7 ms·
We’re Google Workers, and We Are Forming a Union
- gcr 6y agoSo many of the hard problems in software engineering come down to organizing people and empowering them to do what is right. This is a huge step forward for workers in the industry. It takes an expert to write great code, but it takes a hacker to organize entire groups of people. These folks are hackers in every sense. Bravo!
- knighthack 6y ago> ...it takes a hacker to organize entire groups of people. These folks are hackers in every sense. I think we may have a very different definition of the word "hacker". Yours is very likely incorrect.
- spaceribs 6y agoSocial engineering (in the social sciences definition) is the hacking of bureaucracy, full stop.
- getlawgdon 6y agoSocial engineering is the hacking of bureaucracy? No. No it is not. Full stop.
- dandellion 6y agoRight, and planters the hacking of farming, and sandwiches are the hacking of gastronomy, full stop.
- larsbrinkhoff 6y agoIf you are Tom Knight, I'll defer to your definition.
- jensgk 6y agoEver heard of “life hacks”?
- eeZah7Ux 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_ethic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_ethic
- psaintlaurent 6y agoI have an ugly truth for Google employees, unions don't mean anything, in NYC if you are in a union or married to a union employee you will eventually become a victim of targeted harassment campaigns by people with connections to government when they want you out of your job or spending money. Almost all unions or stable jobs have people who believe they "control" the jobs. They will attempt to destroy you and your family any way possible. I've personally been the victim of targeted harassment campaigns. I was punched in the face in broad daylight on the way to work. Someone vandalized my home, stole every valuable item I own and threatened my daughters life. My car was damaged and the mechanics wouldn't fix it properly because they were afraid of retaliation. My wife's car was repeatedly vandalized to get her spending money on a mechanic and then eventually force her to buy another car. Someone even hit me with an electronic weapon while I was sleeping and burned me, I still don't know how the fuck someone got hold of an electronic weapon. The entire point of these harassment campaigns is to force you to spend money on luxury garbage, mechanics, car dealers, house cleaning services. etc. If you contact the authorities for help, no one is going to help you out of fear of retaliation. They give you lip service even if you have video evidence (I have actual audio, video and image evidence all of this happened) I had an actual conversation with someone last night who drove past my house asking why the police were at my home: Me: "Someone left a threatening letter on my door." Person: "If you just purchase enough from us we can call up our friends and get you help otherwise there is always cancer."
- KirillPanov 6y agoYou might want to lay off the drugs, son.
- psaintlaurent 6y agoNo psychiatrist necessary (PROOF): https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/1329514173387190280 https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/132951417338719028... https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/1342449048750583808 https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/134244904875058380... https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/1328834960799756289 https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/132883496079975628... https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/1312119983074279424 https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/131211998307427942... https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/1258894804538339329/video/1 https://twitter.com/psaintlaurent0/status/125889480453833932...
- polote 6y agodupe : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25630011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25630011
- pacificat0r 6y agoCould someone help me understand what an union could do vs the abuses presented as examples in the article? In my limited experience, from my parents(not US) unions are mostly some sort of barganing power for salaries in various industries but stop at that. For example, could a union stop the payout of that high-level exec that was eventually shown the door for harrasment with a good bonus? After that, they are also mostly like various subscriptions that you forget you have, as memberships require pay. In this beautiful part of the world you would even sometimes pressured to pay and join as if you're not a union member can have consequences that are unwanted.
- pydry 6y ago>In this beautiful part of the world you would even sometimes pressured to pay and join as if you're not a union member can have consequences that are unwanted. This is to address the free rider problem inherent in unions. How do you ensure workers who get the benefits also share in the costs/work - especially when management are trying to encourage free riders? Pretty much all free rider problems are dealt with with the group pressuring the free rider in some way.
- MisterTea 6y ago> For example, could a union stop the payout of that high-level exec that was eventually shown the door for harrasment with a good bonus? No. Unions protect workers, not the business. > In this beautiful part of the world you would even sometimes pressured to pay and join as if you're not a union member can have consequences that are unwanted. Are you a citizen of your nation and do you pay taxes? Just as a nation protects its citizens in exchange for taxes, a union protects its members in exchange for dues. Everyone has to participate for the system to reasonably work.
- johannes1234321 6y ago> No. Unions protect workers, not the business. To protect the workers, they also have to protect the jobs, which means they have to also protect the company. Finding the right balance there is tough and one of the greatest challenges.
- choeger 6y agoFrom the article i don't quite see if this is a worker's union or a group of people with certain ideological claims they want to enforce. The comment about the AI researcher that was allegedly fired for being "critical" hints at the latter. While a union that represents workers interests is a good thing, I think it would be dangerous to give even a part of google to people with ideological fervor. If, for instance, this group actually wants to and succeeds in turning google into a tool of the cancel culture, things will get ugly soon. Now that leaves me wondering if it is wise to leave this comment here... edit: Just an example from the mission statement: > We will prioritize the needs of the worst off. Neutrality never helps the victim. What this means is, not all google workers will be treated equally by this union. "Victims", i.e., persons will be ordered by their "oppression status" and gain preferential treatment. Now it will probably be fun to watch the details in this valuation process (e.g., "is a woman more victim than a black (disabled) male?"), but this inherent categorization of human beings into more and less worth is ugly as hell.
- runawaybottle 6y agoI think it’s fine if it starts off ideologically. A union is only as good as the total membership count. Get everyone in with whatever pretense, then you have bargaining power.
- choeger 6y agoThat's a very risky proposition. From what I can tell from the outside, many "progressives" throw equality and freedom out of the window when it comes to voting. By the tone of that article, I would not even be surprised if white males don't get to vote in that union or are excluded from influential positions.
- runawaybottle 6y agoThink of the long game. Getting a union is the hard part. The ideological fervor will change with seasons, but the core issues will remain the same across decades (the stuff workers want to be able to negotiate). Nothing is free, some price must be paid. Nothing pisses off a company more than workers organizing, so take whatever help you can get.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoTiming is perfect, Google reputation is in taters and US + a gazillion states are suing them.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat's taters precious?
- logicchains 6y agoIt means potatoes; their reputation is covered in potatoes.
- therealdrag0 6y agoTheir reputation has been boiled, mashed, stuck in a stew.
- Grazester 6y agoYou mean big tech's reputation is in tartars? Facebook and Amazon are no better and Apple's reputation should absolutely be down in the gutter but people jump aboard their privacy nonsense and turn a blind eye to all the forced labour they use. I do wish Google all the best however. They have handled their very privileged workers very poorly and may pay for it.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoit's tatters not tartars. Tartars are a Turkish ethnic group.
- Wintamute 6y agoThis reads more as an ideologically motivated pressure group, than a traditional trade union. I have a feeling that unions are most successful when they focus on non-divisive universal issues affecting the broadest section of workers possible, rather than culture war talking points.
- ur-whale 6y agoI'm hearing that since the COVID, many Google workers are being deprived of their 3 free meals a day and access to the gym, being forced to WFH. Clearly unacceptable, time to unionize to get things back to a more righteous state. /s
- p0nce 6y ago> working at Alphabet is no longer a choice they can make in good conscience. Sorry to say so, but it has always been a moral failure to work in the surveillance industry.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoAs history has shown us, mass organization prevents evil /s
- finnthehuman 6y ago>Organized workers at the company forced executives to drop Project Maven, the company’s artificial-intelligence program with the Pentagon, and Project Dragonfly, its plan to launch a censored search engine in China. It's expected but annoying that they'd advertise this. We've already seen that googlers' voiced ethics aren't humanitarian, just against the things bad enough to make them personally uncomfortable. And a union is explicitly for the benefit of it's members, not humanity writ large. They're going to continue happily building the world's largest private surveillance system. The most honest googlers I know are the ones that will admit they're just there for the money and have real issues with google's dealings. I doubt we'll get that level of candor from their union. The union will be for everything that makes money but doesn't get google bad publicity (just like google itself).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]