actually improves my opinion of GH's support.
- londons_explore 6y ago2FA should be bypassable after some longish lockout period. For example, someone has lost their password, email access, phone number, and 2FA app. Make them wait a month to regain account access. If any time during that month, the account is used or logged into, cancel the takeover request. During the month, every day send an email to all points of contact on the account letting them know what will happen. It's a trade-off of the harm of unauthorized access to a dormant account Vs blocking someone from accessing their data (that is probably not backed up, and probably took considerable effort to create). Have an account-level setting to disable such a process, for the people who might be offline for extended periods.
- qayxc 6y ago> 2FA should be bypassable after some longish lockout period. Nope. No backups, no sympathy, simple as that. 2FA is worthless if you start to put holes in it like that. So if you value your data, make backups - preferably locally the old-fashioned way, e.g. HDDs stored in at least two different locations or at least using several different cloud providers (which have their own infrastructure and aren't just relying on AWS/GCP/Azure/etc.). There's no such thing as a "trade-off" when it comes to cyber security - either commit to it fully or just don't use 2FA at all. Personally, I think 2FA that doesn't rely on physical devices (phones, keys, smart cards, etc.) is unreliable and sketchy anyways. If you can't spare a few hundred bucks on a NAS that you can just put in a storage unit or bank vault if need be, you data can't be that valuable anyway.
- fsflover 6y ago>> 2FA should be bypassable after some longish lockout period. > Nope. No backups, no sympathy, simple as that. My two sim-cards were lost at the same time. Impossible, right? Now I cannot access my Github account anymore. Perfect security. Nothing important is lost and backups are there. But what about the account itself?
- necovek 6y agoMost countries require SIM registration using a government issued ID document (including prepaid ones). Some providers offer ID registration even for prepaid SIMs. If you want privacy from your government too, don't use SIM-based (sms or call) 2fa. That's generally a suitable backup in my view.
- londons_explore 6y agoYet most countries allow foreign sims to roam into the country. That effectively defeats the benefits of requesting government id's, since the real criminals will just use foreign sims.
- qayxc 6y agoThat's a completely different scenario, though. Roaming is essential for the primary function of phones, whereas 2FA is not.
- necovek 6y agoSure, if you are using a SIM from a country that does not require ID registration. But we are talking about restoring access to your phone number. I don't really care about "a criminal" getting their account back on my service (well, unless I am SilkRoad or something). My point is that I am able to get a new SIM for the same phone number as long as I've registered my ID with the provider. I have even kept my phone number even though I had my phone stolen 3 times for the last 20 years or so. Thus, if any of my accounts rely on that phone number for 2fa, I am good.
- 6y ago
- zuzun 6y agoThey just turned 2FA on for all accounts and that was the moment I found out that mine was pointing to the wrong email address. I wish they would allow you to sign something with your private SSH key to get an inactive account back.
- smarx007 6y agoI think this is where I think having a scan of a passport and requiring a letter certified by a public notary would be a better approach.
- TimWolla 6y agoThey do: https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/authenticating-to-github/recovering-your-account-if-you-lose-your-2fa-credentials#authenticating-with-a-verified-device-ssh-token-or-personal-access-token https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/authe...