4 ms·
It is an interesting approach to physics and good luck to them. But the video isn't promising. The reason a physicist models a thing as a random variable is bec
by roenxi 6y ago
It is an interesting approach to physics and good luck to them. But the video isn't promising. The reason a physicist models a thing as a random variable is because they don't know of a way to distinguish the thing from a random variable.
Dr. Deutsch spent far too much time talking about the fact that at a high level there are a lot of things we are certain about. That is very weak evidence of what is happening at the quantum level. The important part isn't conceiving of something as deterministic. That is easy to do. Proving it experimentally will be the hard part.
There is nothing to report until there is an experiment that people can hold up saying "see! we found it! This part is deterministic not probabilistic!".
- scotty79 6y ago> Dr. Deutsch spent far too much time talking about the fact that at a high level there are a lot of things we are certain about. That is very weak evidence of what is happening at the quantum level. Especially given that sum of billion random variables is determined and pretty precise value.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoWell, one's horoscope is also a set of "determined and pretty precise" values but that's not to say that we have learned anything useful from looking at a person's horoscope, except from what can be informed by a belief that it influences a person's behaviour. That is to say, that the value of a variable can be precisely known doesn't say anything about the utility of knowing that value. Accordingly, the talk in the linked video is not arguing that the values of random variables cannot be determined with precision, rather that doing so is not sufficiently informative for the purposes of understanding physical reality.
- thingification 6y agoFrom memory of listening to this a few times some time ago (caveat: I certainly didn't study the content of this video carefully, but I do understand some significant context of his work as he sees it reasonably well I think): Deutsch here isn't trying to modify quantum mechanics, he's trying to "interpret" it. He wouldn't use the term "interpret" of course, for excellent and fascinating reasons that I can't quickly cram into an HN post, but you can find them in his book The Beginning of Infinity (I was convinced about this area of what he says in the book, not about everything else he says there -- there's a LOT of stuff in there!). By the way, I don't know whether or not you meant to imply that Deutsch is not a physicist, but he is -- and well known for his work on the fundamentals of quantum physics.
- thingification 6y ago> There is nothing to report until there is an experiment that people can hold up saying "see! we found it! This part is deterministic not probabilistic!". To add a bit more on top of my earlier comment: I believe Deutsch would point out that all experiments that have ever been done do corroborate the determinism of quantum phenomena. Experimental tests are only ever understood in terms of theory, and quantum theory, which Deutsch identifies with the many worlds "interpretation", says that the world evolves according to Schrodinger's equation. Other "interpretations" of quantum theory are actually rival theories that fall at the first hurdle of being worse theories. To Deutsch, a bad theory is one that is easy to vary -- in this case, for example, the "Copenhagen interpretation" says that QM -- i.e. Schrodinger's equation -- is true, except when you measure something -- and then it says that you're not allowed to ask what that means. Why not? You're just not, OK? This may sound like sophistry, but it isn't. Consider a closely analogous case: Denying that experimental tests of QM have corroborated that theory -- which is a deterministic theory -- is like saying that dinosaur bones are not evidence of dinosaurs because none of the experimental tests distinguish the theory that dinosaurs really existed from the one that says that God put the bones there: true, but that theory is ruled out because it's a bad explanation (easy to vary: why God, for example?).
- simiones 6y agoThe MWI doesn't really solve the measurement problem - it still doesn't explain in any way why two different detectors that according to the Scrodinger equation should both see the same amplitude for a particular particle at their location will never both detect the particle - only one of them will. However, we also know that the original particle can actually interact with two different particles at the two different locations. MWI can't actually explain this well-confirmed observation (and no, decoherence doesn't explain it - it just explains why macroscopic systems don't exhibit interference with themselves or with other macroscopic systems). At a more relevant practical level, there is no theory that can predict what value a quantum measurement will have beyond probabilities. This is an easily observable fact - and finding the way to perfectly predict the value of a quantum measurement would probably make QM inconsistent with special relativity for example.