4 ms·
My point was not that selling was the only way to achieve freedom and security, merely that it was the optimal way. (That was the thesis of the essay in fact:
by pg 18y ago
My point was not that selling was the only way to achieve freedom
and security, merely that it was the optimal way. (That was the
thesis of the essay in fact: that selling a company and living off
its revenues aren't opposing strategies, but rather that the former is the optimal case of the latter.)
I don't see how anyone could argue that selling was not optimal for
security. Sure, you could gradually save money, but that's not
optimal; it's not more secure than getting a lump sum upfront.
Whether selling is the optimal way for most founders to work on
what interests them most is a fuzzier question, because it depends
on the likelihood that the average founder's startup is the most
interesting thing he could be working on. (Not just interesting;
the most interesting.)
You can't prove this, only offer arguments of various strengths.
The strongest abstract one is similar to Occam's Razor: that a
choice that has to satisfy two independent constraints is unlikely
to be the optimal choice for either alone. Specifically, that you
can probably do better on the dimension of interestingness if you
don't also have to satisfy the constraint of making lots of money.
I'm surprised people find this idea controversial. It seems to
pervade almost everyone's choices from the moment they enter the
workforce. I.e. if you want to make more money, you often have to
compromise on the type of work you do, and if you want to work on
what you love, you often have to make financial sacrifices.
There may be a few statistical outliers who escape this force (a few top athletes, for a few years each) but for everyone else it's as
pervasive as gravity.
- pchristensen 18y agoI think you're talking about an exit and DHH is talking about choosing what kind of business to start. If someone offers to buy you, your chance of a liquidity event is 100%. But if you're still deciding what kind of business or startup strategy to use, that chance is more like 50%, 10%, or even 1% or less. Given those odds that any normal entrepreneur (not you or DHH) faces, he says it's smart to build for profit and take the safer money, rather than go all or nothing.
- sethg 18y agoSo it's a minimax strategy. Or maximin. Or...sheesh, one of these days I oughtta learn game theory.
- Harj 18y agohe says it's smart to build for profit and take the safer money, rather than go all or nothing. the point is that the two don't have to be mutually exclusive. they may well be if you're building a consumer web app without any monetization strategy but not for e.g. an ad network - something that needs to make money from the start and can also be bought out eventually.
- condor 18y ago"I don't see how anyone could argue that selling was not optimal for security. Sure, you could gradually save money, but that's not optimal; it's not more secure than getting a lump sum upfront." That's a pretty bold statement. If you think that an offer on the table is greater than all the net income you're comfortable your company will generate (discounted to present value of course), then you would take the money and run. If on the other hand your company is creating value (net income), and you are confident it will be creating more value (net income) going forward so that the discounted future net income the company generates is way more than the upfront lump sum, you wouldn't sell and it wouldn't be more secure or optimal. I think the issue is that most 'startup' owners aren't focusing on the net income part so they don't view their company as a cashflow generating entity which can be rationally valued against an upfront lumpsum, which means they'll take the money and run just about everytime; why wouldn't they? I'm sure 37signals could have sold their company right after launching basecamp in 2004 for a multiple of revenues at the time, guessing a couple of million dollars. However, for some reason that wasn't optimal for their security, and by 2007 (doubling revenues every year since 04) chances are they've earned/pocketed the value they could have sold the company for in 04 (if not a majority of that value) and they get to keep that cashflow generating machine going forward (which means more cashflow + more valuable equity).
- craigbellot 18y agoIn the case of 37signals and their product line, there's no fuzziness that they are most interested in their business. They say 'NO' to all but a few of their customer requests and implement the ideas THEY want to implement, WHEN they want to implement them. Pg says make something people want and will find useful, while DHH says make something you will find useful and stick to your intuition. I think 37signals and their manifesto make them much happier than trying to please others.
- abstractwater 18y agoI don't think pg and 37s have different ideas about this. They are both very focused on the user. If 37s says no to many customer requests, it's because they think it's best for the user, nothing else. When DHH says "solve your own problems" it's only because he thinks that if you do have a problem, it's very possible other people have the same problem. Hence, you are "making something people want".
- biohacker42 18y agoI keep thinking there is a risk dimension here. Build for profit and the worst case scenario is, you have to wait to save enough to have financial independence. Build to flip and worst case is bust, start again. One strategy is lower risk then the other, pick the one you like best. But DHH does make a good point about the special scenario when your startup is indeed the most interesting thing you'll ever work on. Then after you flip it and decide retirement is not for you, you've already sold your best idea. I think that's a rare scenario, there's not much risk of "losing" the idea of your life. Then again, there's not much chance that any particular startup will be sold.
- MaysonL 18y agoNo, build for profit, and worst case is: you make a profit for a while, and then spend the next couple of decades treading water, slowly going broke.
- dhbradshaw 18y agoSometimes I wonder if a life filled with adventure and engagement might not be bigger and more interesting than one filled with security and freedom.