3 ms·
> asking him to redact names without telling him which ones is even more stupid He should have had the good judgment to redact all names even without being ask
by pdonis 6y ago
> asking him to redact names without telling him which ones is even more stupid
He should have had the good judgment to redact all names even without being asked to. (Or at least all names that he didn't know belonged to people whose lives would not be put at risk by their publication.) He didn't.
> Newspapers were NOT in the same position.
It is true that newspapers (and other "mainstream" media organizations) have a special relationship with governments (and note that I'm not saying it's right that they do, only that as a matter of fact they do), so they aren't in exactly the same position as Wikileaks. That still does not excuse Wikileaks putting people's lives at risk by publishing their names.
> people exposing war criminals get more blame that actual war criminals
I haven't said anything at all about blame regarding anyone other than Assange, so you have no basis for even making any such comparison.
Also, I'm not blaming Assange for publishing the material itself. I'm blaming him for publishing people's names and putting their lives at risk. As I've already said, he could have published the material without publishing the names. He chose not to.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> He should have had the good judgment to redact all names So how exactly are you supposed to hold officials accountable if you don't have any names to go on? > I haven't said anything at all about blame regarding anyone other than Assange Right. That is exactly my problem. When we're talking about war criminals I'd hope the person who exposed it would be the last to get some blame in the matter.
- joshuamorton 6y agoLeave the names of officials. Redact names your don't know, as was already suggested. Newspapers seem to have managed to do this just fine for ages. If there issue is that high ranking officials aren't being held accountable, there's no reason to publish the names of some random agent.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> Leave the names of officials. Redact names your don't know That's not as easy as it sounds. Many of the names you'd want to leave up would be of smaller generals whom you may not be familiar with. The actual shooters should perhaps also not be redacted. At least not fully. > Newspapers seem to have managed to do this just fine for ages. They do this by being cozy with the Pentagon and asking them exactly for what WikiLeaks has asked them for. The difference is the Pentagon's not going to ignore an email from the NYT. It did ignore WikiLeaks.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> Many of the names you'd want to leave up would be of smaller generals whom you may not be familiar with Investigative journalism is a difficult profession. Yet people manage. Throwing your hands up is a disservice to the profession. Calling someone who does so a journalist is a disservice to actual investigative journalists.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoI did address this above but you ignored it.
- joshuamorton 6y agoYou didn't. Assange found that it was difficult to be a real journalist. Instead of attempting to be responsible and do the investigative work required to figure out names that might be worth publishing, he threw up his hands and published them all That's not investigative journalism. It's much closer to muckraking.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoI know, you'd consider the likes of NYT/WaPo to be 'real journalists'. The ones that had so cozy of a relationship with the Pentagon that they saw no problem in being government mouthpieces and getting the public to support a war in Iraq that killed 200k+ people on a made up pretense of WMDs. Same for Lybia, Syria etc.? Because that's how you get the level of government access to be what you'd consider a 'real' journalist. I am glad that you don't get to define who makes a 'real' journalist and who doesn't. Julian is not one of these[1] indeed. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Access_journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Access_journalism
- pdonis 6y ago> how exactly are you supposed to hold officials accountable if you don't have any names to go on? Manning could have told Assange which names were the names of US government officials. (In fact, I'd be surprised if Manning didn't actually do just that; on your own theory of who should be held accountable it would be irresponsible not to.)
- pdonis 6y ago> When we're talking about war criminals We're not. We're talking about Assange. He can still be at fault and worthy of blame for some things he did, even if the US government is also worthy of blame for some things it did.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> We're not. And that's exactly the problem. No wonder they're still free today while Julian's not.