4 ms·
The biggest surprise was when he alluded to the fact that when going through a corner you have to change differential settings three times ... I imagine just ta
by Swizec 16y ago
The biggest surprise was when he alluded to the fact that when going through a corner you have to change differential settings three times ... I imagine just taking a corner at those speeds would be hard enough, let alone playing around with buttons while doing it.
- bruce511 16y agoI didn't interpret it like that. I think that while they may fiddle for balance (for example as the fuel burns off, and the weight comes down, or as the tyres wear etc), I'm not sure they change it for each corner. He mentioned there was a setting for "high speed" corners so I think it's a case of getting the optimum setup for a lap, and then running with that for a while. While there are a lot of switches, it's noticable that the ones they'd want to use a lot, like the KERS, are very close to the fingers in their normal position, whereas the ones which are more "setup" or "fiddle" are closer to the centre of the wheel. I don't think they go through a corner with one hand on the wheel and the other adjusting something in the middle of the steering wheel. Still I suppose when the xBox "F1 Controller" of "tomorrow" comes out, we'll all find out. (Alas without the G-Forces...)
- CWuestefeld 16y agowhile they may fiddle for balance (for example as the fuel burns off, and the weight comes down, or as the tyres wear etc), I'm not sure they change it for each corner. Actually, the setup of the car is not active at all, except for brake bias (which is set via a mechanical lever on the cockpit wall). There is no way to change ride height, stiffness, etc., dynamically. About 20 years ago there was a period in which everything about the cars were dynamic (culminating in the Williams FW-14B [1]). The ride height and other suspension settings, etc., were all under electronic control, so that the setup could be altered for every corner. And thanks to bidirectional telemetry, these settings were actually controlled remotely from the pits without the driver needing to intervene. However, the arms race of complexity and cost led teams to agree to a ban on this technology. It's a bit of a shame, because the engineering had become every bit as interesting as the racing itself. [1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Williams_FW14 https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Williams_FW14
- bmj 16y agoThis is typically the case in most types of auto racing. In some cases (the WRC comes to mind), it was pushing manufacturers out of the sport because they couldn't keep up with the costs.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIn some cases (the WRC comes to mind), it was pushing manufacturers out of the sport because they couldn't keep up with the costs. Not that I disagree with your point, but there's another factor in WRC: Sebastian Loeb. If sponsors want to be associated with winning teams, then there's really no point in sponsoring any team besides Citroen. There's very little chance of anyone other than Loeb winning the championship, and good luck waiting for a podium that he's not standing on. I think you can see this (albeit less clearly) after late 80s F1. A McLaren team-up of Senna and Prost delivered the best two drivers, plus Honda and McLaren's engineering skill; there was little opportunity for anyone else to compete. The result was a decade of competitive wasteland as the sport recovered (giving such lame drivers as, imho, Damon Hill, an opportunity to win a World Driving Championship). It wasn't until a combination of Schumacher's skill and Ferrari resurgence that things got at all interesting again.
- eftpotrm 16y agoSort of, but I'm not sure I'd quite agree with your history. Prost and Senna were alone toe-to-toe for 3 years, 1988-90. Senna wasn't a realistic threat before then (neither was Prost in '87), while '86-87 the dominant battle was between Mansell and Piquet at Williams. But, yes, 1988-90, Senna and Prost carved things up between them. After that... 1991, Ferrari (Prost's team) were nowhere, there was a late season challenge to Senna from Mansell's Williams but they'd had too much early season unreliability 1992, Ferrari were worse than nowhere, McLaren were comprehensively trounced too. Mansell walked it for Williams 1993, Prost wins relatively comfortably from Senna with a major car advantage. 1994, Prost retires and Senna dies. There were then: * 2 years of Benetton & Schumacher * 2 years of Williams, Hill then Villeneuve * 2 years of McLaren & Hakkinen and we're now a) out of the 10 year window and b) into the Schumacher & Ferrari juggernaut. Now, I've heard a number of expert commentators suggest that Schumacher's record is flattered by the opposition he faced, I wouldn't disagree that Hakkinen, Hill and in particular Villeneuve are perhaps not the strongest champions F1 ever saw and I'm not sure this period of F1 was necessarily the most competitive. BUT - I definitely don't agree with your characterisation of F1 history there.
- PedroCandeias 16y agoI don't think that's how it works. The driver is setting three different aspects of the car, which come into play at different stages of a corner. He sets all three of them well before a corner, and then focuses on braking, shifting, steering and throttling. Most onboard footage I watched seems to confirm this.
- lloeki 16y agoIndeed that's the case. But then you may ask why don't he set it up once for the track and be with it? The track would have to be wildly disparate to need a periodic change at certain points in a lap. Such tweaks are mostly to cope more efficiently with varying situations: for example you don't take the same line when you're basically alone or when you want to overtake, which you precisely do at corner entrance or exit - since such cars are not wildly different in power from one another - and that's something the driver plans in advance of actually doing it.
- eftpotrm 16y agoMonaco, compare the Grand Hotel hairpin with the tunnel; very different performance characteristics and diff requirements, I'd suspect. Silverstone, look at the Becketts complex and compare it to Luffield. Spa Francorchamps, compare the requirements of Eau Rouge with La Source. That's just three straight off the top of my head. Circuits are pretty varied; I don't know for sure that they are doing that with diff settings as they lap but anecdotally they alter brake bias pretty regularly so it wouldn't surprise me particularly.
- lloeki 16y agoWhich is precisely what I meant by 'disparate' :) There can be long-winded corners, and then a tight chicane in another area. A different diff setting would allow to maximize stability vs agility by balancing (forward+braking) power on left/right wheels.
- escoz 16y agoRemember that they're fighting for hundreds, sometimes thousands of a second, in laps that usually take 90-100 seconds. Anything that can be done to improve things ever slightly, even if it means having to do extra work for some of the corners, is worth it. During the race, when they have the video from above the cockpit you can clearly see the drivers changing configuration all the time during the race.
- bborud 16y agono, he was talking about there being three different settings for the three different phases of the corner. during friday and saturday sessions they will gather data to find optimum diff settings for the different corners. then during the race all three settings will be controled by a single knob. you can sometimes see drivers fiddle with the diff knob during in-car shots in the race. (you also sometimes see them letting go of the wheel with one hand to adjust the brake bias setting -- which for some reason is often not on the wheel)