5 ms·
>to Its Gladiator-Era Glory Or "infamy". Between gladiator and slave fights to death, executions, and martyrs, it's not more glorious than a concentration camp
by coldtea 6y ago
>to Its Gladiator-Era Glory
Or "infamy". Between gladiator and slave fights to death, executions, and martyrs, it's not more glorious than a concentration camp would be...
- hankchinaski 6y agosupposedly Glory is intended as the magnificence that originally had for people at the time
- ericmay 6y agoWe tend to have different standards for the ancients. For better or worse. Look at structures such as the Great Wall of China, which according to Wikipedia[1] estimates say hundreds of thousands, up to a million perished during the construction. I’ve never been, but I doubt there is a lot of “wow we were so awful for building this” going on in the tourists centers. Maybe I’m wrong. Potentially the Cultural Revolution had that impact. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_of_China
- csomar 6y agoA wall is a really different thing. I guess China (at that time) did the math that the wall construction was going to cost a million life; but a wall was going to save them all from the enemy. So it made sense and actually saved lives.
- retrac 6y agoIn reality, when the enemy finally did cross the wall (multiple times), they just killed the elites, moved into their palaces, and then took over the ever-so-burdensome task of administering the canals... and collecting the taxes.
- jonny_eh 6y agoMore: http://blog.tutorming.com/expats/was-the-great-wall-china-effective-did-it-work http://blog.tutorming.com/expats/was-the-great-wall-china-ef...
- ardit33 6y agoyou also fail to mention that the mongols did mass slaughtering of the entire population of cities that resisted. It was genocide at mass, even children and women were not spared. Also, their raids will conflict massive damage to local populations (pillaging, plundering and rape). So, yeah..... you make it like it was some kind of 'chivalrous' game between nobles/elites, while it was not at all.
- retrac 6y agoNothing that didn't happen during Chinese civil wars. My intended point was quite the opposite. The nobles were playing a game, a brutal one -- and the peasants were the pawns.
- mr_toad 6y agoTrue, but that didn’t make them any less dead. Some estimates put casualties from Mongol invasions as as high as 60 million people. They certainly did kill millions, not just the elites.
- coldtea 6y ago>they just killed the elites, moved into their palaces, and then took over the ever-so-burdensome task of administering the canals... and collecting the taxes. Locals didn't see it as merely "replacing some elite with another" any more than the Nazi Germany winning the war and establishing someone as the "President of the US" would be seen as that. Sure, in the end life goes on, but there are many aspects that change, and domestic versus invading elites are seldom the same... That's if we exclude the mass slaughters at the time, or the treatment of local ethnicities as second class citizens...
- coldtea 6y ago>I’ve never been, but I doubt there is a lot of “wow we were so awful for building this” going on in the tourists centers. Well, the weren't awful to begin with. Whether succesful or not in the end, they built it to avoid Mongol and Manchu raids and invasions, and thus for saving their cities and their lives. So, people perished are more like "people perished in acts of fortification / defense preparations" than "people killed willy nilly for the entertainment of the emperor and the viewers in the arena".
- morsch 6y agoI'm sure many people died building the Great Wall, but the reference for "up to a million" is two travel guides[1], and the reference to "hundreds of thousands" is a throwaway line in pop science book about the Great Wall, whose author gives no evidence on how she arrived at the number. I couldn't find any scholarly articles. Maybe we just don't know how many workers died? Or maybe a search in Chinese would be more fruitful. It seems like something that there would at least be a scholarly agreement on an estimated range. This doesn't take away from your larger point, which stands regardless of whether ten thousand or a hundred thousand or a million died. [1] I think I'll remove those two references from the article, the revision is currently https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Great_Wall_of_China&oldid=998050290 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Great_Wall_of_Chi...
- BurningFrog 6y agoThe Great Wall wasn't some monument to a vain ruler. It was part of the war effort against invading Mongolians. People die fighting wars.
- eplanit 6y agoI think society has come full circle. You've just named 3 new genres of future reality TV shows.
- MichaelMoser123 6y agohttps://www.warriorsandlegends.com/gladiators/the-life-expectancy-of-a-gladiator/ https://www.warriorsandlegends.com/gladiators/the-life-expec... ; they fought 2-3 times a year and would die around age thirty; now that would be the average life expectancy at that time. And you could buy your own freedom after three years. (on the other hand they can't be sure if the average age of thirty for gladiators is correct) Now you would have it much worse if you were a slave at a silver mine, that would have been the worst fate for a slave - it would be a certain death sentence. Also slaves in a city were much better off in general than slaves working on farms.
- Jtsummers 6y ago> they fought 2-3 times a year and would die around age 30; now that would be the average life expectancy at that time. And you could buy your own freedom after three years. That's life expectancy with high infant mortality included. Life expectancy for those who made it to age 10 was around 50.
- ineedasername 6y agowould die around age 30; now that would be the average life expectancy at that time Not really: Numbers like that are low because high levels of infant mortality brought the average down. If you lived past that age, going into your 50's was pretty much the norm. So the gladiators were still dying 20+ years before "normal"
- MichaelMoser123 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demography_of_the_Roman_Empire#Mortality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demography_of_the_Roman_Empire... that's correct, though there might have been regional differences. I don't know if these figures were the same throughout the entire roman empire.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoWell, the gladiator numbers are skewed too because of the high mortality of their profession for guys in their 20’s. If they lived long enough to be free, they likely had a normal lifespan.
- WalterBright 6y agoMany (most?) of the gladiators were free men, looking to increase their wealth and status by being a successful gladiator. Gladiators rarely fought to the death.