4 ms·
>sign up/sign in Why were clear terms like login/register/logout replaced with a “sign ...”? I get confused twice a week by these, especially because the diffe
by wruza 6y ago
>sign up/sign in
Why were clear terms like login/register/logout replaced with a “sign ...”? I get confused twice a week by these, especially because the difference between “in” and “up” is so subtle (and overloaded, like “sign up for a meeting at friday”, unrelated to registration routine). Sorry for offtopic, but it is really annoying. Is it more linguistically correct or just a hipster thing?
- samb1729 6y agoI'm not sure they were ever replaced; the terms co-exist. I believe the terms all stem from the general concept of writing a name on a piece of paper. To "register" your interest in an something, you might sign a piece of paper, or instruct a person to "sign [you] up". To show that you entered a physical event, you would sign an entry log on a piece of paper, then having "logged in" or "signed in", and then do the opposite on your way out. Similarly you might refer to reproducing your physical signature as having "authenticated" yourself, if there's something to compare it to. What makes one particular set of terms the right set given the apparent origins?
- gjvnq 6y agoI usually prefer the terms "sign up" and "log in" as they are different enough to avoid confusion.
- codingclaws 6y agoI researched this several years ago and for various reasons it's best to use: sign up, log in, and log out.
- appleflaxen 6y agocan you elaborate on the basis for this? it sounds interesting, but the rationale isn't obvious.
- jjoonathan 6y ago> "sign ..." Sometimes literally that, with an ellipsis hiding the part that would otherwise distinguish between alternatives, so you just have to click and guess.
- combatentropy 6y agoInteresting. I've always liked "sign up", "sign in", and "sign out", because they were older and more widely used before computing. "Sign up" was used to refer to subscribing, for example, to a magazine. "Sign in" and "sign out" were what they said for the guestbook at a hotel.
- Izkata 6y ago> like “sign up for a meeting at friday”, unrelated to registration routine Are you not registering yourself for the single meeting? Adding yourself to the list?