3 ms·
Has that ever been tested in court? That someone can sign away their first amendment rights?
by MichaelZuo 6y ago
Has that ever been tested in court? That someone can sign away their first amendment rights?
- allan_s 6y agoIsn't that the same than a doctor signing away his right to divulgate his parent information (or a lawyer), or even more mundane, for a tech guy to publish the source code of his company ? (it's an actual question)
- mLuby 6y agoControversially, courts have upheld that citizens can sign away their right to a trial by jury; it's called binding arbitration. Also normal (non-government) NDAs let you sign away your right not to be punished for speaking about certain matters. I don't like it, but it's pretty well established. Point is that—legally speaking—rights aren't actually inalienable.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoIf constitutional rights can be signed away with the stroke of a pen since they are alienable... then a lot of absurdities become possible, such as someone selling themselves into slavery and so on. Do you know the prominent cases of the examples you mentioned?
- ibejoeb 6y ago> citizens can sign away their right to a trial by jury; it's called binding arbitration You can contract with another private entity to resolve disputes via arbitration, yes, but not with the state. The closest thing might be a plea agreement, but that happens after an indictment. You still have the right to a trial, but you may forego it if you choose. I suppose if you're saying that a security clearance is like an NDA with the state, it's a reasonable comparison in function, but the means of prosecution is entirely different. It's like saying that everyone could be subject to UCMJ because of conscription.