3 ms·
TPP was a brutally anti-Chinese trade agreement - it forged privileged trading status with all of China's main rivals and China would only be allowed to join la
by legitster 6y ago
TPP was a brutally anti-Chinese trade agreement - it forged privileged trading status with all of China's main rivals and China would only be allowed to join later if they shaped up.
The US opted to drop it and unsuccessfully deal with the Chinese party 1:1 in negotiations. Imagine if a business partner was robbing you, and instead of finding other partners, you tried to negotiate with them. Obviously, they hold all the cards and have no incentive to play along. If anything, they would want to steal more! They would get more leverage!
I don't know if the TPP would have been a silver bullet, but it's hard to imagine the CCP would be this brazen if they were on the outside looking to come in. Remember that actions in Hong Kong and Xi Jinping's lifetime appointment all happened after the TPP was killed. I think they are power grabbing as much as they can now while no one is really holding them to task.
- legolas2412 6y agoI think even Bernie was against TPP, not just Trump. The situation could be similar to the idea that you gave unfair terms to a business partner and felt robbed. So you found other business partners and signed the same terms with them, basically to spite/limit the original business partner. But now you are still being robbed, even faster infact, and by multiple people, and no way of recourse, as you just signed that deal!
- blaser-waffle 6y ago> I think even Bernie was against TPP, not just Trump. It didn't do much for US workers, just protected Intellectual Property. TPP means you can't outsource it to China, but you can absolutely outsource it to Malaysia, Vietnam, etc. as long as they respect the IP. Mixed feelings. It has no real benefit for US workers, but, at the same time, the damage is done and US manufacturing isn't going to magically reappear. Might as well at least try to lock down the IP and force Asia (read: China) to play by the rules.
- legitster 6y agoExcept China is able to maintain very favorable trading conditions through currency manipulation. If you can get them to stop doing that, there would be a non-zero amount of jobs that get returned to the US.