3 ms·
I have no doubt that math teaching methods in the US are terrible, in general. And I am very open to the possibility that Singapore does it much better. But h
by jessriedel 16y ago
I have no doubt that math teaching methods in the US are terrible, in general. And I am very open to the possibility that Singapore does it much better. But however poor Singapore was in the past, it is now 3rd in the world in per-capita PPP GDP while the US is 7th (according to the IMF; $56,522 vs. $47,284).
Furthermore we should always expect the top countries to be small ones; if each state in the US (pop. ~300m) was considered individually, it seems very likely that several would be more highly ranked than Singapore (pop. ~5m). Seeing as that those states are much more alike to the rest of the US--in terms of culture, government, etc.--than is Singapore, shouldn't we be looking to them for guidance on how to improve the rest of the US?
- snippyhollow 16y agoActually, if you read http://pirls.bc.edu/timss2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.pdf http://pirls.bc.edu/timss2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.pdf , Massachusetts and Minnesota are also benchmarked independently, Massachusetts is #4 globally (page 4 of the pdf, 34 of the document). Also, the level is slowly increasing in the US and slowly decreasing in Singapore. Finally, a lot of countries are missing in these rankings, so these are not true global results.