3 ms·
When I mentally diff Clojure against other JVM-based Lisps -- mainly thinking of Kawa and ABCL here, which are dialects of long-established Lisps -- Clojure com
by bitwize 6y ago
When I mentally diff Clojure against other JVM-based Lisps -- mainly thinking of Kawa and ABCL here, which are dialects of long-established Lisps -- Clojure comes up different enough to be weird, but not sufficiently better than the alternatives for me to put up with the weirdness and choose it over them.
It's kind of like when I recently evaluated Visual Studio Code (for the (1+ n)th time) to use as my default editor. Everybody I know at work uses it, and for a couple years there Hackernews made a collective O-face every time a new version dropped from Microsoft. So it must be good, right? Well, it was different enough from Emacs to force me to get used to an entirely different workflow, but not enough better than Emacs (really, for my purposes, not better at all) to justify making that enormous transition. So back to Emacs I trudge. A reasonable person may make the same call about transitioning from Visual Studio Code to Emacs when they hear advocacy from Emacs users like me.
That's where Clojure is for me -- in this limbo of it sounds good but it's not really worth it for me, personally, to switch. Plus its community has a strong contingent of douchey advocates -- not quite at the level of say, Rust or Newlisp but getting up there -- who act like Rich Hickey was God's gift to programming and make me think "So that's what Smug Lisp Weenies sound like to the rest of the world." And that further cements me in the realm of "hard pass" w.r.t. Clojure. Call it an irrational, emotion-based response.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thom 6y agoTo be honest I don’t really believe any programming language is that big of a boost in the real world, outside of certain hard requirements for correctness or performance. Ironically if I were to want to make another 10-20 year bet on a language it would be Rust so perhaps I’m drawn to douchebaggery, but I’m sorry that’s your experience of Clojure.
- kamaal 6y ago>>not enough better than Emacs (really, for my purposes, not better at all) to justify making that enormous transition. So tell us what your workflow is, so that everyone can benefit from it. It doesn't do much good in just saying Its magic, trust me and then leave it there.
- thom 6y agoEmacs is slightly painful to use on Windows just because I don't want to have WSL2 just for an agreeable set of Unix tools, so I have tried to fall in love with VSCode for the times I find myself there and not in Linux. It is good, and will probably and deservedly dominate developer mindshare for a generation. That said, there are a lot of fundamental differences that might be painful for someone transitioning from Emacs. First obviously is just keybindings, there are great packages to handle most of the basics but like with any new editor it's a faff to get everything right over time. Second is that is has lots of special cases of windows, which are hard to manage. In Emacs everything is the same, just a buffer. Your shell, your database client, your code, all buffers. You decide how all this is laid out and have absolute control. The same navigation, manipulation and search functionality exists everywhere. When you get an autocompletion of some text, it works the same everywhere, and the same navigation and search functions work in those menus. In VSCode, you have some text editor windows, but also tab groups which behave subtly differently, and then the panel and sidebar which are both different. I don't know how to 100% stop these things popping up, and the terminal seems like the only one available, so they're a regular annoyance to someone who is used to owning every character of screen real estate. Extension developers don't create extensions from the point of view that users want to consume textual information like everything else. It's not bad or wrong, it's just that Emacs works at a lower level of abstraction. It would be entirely valid to point out that VSCode's level of abstraction enables a more vibrant extension ecosystem. Third is that there are modes in Emacs that are much more mature than VSCode. Calva for Clojure REPLs is pretty weak compared to CIDER in Emacs. All the git modes are inferior to Magit, even the direct clones of Magit (which are good and tastefully done). All of these are very actively developed and will get better, they're just not there yet. Overall Emacs has fewer primitives, but they apply everywhere to everything, and I find that a much more humane environment for the kind of work I do (it's why it's a nice environment for a Lisp, which has the same philosophy to code).
- mbrodersen 6y ago> who act like Rich Hickey was God's gift to programming This is a typical cult pattern: the “esteemed leader” who is godlike perfect and can do no wrong. Having said that, in all fairness, Rich Hickey is a great presenter and I learned a lot about functional programming from watching his talks. I completely disagree with him on types but still learned a lot.