3 ms·
It's not an argument against democracy, it's an argument for sensible government. It's a very, very bad idea to hold a referendum along the lines of "vote no f
by rsynnott 6y ago
It's not an argument against democracy, it's an argument for sensible government.
It's a very, very bad idea to hold a referendum along the lines of "vote no for the status quo, vote yes for, erm, something, we'll let the Yes side make up some stuff about unicorns and cricket playing vicars for you". The vote should have been for a realistic deal, with article 50 notification contingent on having agreed said deal in principle. People had _no_ idea what they were voting for, and that's entirely Cameron's government's fault.
That doesn't mean that referendums are necessarily bad in principle, though.
In Ireland we have quite a few of these, but generally the government will say what it intends to do with a Yes result. When people voted yes on the abortion referendum, say, they weren't just voting for "more abortions, please" in the abstract, they were told ahead of time what would happen if they did vote yes.
- dageshi 6y agoThe EU doesn't allow negotiation on withdrawal until article 50 is invoked. There was no ability to negotiate any deal of any kind until the UK confirmed it was leaving.
- jimnotgym 6y agoThe UK could have asked for several different deals and got them. EEA would have taken zero negotiation, for instance.
- dageshi 6y agoI don't believe there's any mechanism to go from full EU membership to the EEA when you're already a member? That is more or less the same thing as negotiating to leave before article 50 is invoked. I'm not entirely sure what you're referring too?
- samsonradu 6y agoWhy is it granted they would have gotten an EEA-like deal?
- jimnotgym 6y agoThe UK was already a member of the EEA, ok it was by virtue of it's EU membership in the end, but the UK was a founder member. If the UK had decided that it wanted to maintain it when it left the EU I can't imagine who would have objected?
- ben_w 6y agoFrom what people were saying at the time, the other EEA-but-not-EU members didn’t much like the idea of their group being dominated by the UK. I have no insight into how significant that concern would have been in practice, only that it reached the news.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ipqk 6y agoIf people are generally upset about state of things for possibly various different reasons, and you only give them one lever to pull to "fix it", they're going to pull that lever. And that's how you get Brexit.
- tomxor 6y agoI have heard people explain (in person) this as the reason they personally voted yes! I think this is one of the three major factors that got it anywhere near a 50/50 outcome: 1. Voting on something as vauge as can be, 2. lies and manipulation, 3. single lever problem
- petre 6y agoIt was Cameron bluffing and the lever was the nuclear option. If it went the other way, he'd probably have more leverage to negotiate. Well, surprise. Too bad. I already miss the poor buggers. If Scotland holds another referendum, they're pretty much screwed because Northern Ireland is going to be next. I hope Nigel is happy now.
- rsynnott 6y agoWell, also, Cameron would never have expected to be in a position to hold the referendum. He made it as an election promise in an election where pretty much no-one expected a Tory majority; at best they were expected to be part of a coalition. Then things changed, and here we are...
- ben_w 6y agoI’m not a constitutional expert so I don’t have high certainty in my own belief, but: Can Scotland actually do anything about it if Boris Johnson just stamped his foot and says “no you cannot have a referendum”?
- petre 6y agoThey certainly can and have also exercised this. The UK was part already in the EU when the Good Friday Agreement was signed. "In March 2017 the Scottish Parliament authorised the Scottish Government to seek to hold a proposed second Scottish independence referendum." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposed_second_Scottish_independence_referendum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposed_second_Scottish_indep... "The agreement reached was that Northern Ireland was part of the United Kingdom, and would remain so until a majority of the people both of Northern Ireland and of the Republic of Ireland wished otherwise. Should that happen, then the British and Irish governments are under "a binding obligation" to implement that choice." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Friday_Agreement#Status_of_Northern_Ireland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Friday_Agreement#Status_o...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]