3 ms·
> If a person asks a computer for a "week number 23 of 2021", the only sensible solution in any culture I think would be to use the ISO system. No, because it
by masklinn 6y ago
> If a person asks a computer for a "week number 23 of 2021", the only sensible solution in any culture I think would be to use the ISO system.
No, because it wouldn't match american the expectations of people not using ISO calendars, despite and regardless of weeknumbers not being routinely used by them.
It is an argument that maybe weeknumbers should not be a thing / available in all locales, but not that they should be renumbered to match an other locale, regardless of that other locale making more sense.
- vesinisa 6y agoBut ... haven't we established that the en-US locale week numbering system is not really based on anything sensible. So how the user can have any sensible expectation of what they get as a reply when they ask for a week number? I tried to research the glibc version control history of how it came to be like this. I think it's completely arbitrary, and at times en-US did use ISO 8601 weeks.