3 ms·
I don't think there is a coordinated takedown; after all, ranting about it on HN wouldn't affect anything if advertising actually worked as designed and had the
by Nextgrid 6y ago
I don't think there is a coordinated takedown; after all, ranting about it on HN wouldn't affect anything if advertising actually worked as designed and had the intended effect.
The problem is that first off, people rightfully dislike advertising so it's expected for them to rant about it, second, regulation is being worked on (whether the GDPR, CCPA, or similar) that would thwart targeted advertising, so advertising is now also facing pressure from the government and not just from people ranting about it, and third, these articles talk about brands themselves having doubts about the effectiveness of their advertising efforts and the media rightfully reports on it.
Ranting about ads by itself won't change much, but in this case it seems some advertisers themselves are having doubts as to how effective it really is and both the media and HN is reacting to that.
> Google derives 80% of its revenue from ads, Facebook 99%. Imagine these giants coming down if it turns out that online ads aren't effective?
Just because Google and Facebook are able to make a profit off their ads doesn't mean that their ads are actually good value and not overpriced, nor that the people in charge of assessing the ROI of these ads are incentivized to look into it (which is the point I'm arguing in the thread you linked). You can very well agree that online ads are effective but still aren't worth what they are currently priced at.