4 ms·
The problem to tackle, IMO, is medical privacy and intellectual property. We've created a system where the only sane way for a biomedical company to behave is
by cogman10 6y ago
The problem to tackle, IMO, is medical privacy and intellectual property.
We've created a system where the only sane way for a biomedical company to behave is to patent, copyright, and hide as much medical information as possible. Further, we've made it REALLY hard to share such medical data in the first place.
Now, I get WHY we do this. There are a lot of good reasons (privacy and insurance issues come to the top of my mind). However, we should be working to eliminate those reasons as much as possible.
What we need to advance human understanding of medicine is a national database of medical data that's publicly available.
Ideally, We'd record every measurable aspect about a person in this database and update it throughout their lives (when did they get vaccinated? What allergies do they have? Did they get any cancers?)
That sort of a database would make it really easy to start mining for treatments, correlations, etc. It'd even have some positive benefits like removing the need for every doctors visit giving you a form with 50000 questions you've answered a million times before.
But I get why we don't do this. We don't do this for fear of police overly relying on genetic information to "prove" someone committed a crime (We found your DNA at the scene, you must be guilty). We don't do this out of fear of Insurance companies exploding their rates when any sort of marker comes up (Oh, you've got Gene XYZ that means you'll probably die sooner, so you get a higher rate or we won't insure you). We don't do this because of issues around discrimination (Oh, you have (had?) HIV? You must be gay and we hate gay people here).
But, man, do I wish we could somehow shape society so some day we could do it. It'd have the potential for so much good.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoNice post, but what does that have to do with the Human Genome Project?
- tejtm 6y agoThe GP post highlights a "blocker" on where to go with the Human Genome Project ... integrating existing traditional data and "personalized medicine" i.e your genome at the scale of global statistical significance v.s entrenched interests and a history of bad behaviour by a few bad apples. fantastic rewards, fantastic risks, inevitable whether you work on it or not.
- tejtm 6y agoa glimmer. https://ncats.nih.gov/n3c/about https://ncats.nih.gov/n3c/about As an optimist I like to think that this could be a wedge in a crack Covid exposed in our (US) collective medical/insurance dis-function. With dissimilar records harmonized across many institutions under the same roof and levels of access to the datasets for partners who did not "provide" records to the pool (you) we are testing the theory, my hope is before Covid is over the genie is out of the bottle and cant be stuffed back in for the profit of a few at the expense of many. But you folks reading this who are able to apply disparate strategies to reasoning over large complicated data sets... PLEASE DO !!!